STATEMENT BY the Ministry for Justice and Home Affairs
PR0102
23/01/2009
| UN | Working group has failed to appreciate scale of illegal immigration problem in Malta |
| The Ministry for | Justice and Home Affairs refers to a statement released to the media this evening by the UN Working Group on Arbitrary Detention which was visiting Malta over the past three days. |
| It is evident | from the conclusions of the initial report communicated to the media, that the Working Group has failed to fully appreciate the scale of the problem that Malta, with its limited resources, limited land mass, and a population of just over 400,000 people is facing with the numbers of illegal immigrants arriving to its shores. |
| Putting matters | into perspective on the basis of the country’s population, the 2775 illegal immigrants that arrived in Malta last year would be equivalent to more than 300,000 arriving in Spain during the same period. |
| Some | clarification is thus in order with regard to some of the claims made by the UN Working Group on Arbitrary Detention. |
| In formulating its policies on illegal | migration and detention, the Maltese government sought to achieve a balance between security concerns on the one hand and humanitarian considerations on the other. Moreover, full consideration was taken of the rights of asylum seekers. |
| The first | clarification concerns the detention period. Although it is true that the maximum detention period for illegal immigrants is 18 months, by no means all the persons currently in detention have been or will be in detention for a total of 18 months. As a matter of fact, asylum seekers are detained for a maximum of 12 months - in other words if their case is not determined within 12 months they are released. However, most asylum cases are in fact determined well before the elapse of 12 months, and those who are recognised as refugees or beneficiaries of subsidiary protection are released immediately. |
| Secondly, not all | illegal immigrants are subject to the detention requirement. In fact vulnerable persons have their freedom restricted only until such time as they are given medical clearance, whereupon they are offered accommodation in Open Centres. The eight-year old child that was allegedly detained had in fact entered Malta less than two weeks ago and was released because he had obtained the required medical clearance – which is mandatory for the release of any illegal immigrant - not because he was “pointed out” by the UN Working Group. |
| Thirdly, illegal | immigration in Malta has been de-criminalised. Hence, the immigrants in question are issued with a removal order, in view of their illegal presence in the country. However, once an illegal immigrant applies for asylum the removal order is suspended, pending the result of the asylum application process. |
| In view of these | procedures applicable in respect of illegal immigrants, it can hardly be argued that they are in any way being criminalised. As a matter of fact the objective of the detention policy is to guarantee Malta’s security. In this regard, it should be emphasised that illegal immigrants enter Malta undocumented, which means that they cannot be identified by the authorities. |
| Moreover, those | immigrants who are not recognised as refugees or beneficiaries of international protection have no right or entitlement to reside in Malta. The authorities are, and have been, making efforts to have such persons repatriated to their respective countries. Unfortunately this is not always a straightforward or simple process, which explains why a number of illegal immigrants did spend the stipulated maximum of 18 months in detention, although some accept to be repatriated voluntarily under a scheme offered by the Government of Malta. |
| As regards the | conditions of detention, efforts are continuously being made to enhance existing facilities and to enlarge capacity; however during 2008 Malta witnessed a record number of arrivals of 2,775, as compared to 1,702 during 2007- an increase of 63%. Clearly this places considerable strain on Malta’s detention facilities. |
| A word must also | be said about the Somali suffering from chicken pox and HIV who, according to the UN Working Group, should have been in hospital and not kept in a cell. As a matter of fact this person was not denied hospital treatment and was being kept alone (by no means inside a cell) with a view to avoiding the spread of chicken pox to the other immigrants. It is worth noting that Malta set the example in this matter because illegal immigrants are afforded all the medical treatment that is available to any Maltese citizen. |
| Finally, whilst | appreciating the Group’s comments that illegal immigration is a problem that should be shared by the world as a whole, it is worth noting that such appeals have already been made in the past, to little effect. |
| Regarding the | introduction of parole in Malta’s penal system, the Ministry is informed that the Working Group was already briefed about the imminent publication the White Paper on Restorative Justice, which will propose the introduction of this concept. This briefing, however, took place after the Working Group’s press release had been drafted. |
| With reference to | the proportion of inmates at the Corradino Correctional Facility who are still awaiting trial, it must be said that the out of a total population of 431 currently being held at the CCF, only 131 are being detained while awaiting trial – just 30%. It thus follows that the proportion of “over 50%” quoted in the Working Group’s statement is grossly inflated. One must also keep in mind that such orders for custody are decided by the Courts which are an independent institution. |
Stqarrijiet Oħra:
PR261985
STQARRIJA MILL-UFFIĊĊJU TAD-DEPUTAT PRIM MINISTRU U MINISTERU GĦAS-SAĦĦA U ...
PR261984