THE HON. CENSU GALEA, MINISTER FOR COMPETITIVENESS AND COMMUNICATIONS ADDRESSES THE NSTF MINI EUROPEAN ASSEMBLY ENTITLED ‘COPYRIGHT, ENTERTAINMENT INDUSTRY AND THE INTERNET. HOW COMPATIBLE?’
Intellectual Property refers to the fruit of the mind and includes inventions and product design as well as literary musical artistic and audiovisual works. Intellectual property rights are given by the state to the creators to encourage further innovation and dissemination of knowledge as well as transfer of technology and development in general.
Intellectual property rights may be divided in to two main branches:
| The first branch is referred to as industrial property rights and | includes the rights associated with |
| a) | trademarks which serve to distinguish the goods or services of one undertaking from those of others –trademarks when registered may be renewed indefinitely every 10 years and are valid only in the country where they are registered except in the case of a community trademark which is valid for the whole European community |
| b) | designs the registration of which protects the aesthetic aspect of a product. Such a registration may be renewed every five years up to a maximum period of 25 years and is only valid where it is registered except in the case of a community design which is valid for the whole European community |
| c) | inventions which must not form part of the prior art, must not be obvious and which must be industrially applicable . These may be protected through a national patent which is valid for 20years. No community patent exists as yet |
| The second branch refers to Copyright and Neighbouring rights. Copyright | pertains to the rights of authors of literary, musical artistic works and audiovisual works and databases. Neighbouring rights pertain to the rights of performers, producers of sound recordings and broadcasters. No registration is required and the rights are valid internationally subject to multilateral treaties such as The Universal Copyright Convention, the Berne Convention for the Protection of Literary & Artistic Works, Rome Convention for the Protection of Performance, Producers of Phonograms & Broadcasting Organisations, the WIPO Copyright Treaty, the WIPO Performances and Producers of Phonograms Treaty and the WTO Agreement on Trade Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights. Within the copyright protection is valid for until 70 years after the end of the year in which the author dies. The term of neighbouring rights is 50 years from the end of the year in which the performance, sound recording, audiovisual work or broadcast is fixed, published or transmitted respectively. |
| According to the single Market News a | study conducted by the Turku School of Economics in Finland copyright industries contributed more than Euro 1200 billion to the EU economy and employed 5.2 million people. It is worth noting that the study emphasizes that these figures may be understated by as much as 10per cent and also that they relate to the year 2000 ie prior to enlargement. It is no wonder that copyright protection mechanisms have seen substantial changes though out the ages which reflect both the importance being given to this industry and the development of new technologies. The EU in fact has issued several directives which include: |
Directive 91/250 on the Protection of Computer Programs
Directive 92/100 on Rental Rights & Lending Rights
Directive 93/83 related to Satellite Broadcasting & Retransmission
Directive 96/9 on the Protection of Databases
| Directive 93/98 harmonising the Term of Protection of Copyright and | certain Related Rights |
| Directive 2001/29 Information Society - Harmonising of certain aspects of | Copyright and Related Rights |
| Directive 2001/84 on the Resale Right for the benefit of the author of an | organised work of art |
| Another directive on administrative aspects of enforcement is to come | into force this year while a directive on criminal procedures is also being prepared. |
| The | significance of the word stealing is understood by everyone. However, few are those who actually recognise that not respecting the Copyright Law is another form of stealing. |
| Everybody | works hard to earn money to buy things which they need so if someone steals something which belongs to someone else it is considered a criminal act punishable by law and may even lead to imprisonment. Nevertheless, it is important to note that physically taking an object is not the only way in which a person may steal. The same can be said for artists, authors and others who sell their products to make a living, and these products are illegally copied and sold for a cheaper price. |
| In | olden times if someone created a song another person could only copy it by memorising it and singing it again. With the development of the written alphabet and musical notations it became possible to copy a song by writing it down again if it had already been written. This obviously also applied to story telling and play acting. |
| Whilst | such copying was frowned upon, its prohibition was not actually in encapsulated in law because of its relatively infrequent occurrence as few people could write or read. With the spread of education and the advent of the printing press in the 15th century all this changed. It suddenly became possible to make hundreds of copies of a person’s work and to sell them without any permission from or compensation to the author. The creator was thus suddenly losing out on the selling of copies of his work which he could have sold himself. The situation thus necessitated the need for a new type of legislation known as Copyright Law. |
