Left arrow Mur Lura

STATEMENT BY THE MINISTRY FOR SOCIAL POLICY

PR0591
Date Icon 07/04/2009
Clarification by the Ministry forSocial Policy on the issue of recognition of port workers
Various reports have appeared inthe media on the issue of the recognition of port workers. There have been a number of inaccuracies and gross departures from the truth and it is important to clarify the position of the Department of Industrial and Employment Relations and Registrar of Trade Unions on this issue.
Firstly it must be stressed thatit is the employer, and only the employer, who awards recognition to one or more unions, or refuses such recognition, as the employees’ representatives. The Director of Industrial and Employment Relations or the Registrar of Trade Unions have no say in this matter.
In an effort to facilitate theprocess and avoid needless disputes, the Registrar of Trade Unions, whenever so requested by the employer, carries out a verification exercise to help guide an employer reach an informed decision on the award of recognition. This is done by virtue of the powers of the Registrar in terms of the Employment and Industrial Relations Act.
The only certain manner toascertain whether an employee is a member of a trade union or not is by direct interview. This system has been in place for every verification carried out last year. Indeed 18 such verifications were performed last year involving various unions including the GWU. Indeed in a particular exercise held last year, 3 unions were involved with 2 of them being the GWU and MDU.
After making the necessarylogistical arrangements with the employer in consultation with the union/s involved, the verification exercise involves having public officers representing the Registrar asking participating employees 2 questions in confidence in terms of article 52(2) of EIRA:
1. Are you a member of a Tradeunion?

2. If yes, which union?

Employees are not asked which union they prefer to represent them, as has been erroneously reported in the media, as this does not fall within the powers of the Registrar. Neither is the Registrar empowered to carry out or order ballots.

The result given to the employer and copied to the unions is that a particular union has or has not more than 50% of the employees in the particular category being surveyed. This has been the procedure used as recently as February 2009 at a verification exercise at OIWAS with the involvement of GWU and UHM.

The Registrar has no objection to the parties involved in recognition matters to agree and implement different methods on the basis of which the employer would be in a better position to decide whether to award recognition or not. At best this would save time and effort on the part of the Registrar and his staff, as the Registrar’s intervention would no longer be required. Indeed this was verbally communicated to all parties in this issue on several occasions. However this is not something that can be imposed by the Registrar or by one of the parties on all the parties concerned. In the absence of such an agreement on a different process between the parties and with a valid request by an employer to perform a verification exercise, it is the duty of the Registrar to perform such an exercise. Indeed, last Friday a separate exercise was scheduled to be carried out at the request of an employer at a different workplace where GWU were claiming recognition, but this exercise was cancelled by the Registrar when the employer withdrew his request.

There have been a number of gross distortions of truth in a section of the media:

  1. The Registrar has been accused that he held meetings with MDU officials on this issue whilst refusing to meet the GWU. This has been conveniently interpreted as showing a lack of impartiality. This is untrue, as the Registrar has not held any meetings with either the GWU or MDU or with the employer. No one bothered to verify this claim with the Director prior to going to print.
  1. It has been stated that the Director has been aware of and has accepted a closed shop system being operated in the allocation of work to port workers. This is again patently untrue. The Director is unaware of such a system and although the GWU, who have made the allegations, were formally asked to provide details of such a practice, to date no such information has been forthcoming.
  1. In today’s ‘l-Orizzont’ it was alleged that yesterday the Director spoke to the port workers. This is totally and categorically untrue. Again, no one bothered to verify this claim with the Director prior to going to print.

Such statements only serve to distort the real picture and do not reflect the reality on the ground. At the very least they would appear to indicate a serious lack of basic journalistic ethics.

The Director is carrying out his duties in accordance with the Employment and Industrial Relations Act. The carrying out of a verification exercise in the current format is a legitimate procedure in conformity with the Employment and Industrial Relations Act, has been carried out several times in the past with no problems and gives employees the opportunity to express themselves as regards claimed union membership.  This is a service offered to employees and to employers to ensure that, if the employer so requests, the employer has a clear indication of whether the claims of a union that it has a majority of employees as its members are true. In the end, it is the employees themselves that will benefit from such an exercise as it facilitates the process of union recognition.

Finally it is important to stress that the Director or Registrar have always been impartial in dealings with all unions. It is precisely because it is important to maintain impartiality that the Registrar has retained the criteria for the carrying out of verifications as per usual practice and has applied this method across the board. Doing otherwise would actually justify the false claims being made that the Registrar is adopting two weights and two measures.

DOI – 07.04.2009

Ixxerja din l-istqarrija Icon socials Icon socials Icon socials Icon socials

Stqarrijiet Oħra:

STQARRIJA MILL-UFFIĊĊJU TAD-DEPUTAT PRIM MINISTRU U MINISTERU GĦAS-SAĦĦA U MILL-MINISTERU GĦALL-POLITIKA SOĊJALI U L-FAMILJA   Aktar għarfien dwar is-saħħa mentali fost it-tfal

PR261985

STQARRIJA MILL-UFFIĊĊJU TAD-DEPUTAT PRIM MINISTRU U MINISTERU GĦAS-SAĦĦA U ...

STQARRIJA MILL-UFFIĊĊJU TAL-PRIM MINISTRU  Il-Prim Ministru Robert Abela jippresjedi l-iffirmar ta’ tliet ftehimiet kollettivi għal madwar 1,700 ħaddiem

PR261984

STQARRIJA MILL-UFFIĊĊJU TAL-PRIM MINISTRU Il-Prim Ministru Robert Abela ji...

Aktar Stqarrijiet Right arrow