Left arrow Mur Lura

Ministerial Statement by Prime Minister Dr Lawrence Gonzi regarding the  immigrants who were rescued by the M/V Pinar-E  off Lampedusa

PR0640E
Date Icon 20/04/2009
House ofRepresentatives, Valletta, Malta
20 April2009

Mr Speaker, 

I feel that Ihave the duty to report to this House the developments that have taken place since last Thursday, when 154 immigrants were taken on board the ship MV Pinar E from two boats which were 41 nautical miles from Lampedusa, and 114 nautical miles to the South West of Malta. I am doing this not only to assure the House that the Maltese Government adopted the correct moral, ethical and legal position, but also to assure the House that this incident has in no way affected the diplomatic relations between Malta and Italy, which relations are still as strong as ever.
I shall begin bypresenting the facts as they occurred -
On Thursday 16April 2009, at 05.10 in the morning,  the Operations Centre of the Armed Forces of Malta (Rescue Co-ordination Centre) was informed by the Italian Maritime Rescue Coordination Centre of Rome that a number of illegal immigrants were on a small boat drifting 45 nautical miles away from Lampedusa. The Malta Rescue Co-ordination Centre acted immediately upon this information. Through the Vessel Traffic Management System the ship MV PINAR E was identified as the vessel at that time closest to the location where the incident was reported, and therefore directed this ship to help this group of people as necessary.
It is worthstressing that as from the very first moment, Malta honoured its primary obligation as per international law, meaning the obligation to co-ordinate search and rescue operations in the area technically known as the Search and Rescue Area for which we are responsible.
The shipMV PINAR E, which is Turkish owned and Panaman registered, was on its way to Sfax in Tunisia. When the ship arrived at the location it had been directed to, it confirmed that there were about 70 people on board the boat, and also that they required assistance.
At about noon,the MV PINAR E  reported that there was another boat, with about  80 immigrants on board, which was also approaching them.  It transpired that the two boats were following the MV PINAR E.
When one of themstopped, probably due to lack of fuel, the Malta Rescue Co-ordination Centre ta’ Malta intervened and reminded the master of the  MV PINAR E that according to international law, if the immigrants were in danger, the merchant ship was obliged to offer the necessary assistance and to take the rescued people to the closest port.
It is anirrefutable fact that the closest port in this case was Lampedusa.
It is also a factthat reports in certain elements of the international media to the effect that the boats were in Maltese territorial waters were totally incorrect, as on the contrary, the rescue took place 114 nautical miles far from Malta.
At16.58 hours, the MV PINAR E, a merchant ship, took on board the immigrants from the two boats. The ship also took on board a corpse which was floating next to one of the immigrant boats.
According to thePINAR’s captain, there were 154 people rescued, amongst whom there was a pregnant woman, 25 injured people, of whom 7 required urgent medical treatment. There were also some cases of fractures. All of them needed food and water.
The Italianauthorities informed the Malta Rescue Co-ordination Centre that they did not have any available assets in the area which could render the required assistance, and therefore the Rome Maritime Rescue Coordination Centre informed the Malta Rescue Co-ordination Centre that the rescued immigrants had to be taken to Malta since "this event is developing in your SRR, and Lampedusa isn't a safety place, the MV PINAR E must head to Malta where the migrants will be recovered".
A short whilelater, the Italian authorities gave instructions to the MV PINAR E not to enter their territorial waters, meaning twelve nautical miles out of Lampedusa. The captain of the ship insisted that they had on board injured immigrants who were in a bad way, and asked the Italian authorities for medical supplies. At one moment, the Italian authorities instructed the ship to continue on its way to its original destination -  Sfax in Tunisia. Then the Italian Maritime Rescue Coordination Centre instructed the ship to sail to Malta.
In the meantime,an Italian naval vessel was also dispatched to the area to ensure that the MV PINAR E would not enter Italian territorial waters.
In order tohonour his international obligations, the captain of the MV PINAR E informed the Italian authorities that he was still going to sail to Lampedusa insisting that the people he had rescued required help.  The Italian authorities maintained their position that the MV PINAR E was not authorised to enter Italian waters, and directed this merchant vessel to a position 24 nautical miles south west of Lampedusa.
On Friday,17 April 2009, an Italian helicopter landed an Italian doctor on the ship to evaluate the situation. Between Friday 17 and Sunday 19 April, Italian medical staff went on board the vessel to give the required treatment.  A 15 year old girl, and two other persons were taken to a medical centre in Lampedusa, while Italian ships supplied the MV PINAR E with food and water for the immigrants and the crew.  In the meantime, the ship had anchored 17 miles to the South of Lampedusa.
The MaltaRescue Co-ordination Centre ta’ Malta continued to exert pressure on the Italian Maritime Rescue Coordination Centre in Rome in order to allow the rescued people to disembark in Lampedusa; however no authorisation for the ship to enter Italian waters was forthcoming.
The situationstayed like this with no change in developments till yesterday afternoon, I spoke with Italian Prime Minister Silvio Berlusconi.
In this telephonecall, I explained the facts as I was aware of them, and explained how the Maltese Government had acted according to its international obligations, and according to what had been done for the past decades. I have to highlight the fact that Premier Berlusconi listened to what I said with attention. We then both agreed to keep the excellent relations between our two countries and indeed to continue to improve them.
Later that samenight, at 23.00 the Italian Maritime Rescue Coordination Centre in Rome informed the Malta Rescue Co-ordination Centre that the rescued people were going to be transferred to Italian patrol boats for disembarkation in Italian ports.
I also have toadd that earlier today in the afternoon, I also spoke with the President of the European Commission, Jose Manuel Barroso and in brief explained to him these facts I have just presented to the House.