| Copyright | protection originated in the form of a printer licence i.e. a printer could only print books if licensed by the King. However progress in the 20th Century has been breathtaking. The simple manual typewriter evolved into the electric and electronic typewriter and then into the Desktop Computer which itself evolved into the laptop and palmtop. At the same time, we have had the introduction of the photocopies and the scanner. Gramophones became cassette players and recorders which became CD players. Video players and video recorders became DVD players and recorders. All this has been complemented by developments in communication technologies - mobile phones as opposed to landlines, electronic mails replaced telex and facsimile machines, satellite and cable transmissions has made it possible to broadcast a programme anywhere in the world. And then of course there is the internet. |
| This revolutionary | technology bodes well in so far as dissemination goes, but obviously there is the downside. The developments mentioned have made it very easy to make high quality resolution copies of works. In addition, films and music can be uploaded to the internet and downloaded by anyone with an adequate computer. All this can be done with the original creator not being given a single cent in return for his effort and for the time and money he spent to produce his work. |
| Copyright | nowadays is no longer restricted to books but covers all sorts of literary works, irrespective of literary quality such as: |
| (a) | novels, stories and poetical works; |
| (b) | plays, stage directions, choreographic works or entertainment in dumb show, film scenarios and broadcasting script; |
| (c) | textbooks, treatises, histories, biographies, essays and articles; |
| (d) | encyclopedias and dictionaries; |
| (e) | letters, reports and memoranda; |
| (f) | lectures, addresses and sermons; |
| (g) | computer programmes. |
| Copyright protection nowadays is | expanded to cover the subject matter such as artistic works, database and audiovisual works and music works. Obviously the type of protection given, also had to develop to reflect the great advances in technology of the twentieth century. |
| Copyright in | Malta is regulated by the Copyright Act 2003 which stipulates under Article 7(1): |
| “(1) Copyright in an audiovisual work, a database, a literary, musical | or artistic work shall be the exclusive right to authorize or prohibit the doing in Malta in respect of the protected material in its totality or substantial part thereof, either in its original form or in any form recognizably derived from the original of any of the following: |
| (a) | the direct or indirect, temporary or permanent reproduction by any means and in any form, in whole or in part; |
| (b) | the rental and lending; |
| (c) | the distribution; |
| (d) | the translation in other languages including different computer languages; |
| (e) | the adaptation, the arrangement and any other alteration and the reproduction, distribution, communication, display of performance to the public of the results thereof; |
| (f) | the broadcasting or rebroadcasting or the communication to the public or cable retransmission; |
| (g) | display or performance to the public.” |
Infringing Copyright
| Infringement is subject to civil proceedings which could result in the | payment of damages, the delivery of all infringing articles and the restitution of all profits. |
| Copyright infringement is also a crime and carries a penalty of up to one | year imprisonment and Lm5,000 fine. While Customs and Police can and do seize printed goods and take the responsible people to Court, a substantial amount of copyright infringement takes place in the home as a result in the modern technologies mentioned above. It is possible to catch the big companies which make illegal profit in this way. |
| “The Napster Case: Piracy on | the Internet |
| On February | 12, 2001, the United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit rendered its landmark decision in an important legal case, A&M Records, Inc., et al. vs. Napster, Inc, ruling that Napster’s “fair use” defense without merit. Napster was a hugely successful music file-sharing website and programme (up to 10,000 downloads per second), in which files were of musical copyright works without the authorization of the rightholder – it was a business built on illegal transactions.” |
| It is very difficult however to stop people downloading from the internet | and copying CDs and DVDs. Though the industry is trying to stem this with anti- copying technology the most successful way of controlling this is by realising when we make illegal copies we are actually stealing. |
| If we indeed support our favourite band or singer we must remember that | their success and our continual engagement is dependent on their reaping rewards for their creativity. With illegal copying and downloading we are actually hurting those who we profess to support. |
Stqarrijiet Oħra:
PR261953en
PRESS RELEASE BY THE NATIONAL AUDIT OFFICE Performance Audit: Verifying In...
PR261953