Left arrow Mur Lura

LAUNCH OF THE WHITE PAPER ON RESTORATIVE JUSTICE

PR0279E
Date Icon 20/02/2009

Points from Speech by the Hon. Dr. Carmelo Mifsud Bonnici, Minister for Justice and Home Affairs, during the launching of the White Paper on Restorative Justice

1.         Every crime needs to be punished.  The damage caused by every crime needs to be repaired.  Order in society needs to be stabilised again.  The State has the duty to sue who has committed the crime, proceed against him in Court subject to fair proceedings and then see that the Court judgment is executed.  One has to ask whether this is enough.  Is it enough that the accused is thrown into prison?  Is the State obliged to see what happens to the crime victim?  Does the State have the duty to see why the offender has made a mistake and help him repair the damage done, reform himself and go back within the Community as a law-abiding citizen? 

2.         In the past, Criminal Justice was aimed mostly towards punishment.  In primitive times, punishment used to be requested by either the victim or his relatives, rather than by the State.  Part of the progress of civilization was the first step for the Community not allowing the victim and his relatives to seek justice on their own accord.  Crime causes damage to everyone.  Later on, the laws began choosing between the punishment which is given by society, and therefore proceeding against the offender, and the repair of the damage done to the victim, which was left to the victim as a civil action.  Moreover, time has come when according to the best legislators, punishment began to be considered not only as revenge and as a means to keep on guard who becomes tempted to commit the crime, but also as a means of reform of the offender. 

3.                  Today, it is clear that it is not enough for the State to punish the offender by imprisonment or by imposing a fine.  It is necessary that the State intervenes more so that besides providing: 

·        A Police Corp, to maintain order, and when order is breached, to investigate who has breached order and brings him/her to court;

·        Courts which proceed against the offenders with justice and subject to all the guarantees of the rights of every individual;

·         Prisons where those who are found guilty serve the term of their verdict; 

Ensures as well that: 

·        The offenders of crime receive compensation from the offender or, in certain cases, when this is not possible, even from the State;

·        The offender is helped to reform by admitting his mistake, paying compensation to the victim and to the State, educating him again in order to become once more a law-abiding citizen. 

4.         It is necessary that our county enhances the emphasis on repair, without forgetting the aspect of punishment.  Repair to the victims of crime; repair to society, because breach of order harms all society and incurs expenses on the State through expenses connected with the police, investigations, courts and prison.  Every crime, apart from social damage, causes as well economic and financial damage.  Economic, because the development of our country depends on how much one feels secure, on where one can invest and where the tourists can visit without problems.  Financial, because the whole expense to maintain order, for the investigation of crimes, for the courts to proceed against the offenders and for the maintenance of the prison, is very high. 

5.         Criminality is a very complex phenomenon.  There is a challenge to prevent crime from happening, and a bigger challenge to contain recidivism because a high proportion of those who commit the first crime, repeat it.  Prison alone does not bring some criminals into their senses.  Sometimes prison can be an obstacle for the reparation of the damage done.  The prisoner, especially if he is young, whilst in prison can be influenced by the boasting of other criminals, and this goes against the process of reform.  Every prisoner, whilst imprisoned would not be in a position to repair the damage done. 

6.         Therefore, one has to weigh the need for punishment by imprisonment, together with the other need that the person found guilty repairs by paying compensation to the victim, repair to society and the expense to the State.  The fact that he executes the judgment in prison is not repair enough.  In order to reform himself truly, the offender has to show that he understood that he has done a mistake, by paying his debt to the victim, to society and to the State.  The policy of Restorative Justice emphasizes these aspects.  So the person found guilty has to see that he redeems himself not only by simply executing the punishment, but by paying the debt towards the victims, towards society, towards the country and towards himself.  An individual who commits a crime loses the respect of the Community, but also towards himself.  An offender reforms himself when, apart from paying, he understands. 

7.         It is also very important that in the fight against criminality, every remission and pardon, every concession of freedom, is aimed and connected with repair, with reform and in the change of behaviour.  The remission of imprisonment, which we intend to introduce, the granting of parole, the same Presidential pardon are not concessions without the purpose of compensation, repair and reform. 

8.         Remission, which to date was only conditional on good behaviour in prison, granting of parole, as well as pardon

+pr0279(English)

Ixxerja din l-istqarrija Icon socials Icon socials Icon socials Icon socials

Stqarrijiet Oħra:

STQARRIJA MILL-UFFIĊĊJU TAD-DEPUTAT PRIM MINISTRU U MINISTERU GĦAS-SAĦĦA U MILL-MINISTERU GĦALL-POLITIKA SOĊJALI U L-FAMILJA   Aktar għarfien dwar is-saħħa mentali fost it-tfal

PR261985

STQARRIJA MILL-UFFIĊĊJU TAD-DEPUTAT PRIM MINISTRU U MINISTERU GĦAS-SAĦĦA U ...

STQARRIJA MILL-UFFIĊĊJU TAL-PRIM MINISTRU  Il-Prim Ministru Robert Abela jippresjedi l-iffirmar ta’ tliet ftehimiet kollettivi għal madwar 1,700 ħaddiem

PR261984

STQARRIJA MILL-UFFIĊĊJU TAL-PRIM MINISTRU Il-Prim Ministru Robert Abela ji...

Aktar Stqarrijiet Right arrow