SPEECH BY THE HON LAWRENCE GONZI, PRIME MINISTER, WITH THE THEME “MALTA IN THE EU: FIVE YEARS ON - REFLECTIONS AND AMBITIONS” AT THE EUROPÄISCHES HAUS, BERLIN, GERMANY – TUESDAY, 20 JANUARY 2009
PR0078
20/01/2009
Excellencies
Distinguished Guests
Ladies and Gentlemen
On 1 May 2009 Malta and nine other countries mark the fifth anniversary of their membership of the European Union. For obvious reasons, the accession of these ten Member States changed the face of Europe. A lot has been said about this process and I do not propose to discuss this aspect of the 2004 enlargement. Instead, I propose to discuss the changes that EU membership has brought to one of the countries that joined the Union five years ago – Malta.
| The Economic | Dimension |
| Let me start with | the economic dimension. Five years of EU membership – together with the years of preparation for membership – have led to a total transformation of Malta’s economy. |
| Investment: | First of all, membership has brought with it an unprecedented level of investment, notably foreign direct investment as Malta’s integration into a single European market of half a billion people attracted the attention of investors from all over the world in diverse sectors ranging from pharmaceuticals to information and communications technology as well as the financial services sector which now benefits from the single European passport. Malta now ranks as one of the most attractive countries for foreign direct investment not only in the European Union but also on a global level. In last year’s World Investment Report compiled by the United Nations Conference on Trade and Development (UNCTAD), Malta classified fourth in the world in foreign direct investment performance. |
| Diversification: | Secondly, by exposing our once state-dominated economy to the full force of competition, EU membership has triggered a major restructuring process. Liberalisation has proceeded in earnest and privatisation has been pursued with vigour, with the role of Government in public companies steadily diminishing. All the while, the private sector saw a major transformation as new investment flowed in to replace declining or uncompetitive sectors. The end result was a remarkable diversification of the economy with the gradual decrease of certain sectors, such as textiles, which were previously dominant, and the rapid growth of newer, higher value-added sectors such as pharmaceuticals and information and communications technology. So membership has meant restructuring, new investment and diversification. |
| Employment: | Thirdly, far from bringing about a loss of jobs as many had feared or predicted, EU membership has unleashed dynamism into the labour market, which grew rapidly, adapting to new realities and new needs, with falling unemployment. Such changes happened despite the difficulties that inevitably come with the initial years of adaptation. Indeed, the rate of loss of jobs from declining sectors was by far outpaced by the rate of job creation in the growth sectors. This resilience should serve us well in the current international economic downturn. Unfortunately, although the fundamentals of the economy remain strong, the Maltese economy is too open not to be affected by the downturn. |
| EU Funding: | Fourthly, EU funding is helping economic development by injecting much-needed financial resources into major infrastructural projects, notably in the transport, environmental and education sectors. Equally, EU funding is proving crucial in supporting our investment in human resources – which is our only natural resource – especially in helping workers integrate or reintegrate into the labour market. |
| By 2013, Malta is | estimated to be a recipient of EU financial assistance which tops the €1 billion mark – equivalent to €2500 per person – making Malta a clear net beneficiary in its first years of membership. |
| The Euro: | And fifthly, membership has brought with it a commitment to membership of the Euro area which, in turn, has meant a commitment to fiscal discipline, notably by reining in the budget deficit and public debt, as well as a commitment to restrained inflation. Inevitably, preparing for the Euro has reduced our policy options at a crucial time of adaptation and we have had to ask taxpayers to dig deeper into their pockets. But the adoption of the Euro on 1 January last year has already paid off handsomely. Not only have the Maltese consumers adapted quickly and positively to our new currency, but the Euro has already provided us with a shelter in some areas during the recent financial crisis. |
| All the while, I am | conscious of the fact that the Euro is not merely a financial or economic project. It is fundamentally a political project. |
| This brings me to | the second part of this afternoon’s discussion which is the political dimension of EU membership. |
| The Political | Dimension |
| I should say, at | this stage, that I conceive of the European Union as primarily a political project. EU membership has fully integrated my country in that project, into the European family of nations and into the process of an ever closer Union. |
| For several years we | watched the European Union evolve from the outside – from three Communities to a Union. Today, we are proud to be active in the process of European integration from within. Despite the mishaps that befell the European Constitutional Treaty, the political process remains open and I am optimistic on the prospective entry into force of the Lisbon Treaty in the not-too-distant future. |
| My main reflection | on the political dimension must definitely relate to the relative weight that a country the size of Malta, with a population of less than half a million, has within the institutional structure of the Union. For it is this weight that allows a country to have a meaningful participation as a Member State of the Union. Without a true and adequate representation, a country’s participation cannot be meaningful. |
| In this regard our | experience is that small countries can, and do, punch above their weight. We already knew that this meaningful participation was possible before we joined – Luxembourg was the best example of this reality. But we can now confirm our impressions on the basis of our own experience. During the past five years, we have actively contributed to shaping EU policies and EU decisions in different policy areas ranging from maritime affairs to immigration policy. Incidentally these decisions used to affect us in any case even before we joined. But before we joined we merely used to follow them; now we can also shape them. |
| The contrast with | countries that have chosen to stay out could not be more stark. Countries such as Norway, Iceland and Switzerland are still subject to much the same rules as us; with the important difference that they are not part of the decision-making process. |
| In a few days’ time, | the Swiss people will vote in a referendum to decide whether to accept the extension of free movement rights to the newest EU citizens, those of Bulgaria and Romania. |
