STATEMENT BY THE MINISTRY FOR JUSTICE AND HOME AFFAIRS
PR0135
28/01/2009
| Counter-statement regarding list of Maltese | persons nominated for Judge on the ECHR |
| Government refers to a statement published by | the Opposition earlier today regarding the list of Maltese persons nominated for Judge on the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR). |
| The European Convention on Human Rights in its | Article 21, Criteria for Office, says in (1) that judges “shall be of high moral character and must either possess the qualifications required for appointment to high judicial office or be jurisconsults of recognised competence.” |
| In its first list in 2004 the Maltese government | submitted the names of: judge Giovanni Bonello himself, the Hon. Joseph Filletti and the Hon. Joe David Camilleri. |
| In 2006 the government issued a public call for | applications for the post of judge. From among the applicants, it chose the three most qualified and experienced in human rights and constitutional law, namely, the three judges of the constitutional court, the Hon. Vincent Degaetano, the Hon. Joseph Filletti and the Hon. Joe David Camilleri. |
| The Assembly did not consider the list because | it did not include a woman. |
| At the request of Malta, the Committee of | Ministers of the Council of Europe asked for an advisory opinion of the European Court of Human Rights. The latter in its judgement of 12 February 2008 fully supported Malta’s position. Paragraph 54 states as follows: |
| “In any event it is clear that, in not allowing | any exceptions to the rule that the under-represented sex must be represented, the current practise of the Parliamentary Assembly is not compatible with the Convention: where a contracting Party has taken all necessary and appropriate steps with a view to ensuring that the list contains a candidate of the under-represented sex, but without success, and especially where it has followed the Assembly’s recommendations advocating an open and transparent procedure involving a call for candidatures, the Assembly may not reject the list in question on the sole ground that no such candidate features on it.” |
| The Maltese government has not recieved any | communication from the ECHR suggesting any revision of the decision quoted above. |
Other Press Releases:
PR261985
STQARRIJA MILL-UFFIĊĊJU TAD-DEPUTAT PRIM MINISTRU U MINISTERU GĦAS-SAĦĦA U ...
PR261984