PRESS RELEASE BY THE NATIONAL AUDIT OFFICE Performance Audit: Verifying Income Tax Returns
Auditor General Charles Deguara presented the Performance Audit highlighted in caption to the Speaker of the House of Representatives Carmelo Abela. This Report examined whether the Malta Tax and Customs Administration (MTCA) has appropriate mechanisms in place to support accurate reporting in personal and corporate income tax declarations and facilitate voluntary compliance.
Income tax is a major source of Government revenue in Malta, generating approximately €3.4 billion in 2025 and accounting for 51 per cent of total Government tax revenue. Under Malta’s self-assessment system, taxpayers are primarily responsible for accurately declaring their income. Effective compliance management is therefore critical to safeguarding public revenue.
The audit acknowledged that MTCA has established a clear direction through its Strategic Plan 2023-2025 and is implementing an ambitious transformation programme centred on organisational reform, digitalisation, the introduction of data analytics capabilities and strengthened compliance management. The foregoing demonstrates a clear commitment towards developing a more integrated, intelligence-led and responsive organisation and provide a strong foundation for continuous improvements.
At the same time, the review identified a number of long-standing challenges that continue to affect operational effectiveness. These include historical maintenance back-logs to the taxpayer register, fragmented data environments and data-quality issues – all of which influence the reliability of available taxpayer information. On-time filing compliance remained below expected international benchmarks, particularly among corporate taxpayers. Moreover, outstanding personal and corporate income tax returns included cases that had remained unresolved for more than 25 years.
MTCA has already taken important steps towards embedding a risk-based approach to compliance management. As this continues to mature, opportunities remain to strengthen the tax audit selection process, primarily by having clearer audit trails and further alignment of resources with identified compliance risks. The Review also highlighted scope to reinforce the effectiveness and timeliness of the current penalty framework, thereby strengthening its intended purpose of encouraging voluntary compliance. Currently, penalties may become due only after outstanding returns are filed or an assessment is issued, potentially limiting the deterrent effect.
The audit further noted that tax audits generated additional revenue opportunities. However, a number of assessments were subsequently revised downwards during the objections stage, highlighting the importance of quality assurance and closer coordination across the audit and objection’s function.
Overall, the audit concluded that MTCA has made meaningful progress towards establishing a more modern, data-driven and risk-based tax administration. The reforms, which are currently underway, provide a robust platform to further improve governance arrangements, the reliability of taxpayer data, filing-compliance, tax audit processes, operational capacity and management information to support the ongoing transformation programme to deliver measurable and sustainable benefits.
The NAO recommends that MTCA strengthen strategic planning, taxpayer-register maintenance, filing compliance, the penalty regime, risk-based audit selection, resource alignment, quality assurance, and performance reporting.
The Report may be accessed through the NAO website: nao.gov.mt as well as on the NAO Facebook page www.facebook.com/NAOMalta.
Other Press Releases:
PR261953
STQARRIJA MILL-UFFIĊĊJU NAZZJONALI TAL-VERIFIKA Performance Audit: Verifyi...
PR261952