Mr Speaker, 

As i have alreadystated, in this case, Malta adhered to its obligations under international law. I feel it would be appropriate for me to give a brief explanation of these obligations, in order to have this explanation officially recorded in this House.
Our obligation isto co-ordinate rescue activities in the Search and Rescue Area for which we are responsible. These all arise out of the following instruments of international law -

a.           The United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea, Article 98 reads thus -

Duty to render assistance 

“1. Every State shall requirethe master of a ship flying its flag, in so far as he can do so without serious danger to the ship, the crew or the passengers:
(a) to render assistance toany person found at sea in danger of being lost;
(b) to proceed with allpossible speed to the rescue of persons in distress, if informed of their need of  assistance, in so far as such action may reasonably be expected of him;
(c) after a collision, torender assistance to the other ship, its crew and its passengers and, where possible, to inform the other ship of the name of his own ship, its port of registry and the nearest port at which it will call.
2. Every coastal State shallpromote the establishment, operation and maintenance of an adequate and effective search and rescue service regarding safety on and over the sea and, where circumstances so require, by way of mutual regional arrangements cooperate with neighbouring States for this purpose.”

b.            The Hamburg Search and Rescue Convention (1979) which is the convention which regulates rescue operations. In fact the signatories to this convention are pledged to try and reach agreement on rescue co-ordination.

c.            The provisions of the Hamburg Convention are reflected in the International Aeronautical and Maritime Search and Rescue (IAMSAR) Manual of the International Maritime Organisation and of the International Civil Aviation Organisation.  Here it is clearly stated that the “the purpose of having an SRR is to clearly define who has primary responsibility for coordinating responses to distress situations in every area of the world”. 

d.             Malta is also a member of the Safety of Life at Sea Convention.  Here also we are obliged to make arrangements for rescue in our region.   

These al show clearly that our obligation is to co-ordinate rescue operations in our search area we are responsible for.  

Mr Speaker, 

I would like tofinish this statement with two final points:
The first is thatthe Maltese Government has always observed and will keep on observing its international obligations. We have always maintained this position, and when faced with this situation, we shouldered our responsibilities as we were in duty bound to. It is worth reminding that a number of illegal immigrants have ended up in our country because our Armed Forces brought them here because that is what our international obligations dictate. That is why I, in my country’s name,  rightfully expect that other countries honour their international obligations as we have always done.
Here I would liketo thank the Armed Forces and the other forces of law and order for their work and dedication.
My second pointis that we must never forget that we are talking about a human tragedy. There is at stake human dignity and the lives of people, a life which we are proud to defend in all its stages.
It is this beliefthat should guide us in every step we make and every decision we take. These are the values which will help us continue striving in all international fora for greater support in the challenge our country is facing in the form of illegal immigration.
The reality isthat our country alone cannot guarantee all this. While we must do our share, we also help and support from those who can afford to give more.
That is what we have done, and that is what weshall continue to do.

DOI – 21.04.2009

Ixxerja din l-istqarrija Icon socials Icon socials Icon socials Icon socials

Stqarrijiet Oħra:

STQARRIJA MILL-UFFIĊĊJU TAD-DEPUTAT PRIM MINISTRU U MINISTERU GĦAS-SAĦĦA U MILL-MINISTERU GĦALL-POLITIKA SOĊJALI U L-FAMILJA   Aktar għarfien dwar is-saħħa mentali fost it-tfal

PR261985

STQARRIJA MILL-UFFIĊĊJU TAD-DEPUTAT PRIM MINISTRU U MINISTERU GĦAS-SAĦĦA U ...

STQARRIJA MILL-UFFIĊĊJU TAL-PRIM MINISTRU  Il-Prim Ministru Robert Abela jippresjedi l-iffirmar ta’ tliet ftehimiet kollettivi għal madwar 1,700 ħaddiem

PR261984

STQARRIJA MILL-UFFIĊĊJU TAL-PRIM MINISTRU Il-Prim Ministru Robert Abela ji...

Aktar Stqarrijiet Right arrow