ADDRESS BY THE HON. Dr. Michael refalo, MINISTER FOR TOURISM TO THE Malta hotels and reswtaurants association (MHRA) ANNUAL GENERAL MEETING – Sliema - Thursday 28th November 2002
It is always a pleasure to be with you Mr. President, and with your lady and gentlemen members. This time twelve months ago, I had described the 2002 budget measures, that government had then just introduced, as specifically designed and tailor made to be the springboard for the industry’s recovery.
TWELVE MONTH OVERVIEW
Twelve months on, you know as well as I do, that the enormous corporate effort launched and implemented by government, by the Malta Tourism Authority, by Air Malta and the private sector, ably led by MHRA, has engineered and brought about a positive turn-around of tourism’s fortunes. We have successfully achieved our goal well before many of our Mediterranean competitors.
We have come through without resorting to subsidies, without massive price cuts, without handouts and without throwing silly money at operators. We have succeeded because we knew what we wanted to achieve, how and where we were going. We succeeded because we planned well, worked hard, worked together, and made the best use of available resources, in essence far less and much smaller than what our competitors have at their disposal.
2001 was the first time ever that international tourism arrivals registered a volume decline. Three major economies were slithering downwards. The situation in the US, Japan and Germany, impacted negatively and rippled through the economies of their trading partners in Europe, North and South America and in Asia. By summer 2001 international tourism had begun to splutter. Following the tragic 11th September 2001 events, the industry practically grounded to a halt. Malta could not, and did not, buck that trend.
They were black days for the industry. Despite a good forward booking situation tourism Malta suffered minor losses in volume and in earnings during the first quarter of 2002. However, when tour operators and suppliers cut programmes and air seat capacity, second quarter results, beginning April, took a steep nose dive. By summer, visitor volume had picked up appreciably in response to innovative publicity and advertising campaigns. The gap between 2001 and 2002 results narrowed and, as predicted, the industry enjoyed a good summer. Results then showed that recovery was near and on the cards.
OCTOBER 2002 RETURNS
We now have Air Malta and MIA data for October. Air Malta estimates reveal a 9.0% increase over October 2001 and the MIA’s passenger movements count endorses the national airline’s estimate. A 9.0% increase translates into over 116,000 visitors, which, when confirmed by NSO statistics, would make last month the best ever October on record.
For the first time this year October registered gains in all four core markets. 10% from the UK, which undoubtedly proves that additional funds employed in advertising, more aggressive marketing and publicity, are infinitely more effective than the TOSS subsidy scheme, 16% from Germany, which signaled a resurgence of group traffic, over 25% from Italy a market that has performed admirably throughout 2002, and a slight increase of just under 3% from France.
Returns for November and December are forecast to exceed 2001 results and MTA’s estimate is that we should end 2002 somewhere between – 4% to – 5%.
MALTA COMPARES WELL WITH COMPETING DESTINATIONS
How do we compare with the performance of competing destinations? The latest available data supplied by the European Travel Commission shows that Cyprus is 14% down and had by August lost 26% from Germany, 13% from the UK, 52% from Italy and 14% from the US; Spain gained 1.8% during the first eight months mainly due to a large increase in cross border overland traffic from France (+20%) and the Benelux (+16%), lost massively in Majorca and the Balearics (-20%) and should end the year level with 2001 results; in the first quarter Portugal was marginally down from most markets; Tunisia will end the year at –20%, Greece anywhere between –1% and 5%, while Turkey should gain 10%.
FORECAST FOR 2003
What of 2003? Although international analysts forecast recovery they are very wary in their predictions. Recovery from source markets will vary in time and it will take much longer for outgoing tourism from Germany to pick up and reach levels to which, the world, and we, have been accustomed. The new Air Services Agreement will give Air Malta a measure of greater flexibility to develop potential and should be of assistance.
A brighter future beckons in the UK market, but there again forecasts are shaded because of the uncertainty surrounding Airtours’ future. In this regard the latest information we have is quite encouraging. Banks have extended credit to the company and Airtours has lodged customers’ deposits on time.
Italy should continue to deliver quite well while we expect another steady performance from the French market. Additional air seat capacity will be placed in the Benelux while direct flights from Helsinki should improve an otherwise problematic situation in Scandinavia and Northern Europe. Smaller, emerging and long haul markets, except those in the Eastern Mediterranean, should do better in 2003.
I can only repeat what was starkly underlined in London earlier this month during the WTO’s Tourism Recovery Committee. Recovery depends entirely on the resolution of problems that initially led to tourism’s decline. The escalating violence in the Middle East, the aftermath of the Bali bombing, international terrorism aimed at leisure industry targets and the very real possibility of war in Iraq. All these very actual and potential problems as well as the state of some of the world’s major economies, overshadow international tourism’s progress and expansion. Malta cannot expect to remain immune.