| On its part, Iceland | – with a population even smaller than Malta’s – ponders over a possible reconsideration of its decision to stay out of the Union as it faces a veritable financial and economic collapse. |
| Now compare that | with countries such as Ireland – and it could have easily been another country – whose referendum last June effectively blocked the ratification process of the Lisbon Treaty. The response to the Irish referendum was not a decision to shun Ireland but a wiser decision to ask its government to reflect on the reasons for the rejection and to look for a concrete response to the legitimate concerns expressed by the Irish electorate. Last month’s European Council was able to reach agreement on the elements of this response, as put to it by the Irish government. |
| The experience of my | country has been similar in the sense that we sense that our impact on decisions that affect us is superior to what it would have been had we chosen to stay out. We naturally feel strongly that the institutional representation of small countries must be sufficiently adequate to enable them to participate in a meaningful and effective manner within the EU structures. |
| The | Commission: Part of our response to the Irish referendum in the European Council last December reconfirmed the principle of one-Commissioner-per-Member-State once the Lisbon Treaty comes into force. There is a lot to be said about a large Commission affecting the dynamics within the College of Commissioners, about its impact on the efficiency of the College’s work as well as the relevant importance of individual Commissioners within the College. Nevertheless, we welcome this decision because although we are aware that Members of the Commission act independently, we nevertheless feel that having a national in the Commission gives reassurances that no country’s interests, no matter its size, can be overlooked. |
| The | European Parliament: The same concerns had led to Malta’s objections in December 2000 when we were still a candidate country, to an agreement reached during the Nice Treaty negotiations to allocate just five seats in the European Parliament to Malta when the long experience of Luxembourg – with our same population – had amply shown that a representation of six seats was the bare minimum that a country could have to enable its voice to be sufficiently heard. These concerns have to be seen also in the context of the European Parliament’s co-decision powers in the adoption of laws which bind Maltese citizens as well. |
| We have since | insisted on addressing this point at subsequent Treaty negotiations. This we did primarily by entrenching into the European Constitutional Treaty – and now in the Lisbon Treaty – a minimum threshold of six seats in the European Parliament to enable an effective representation for the smallest Member States. |
| Large | Countries: None of these arguments is to say that large countries do not have an important, indeed, a pivotal role in the European Union – Germany’s contribution to European integration speaks for itself. But for Europe to be truly reflective of the dual democracy for which it stands – the democracy of States as well as the democracy of people – it is clear that the weight afforded to small countries cannot be proportionate to their size. That this dual democracy finds its place in the institutional structure of the Union is ultimately what makes for cohesion and what binds the Union’s countries, large and small, together. |
| Immigration: | Nor is it to say that all is plain-sailing. As a frontier state on the southern external border of the Union we are experiencing, at first-hand, the human tragedy of thousands of boat people crossing from Africa in the quest for a better life in Europe. Thousands of lives are saved at sea every year by our armed forces, despite their significant constraints, but still hundreds of lives are lost. There is, however, a dimension other than the humanitarian which impacts directly on Malta. |
| For these immigrants | whose real objective is to reach mainland Europe, Malta is not so much a point of destination as much as it is a point of transit. Our capacity to host arriving immigrants has exceeded all reasonable limits and the phenomenon shows no signs of receding. And yet, although there has been progress over the past years, including the 2008 European Immigration and Asylum Pact, the Union continues to be slow in extending the required solidarity to Malta. |
| The protection of | Europe’s external borders cannot be left to frontier states alone. More so when particular frontier countries are facing disproportionate burdens. As can be imagined, this reality was one of the items I raised with Chancellor Merkel earlier today. |
| Ambitions for the | Future |
| Malta will continue | to pursue its strategy to make a success out of membership in the years to come. We hope to see further benefits in terms of sustained economic development, more investment, more and better jobs and ultimately a steady rise in the standard of living to reach, and hopefully exceed, the European average. We feel that membership has provided us with a good tool to reach these ambitious goals and we intend to exploit this tool to the maximum. |
| In the medium to | long-term we have also taken the conscious decision to shift our focus on seven key sectors in which we hope to seek excellence in the Mediterranean region by the year 2015. The sectors targeted in our “Vision 2015” are (1) education, (2) health, (3) the financial services sector, (4) information and communications technology, (5) tourism and (6) high value-added manufacturing and ancillary services and (7) and Gozo, Malta’s sister island, as a model for sustainable development. |
| In these seven | sectors we are confident that we possess a comparative advantage and that we can excel not only for the benefit of our citizens but also for the benefit of our region. We are also confident that in these sectors we can attract the interest and the investment of our partner countries and of potential investors from Europe and beyond. With these sectors we aspire to re-dimension our economy and to turn our country into a leading player in the Mediterranean region. |
| In conclusion, my | assessment is that the first five years of EU membership have been an exceedingly positive experience for Malta. The transformation has not been trouble-free. It has, however, profoundly changed our economy and our public administration for the better, and also, I would add, our political climate. Most importantly, this transformation has engrained in us the clear understanding that change is a continuing process and a necessity in itself. Those who resist change are bound to fail. |
| Malta, the smallest | Member State of the European Union is today a positive and reliable member not just of the European Union but also of the Euro area and of the Schengen zone. These developments have transformed Malta from a relatively isolated nation on the fringes of Europe to a frontrunner of European integration. In the years to come we shall continue along this path with a steadfast determination. |
Other Press Releases:
PR261985
STQARRIJA MILL-UFFIĊĊJU TAD-DEPUTAT PRIM MINISTRU U MINISTERU GĦAS-SAĦĦA U ...
PR261984