Welcome address by His Honour, the Chief Justice Vincent A. De Gaetano, at the UNIDEM Seminar: “Cancellation of Election Results” - Mediterranean Conference Centre, Valletta, MALTA – 14/15 November 2008
PR1741
14/11/2008
| Honourable Minister, Distinguished Participants, | Ladies and Gentlemen: |
| On behalf of the | Constitutional Court of Malta, I welcome you all to this UNIDEM Seminar. When some weeks back I was first approached by Malta’s representative on the Venice Commission – President Emeritus Ugo Mifsud Bonnici – with the proposal to co-host the seminar, I was, I must confess, slightly taken aback by the topic: “Cancellation of Election Results”. |
| The topic is one | whose importance is not immediately apparent; and moreover, being a topic which every judge prays that he or she will never have to rule upon, one tends to prefer topics of more immediate and general application. On the other hand, however, one cannot doubt that elections, particularly general elections, are pivotal in any modern and true democracy. |
| Free and fair | elections are the benchmark by which the legitimacy of a government is measured. Measures or incidents which, directly or indirectly, impinge upon such freedom or fairness may, depending on the gravity or extent of those measures or incidents, give rise to situations which undermine the validity of those elections and consequently the legitimacy of the government. |
| Such measures or | incidents will invariably give rise to disputes which must be resolved. Of course such disputes need not necessarily be resolved by a “constitutional” court or indeed by a “court”. |
| Where an | Electoral Commission is regarded as having the same independence and impartiality as a court, it may be proper to have the dispute referred to that body; but even so there will invariably remain some issues which will end up before the ordinary courts. Moreover, where elections are, to a lesser or greater extent, regulated by the Constitution of the land, it is more than likely that matters which call for the suspension or cancellation of elections -- whether in one or more electoral districts or generally -- will end up in the lap of the courts. This, in turn, will raise issues whose importance may, again, not be immediately apparent. |
| For example, in | election issues, time is of the essence. Should decisions of the court, therefore, be subject to appeal, or should a court deciding such issues be a court of first and last instance? The ultimate question, of course, is: should the outcome of elections be determined by the judiciary? That is not meant to be a rhetorical or a cynical question, although political elections have not failed to attract a degree of cynicism by writers, philosophers and even statesmen. |
| One cannot help | calling to mind, for instance, what George Bernard Shaw said about elections and democracy: “Democracy is a form of government that substitutes election by the incompetent many for appointment by the corrupt few”. Or the even more cynical words of Josef Stalin: “It is enough that the people know there was an election. The people who cast the votes decide nothing. The people who count the votes decide everything”. |
| Distinguished | guests, ladies and gentlemen: the legal issues which may be associated with, or which may stem from, the cancellation of elections results are far too many for me to enumerate. I am sure, however, that many of these issues will be touched upon in your deliberations. The place where you will be deliberating – the Mediterranean Conference Centre, where we are now – was, as I am sure you have been told, the Sacra Infermeria of the Order of St. John. |
| The Order never | held elections such as the ones you will be discussing – their elections were limited to electing, by those members of the Order entitled to vote, the Grand Master and the holders of certain important posts. But at least the Order has left us this beautiful place where you can work. So without more ado I will now pass on the word to the representative of the Venice Commission, Mr Garrone. |
| I wish you all an | interesting and fruitful seminar, and also a pleasant stay here in Malta. Thank you. |
Other Press Releases:
PR261985
STQARRIJA MILL-UFFIĊĊJU TAD-DEPUTAT PRIM MINISTRU U MINISTERU GĦAS-SAĦĦA U ...
PR261984