Speech by the Hon. Tonio Fenech, Minister of Finance, the Economy and Investment at the National conference on Credit and Financial Crisis – St Julian’s - 29 April 2009
Distinguished Guests, Ladies and Gentlemen, Good morning
I would like to thank the organizers of this conference for inviting me here today and giving me the opportunity to share with you the Government’s assessment of these challenging times, the response measures we are taking and the opportunities that can emerge for us even in these troublesome times.
The prolonged international financial crisis and its negative impact on the world economy are still creating a global environment characterised by higher unemployment, lower demand for goods and services and recessionary pressures. Whether we like or not, we are part of this bleak wider economic picture and any policy decisions have to be taken within this international dimension in mind.
The shroud of the global turmoil and heightened uncertainty has placed an overriding responsibility on Governments to give priority to addressing the challenges faced by their respective economies, safeguard jobs whilst doing so without jeopardising the economy’s sustainability.
In doing so we must also endeavour to sustain our economies in a manner that does not weaken our social foundations.
There is no shortage of analyses of what went wrong in the world's capital market over the past eighteen months. But what is clear is that it was no one thing but a rather complex set of relationships, interactions, events, and omissions on the part of many different actors, be they regulators, supervisors, operators, institutions, investors and also Governments.
Regardless of who is to blame, what is certain, at least in my view, is that the crisis could have been avoided were it not for lack of proper risk management processes within institutions; too many incentive arrangements and remuneration schemes within companies that reward short-term rather than sustainable results; and poor systems of governance that do not seem to provide adequately for challenging management’s strategies and risk taking attitude, and yes where regulators have not imposed more rigorous rules of engagement, rules that today we all agree need to spearhead a new international financial framework.
I will not use this opportunity that I have to speak to you today to take you over the causes of the crisis; I would rather focus on measures that Government has in store in safeguarding employment, restoring consumer confidence and maintaining trust in the local economy. But first allow me to home in for a few minutes on two issues which are in my view of direct relevance to today’s discussions.
The first is the extent, or perhaps I should say ‘limited extent’, to which the crisis has hit the local economy. I think you probably agree that the effects of the crisis on the local economy were contained, not only in terms of affects such as corporate failures and unemployment levels, but also in terms of the number of industries being impacted negatively by the crisis.
Whilst the impact of our financial system, where mostly in terms of market right downs on in investments, whether held by financial institutions or private investors, this has not impacted the stability of our financial system and any of our financial institutions. Whilst profit within the banking sector are down our domestic banking system is still very strong characterized by a capital adequacy ratio which is well above the statutory minimum, a strong liquidity ratio, a prudent loan-to-deposit ratio, well diversified portfolios, and non-performing loans on a downward trend.
I must however emphasis that the two main sectors that are being mostly effected by the global economic downturn in our case is manufacturing and the tourism sector. This is mainly due to our industry’s dependence on exports (whether products or services) because of the size of our economy and their dependence on foreign generated demand.
On the manufacturing front, the Government has specifically set up a task force that is working in close collaboration with industry players particularly hit in these time of crises, to identify ways in not merely safeguarding jobs but also to identify new investment opportunities that would not only increase our manufacturing capacity but also prepare our manufacturing base to respond more quickly and positive to a future upward trend in demand, which at some point in the present cycle will come.
The major catalyst of the global (and I stress the word ‘global’) crisis was however the financial system in developed countries. We heard of commercial banks’ excessive lending to sub-prime high risk lenders. Stories of investment banks valuing worthless portfolios have also raised eyebrows and questions have caused uncertainty and on the integrity of the financial system. Abuse of accounting standards to keep off balance sheet loss making assets and significant obligations had also become the order of the day. I am however pleased to note that local financial institutions steered away from such measures, thus maintaining the integrity of our financial system and minimising the contagion effect that larger economies suffered tremendously from.
But we must not take our eyes off the ball. We must hold on to our values, business ethics and sound corporate governance principles. While I am sure that the regulators in the relevant areas are doing their utmost in safeguarding the public interest, market players should nonetheless harness principles that go beyond rules-based measures.