MINISTRY – MHRA RELATIONS
Mr. Chairman, Ladies and Gentlemen, throughout 2002 your committee has held frequent meetings with me and my officials. We have had a regular exchange of views and strengthened the ongoing dialogue that underpins the excellent relations between my government and MHRA.
So long as they are also accessible to non-members my Ministry will continue to support MHRA initiatives and will moreover assist in research initiatives and programmes which benefit the industry as a whole.
OFFICIAL RECOGNITION
As Minister I have the unenviable task of deciding which association or professional grouping should be officially recognized to represent a particular segment of the industry and also on its eligibility to participate in elections for the nomination of representatives to serve on the Authority’s Board and Directorates. MHRA’s professionalism, structures and wide reach makes your association a natural and obvious choice. However a number of other groupings fail to give such assurances.
Rather than use my discretionary powers without a firm basis for decision, this time last year I asked Ministry officials to communicate the benchmarks which the Ministry has set for recognition. This year, being the first since benchmarks were introduced, I decided to give a liberal interpretation to their application.
This notwithstanding, three groupings failed in all respects and I cannot therefore accord them official recognition. This decision will stand, but I am quite prepared to reconsider and review it throughout 2003 should the associations/groupings concerned meet the Ministry’s benchmarks and prove that they are professionally organized and truly representative of their sector.
MALTA AND THE EU
My final point today is about accession to the European Union. The harmonization of legislation and the process of alignment with Acquis provisions have gradually, but very surely, given the industry practical experience of what operating within an EU scenario really means. After undergoing the pain of restructuring our tourism operators now expect to enjoy the many gains and benefits of membership.
Consumer related, health, labour and environment directives have been transposed into our body of laws. There are no hidden agendas, secrets, unknowns, questions or threats. It would therefore perhaps be worth the while of those tourism bodies who forgetful of the recent past, criticize the absence of budget "incentives", to seriously consider the many possibilities and great potential that EU membership offers. Accession is by far the best, most valuable and proven incentive to kick start and promote the further expansion of Malta’s tourism industry.
For many years, despite the insistence of South European member states, the EU gave little importance to tourism. It left member states to labour or thrive on their own. The recession that hit Europe in the mid-nineties changed all that. It brought with it a greater awareness and understanding of the industry’s employment generation and earning potential. It was only as recently as 1997 that the EU began to investigate how the economies of member states could gain and capitalize from the industry’s potential.
During their six month Presidency the more tourism oriented member states included meetings for EU Tourism Ministers to which we, their colleagues from candidate countries, were invited. It was at these fora that I raised Malta’s objections to the UK’s discriminatory passenger departure tax measures and called for the urgent need to liberalise air transport restrictions vis-à-vis candidate countries.
For departure tax purposes the UK now applies uniform provisions for both member and candidate states, and the German civil Aviation Authorities have recently relaxed air transport restrictions vis-à-vis Malta. The EU now urges member states not to increase the tax burden on tourism operations. It is presently revisiting the Tour Operator Margin Scheme to ensure a level playing field for operators within and out the EU.
EUROPEAN TOURISM FORUM
Last May at Santander, EU ministers decided to hold the first Session of the European Tourism Forum that will convene in Brussels next month. I have given notice that Malta will be submitting a formal proposal for discussion at that forum.
In this day and age the proposal which we will submit to namely, for the setting up of an adequate mechanism to accord better protection for tourism SME’s in the event of tour operator bankruptcy, is very relevant. I need not remind you that some of our hotels, small and not so small, have recently suffered cash flow and other problems as a result of the folding of a Malta specialist UK tour operator.
While in the case of tour operator failure, the rights of consumers to repatriation, refunds, and to one’s holiday, are all safeguarded by the likes of ABTA and ATOL in the UK and DRV’s insolvency scheme in Germany, there is, as yet, no mechanism to protect the accommodation industry from non payment due to suppliers’ insolvency.
Malta’s Business Promotion Act accords partial remedies, but they are patently not sufficient. What is required is a Europe wide structure. We will therefore submit a proposal for adoption by the EU’s DG XXIII, namely to appoint a task force of experts specifically to investigate, study and report on the setting up of a mechanism designed to provide better protection for tourism SMEs in the event of suppliers’ commercial failure.
CONCLUSION
Chairman, ladies and gentlemen, I am certain that MHRA members and others who operate in the accommodation sector are as anxiously keen as I am to see action on this front. Unilateral action serves little purpose. It is the EU that provides the appropriate forum with the corporate reach that the application of this proposal calls for.
My thanks again to you Mr. Chairman and to all MHRA members for the cooperation extended to the Ministry. While I extend my best wishes to all of you I look forward to renewed cooperation with MHRA for the greater benefit of those who either invest or have chosen to make a career in tourism.
Other Press Releases:
PR261930en
PRESS RELEASE BY THE MINISTRY FOR YOUTH, WELLBEING AND THE IMPLEMENTATION O...
PR261930