Speaking of safeguarding the public interest, I cannot but say a few words on what challenges the accountancy profession is facing and what the profession should be doing in that regard. Just like everyone else who wants to be part of the future solution, on a global level the profession must start with a careful examination of the standards and methods in use and the strengths and weaknesses of what the international standard setting institutions produced for the global economy. This includes such things as:
· Are we using the correct standards, and is their application consistent and fair?
· Are the results of fair-value accounting as reliable as they should be?
On a local level, we have sought to address some of these issues through the introduction of the General Accounting Principles for Small Enterprises. This was the result of a two-year long process which started well before the turmoil started hitting the world’s capital markets. However this new framework will also have its role to play in combating the crisis from a local point of view. I see GAPSE as contributing to this on three main fronts. First, GAPSE will eliminate volatility in reported earnings through the optional consistent use of the cost model. As you know, a number of international financial reporting standards require the use of fair value for certain assets and liabilities.
One might argue that fair value, even in “normal” (pre-crisis) times, always has an element of subjectivity and is not always easy and straightforward to determine. Let alone in the circumstances which the world is living through nowadays. An essential feature when determining fair value is an active market which is functioning as it should be. Today, unfortunately, markets are not only inactive but are at times extremely volatile. The cost option allowed immunes local entities from these unpleasant circumstances.
I conclude on this point by thanking the Accountancy Board, the Malta Institute of Accountants and the MFSA for their invaluable contribution in making GAPSE the robust standalone accounting framework that we have today.
You will note that, so far, I have been very positive in my thoughts on the local scenario. This does not come out of surrealism; on the contrary, it is an acknowledgement of the efforts made to limit the harm that the crisis might have caused to the local economy and I thank all those who have been involved, in one way or the other, in supporting our efforts. As a Government we are still very attentive and considerate of the occurrences in the global economy.
Allow me to spend a few minutes going through these measures let me take just two highlight our efforts on manufacturing and tourism.
We have acted in those areas and on those levels where we can make a difference. Take the manufacturing industry. Unlike Germany, a subsidy on car purchases would not have affected the European car market and thus car-part producing local companies that had gone on a four-day week would not have benefited at all. Instead, we have intervened on the micro level, and through the Economic Stability Task Force we have been meeting companies individually to understand their needs and concerns; meetings that have yielded positive results, such as the one announced last Monday, when another company, Dedicated Micros, has reverted back to a five-day week.
Like Dedicated-Micros we have assisted Trellaborg, Methode, and Stainless Steel, who together employ over 2,000 employees. Within the support framework these companies have not only reverted back to normal working levels but also and committed themselves to new investment commitments to the tune of Euro 10 million.
Tourism then, is a different story, and here, we are have adopted a multi-level policy. We appreciate that tourism worldwide has suffered a significant downturn during this crisis; yet many people around the world are still traveling and that is why we have significantly increased our marketing budget; that is why Air Malta is now operating all its 12 planes on routes leaving and coming to Malta, while also adding numerous other flights such as to Verona, Stuttgart and Paris Charles De Gaulle. But we also need to cater for the needs of the individual hotel or restaurant in providing better value for money – hence, a moratorium on loan repayments and subsidies for refurbishments and extensions. These incentives have been added over and above a significant budget allocated last November to improve product Malta more than ever.
Ladies and Gentleman,
This economic and financial crisis is of historical proportions. We have acted at the micro and macro levels, we are strengthening our regulatory framework, we have avoided new taxes (unlike other countries) and we have continued to work on our reputation and attractiveness, with positive outcome such as the G20 and OECD published white list where Malta’s tax and banking practices were placed at par with those of the USA and the UK. We want to use the opportunity provided by this situation to ensure that we come out of this stronger and better than before. With everyone’s effort, I am confident that this is indeed possible.
After years of hard work in achieving our targets, and here I refer to EU membership and the adoption of the Euro, we need to appreciate not only the stability and yes allow me to say it the shelter these have offered us in these unprecedented times of crises, but also realise the opportunities these are offering, through market excess, currency stability and funding to meet the present challenges and determine new opportunities.
Thank You.
DOI – 30.04.2009
Stqarrijiet Oħra:
PR261985
STQARRIJA MILL-UFFIĊĊJU TAD-DEPUTAT PRIM MINISTRU U MINISTERU GĦAS-SAĦĦA U ...
PR261984