Left arrow Mur Lura

ANNUAL AUDIT REPORT ON THE PUBLIC ACCOUNTS 2006

pr1380E
Date Icon 29/09/2008

The Financial Report for year 2006 was submitted by the Accountant General in terms of the Financial Administration and Audit Act, 1962. Following examination, in terms of the Auditor General and National Audit Office Act, 1997, the NAO noted that:  

•        detailed analysis of variations for 2006 was not provided in respect of certain items of revenue; 

•        transactions dated 2007 were incorrectly reported in the 2006 financial year; 

•        debenture interests and loan repayments recorded as received from a public Corporation were effectively paid by Government; 

•        from the Lm11.90 million (€27.70 million) budgeted funds, only Lm5.50 million (€12.80 million) were actually used towards paying Treasury Clearance Fund Advances; 

•        the completeness of reporting of the Statements of Investments and Abandoned Claims, Cash Losses and Stores written off could not be ensured; and 

•        the Public Account for the period June 1992 – December 2001 has not yet been reconciled since Treasury is of the opinion that it is not feasible considering that the exercise has to be done manually.  

A number ofMinistries, Departments and Entities failed to send their annual 2006 Return of Arrears to the Treasury Department as stipulated in Treasury Circular 2/2007 for onward transmission to the NAO. Figures of some Departments had to be published as given. Some Departments also lacked submission of detailed breakdown of figures, hindering audit testing. A number of findings in the Courts of Justice, Ministry of Education, Youth and Employment, Ministry for Rural Affairs and the Environment are being separately reported upon.
The automatedattendance recording system at the Electoral Office was not being used after office hours to exercise the necessary controls on overtime.  The Salaries Section lacked segregation of duties and payments for overtime were not being independently verified. Employees and other third parties were being additionally compensated for work performed during office hours in connection with elections.  Certain remuneration bypassed the Final Settlement System for tax purposes.  Arrear charge approval was not sought to cover a budget overrun.
A number ofconcerns and weaknesses resulted following a review of the audit reports submitted by Local Government auditors for all Local Councils, including:

•        Thirty-four (34) audit reports representing fifty per cent (50%) of Local Councils were qualified; 

•        Ten (10) Local Councils recorded a negative working capital in the Statement of Affairs; 

•        Forty-nine (49) Audit Reports were delivered by 30 June 2007 while the other nineteen (19) did not meet the deadline.  The financial statements of one Local Council were not received for the second consecutive year; 

•        Twenty-three (23) Local Councils failed to submit a reply to the management letter by 31 October 2007. 

In themajority of cases no Joint Committees’ audit reports were available by the time the audit of the Local Councils was carried out.  In fact up to 31 October 2007, only one Joint Committee submitted the audited financial statements for the year under review. It is observed that no legislation regulating the submission of the Joint Committees’ financial statements is in place.
Eight LocalCouncils had a change in their Executive Secretary during the year.  However only one of these Councils carried out a mid-term audit as required in the Local Councils (Audit) Procedures 2006.  The mid-term audit is to serve as an independent hand-over exercise whenever an Executive Secretary leaves the employment of a Local Council and another is appointed.
A number ofaudits carried out at the Land Department revealed that:

•        The Account - ‘Acquisition of Property for Public Purposes’ has an opening balance which is being carried forward from previous years. The Department is not in a position to quantify this balance or to identify the properties to which this balance relates; 

•        Upon the signing of contracts, an amount equivalent to the total value of the immovable property acquired is transferred from the above stated Account to the Central Bank of Malta Account.  However, a breakdown indicating to which contracts this amount relates to was not made available;  

•        An exercise carried out on a sample of properties listed as vacant according to Departmental records showed that, in some cases, property was found to be illegally occupied. No action was being taken to allocate properties by tender, and no proper follow up was made on cases initiated.  

An audit onthe Issue of Visas at the Immigration Branch of the Police Department gives one to understand that the period being taken for the processing of application for extension of stay was too long. Furthermore, Immigration Officers’ decision for approval or non-approval was not sufficiently documented.
An audit ofthe Inventory at the Police Department showed that various shortcomings were noted when analysing the inventory database with regards to the valuation of motor vehicles and other assets, such as Furniture, Fixtures and Fittings.
Creditors inrespect of Medicines and Surgical Materials at the Government Pharmaceutical Services increased throughout the year by Lm2.80 million (€6.52 million) and totalled Lm12.20 million (€28.42 million) as at 31 December 2006, of which thirty-one per cent (31%) were outstanding for over 150 days.  Furthermore, by the end of July 2007 about Lm16.90 million (€39.37 million) were already paid in respect of Medicines and Surgical Materials.
A number ofcontrol and compliance weaknesses were noted in an audit carried out on Contractual and Professional Services at the Health Division.
The winterschedule of most Departments falling under the Rural Affairs and Paying Agency is fifteen (15) minutes daily short of the Public Service’s official timetable without being compensated for in the summer months. Attendance sheets of previous years were not made available for audit purposes. Timely authorisation to work overtime was not obtained from the Permanent Secretary.  Various other shortcomings were noted in the payment of overtime.
A number ofSocial Assistance beneficiaries in a selected sample were receiving an incorrect rate of benefit. The Automatic Assessment for Social Assistance introduced in March 2005 was barely being used as a result of the very complex process of inputting data. Various weaknesses were noted with respect to medical panel reviews.
TheMinistry of Foreign Affairs lacked adequate control on travel expenditure, potentially contributing to an increase of twenty five percent (25%) over the original budget.  Agendas or programmes relating to visits abroad were not found in any of the advances files. Certain expenses paid through the Ministry’s credit card were not deducted from the subsistence allowance. Documentation supporting travel abroad was at times incomplete and unclear. Approvals for hospitality expenditure as well as that for the purchase of a number of assets were only obtained after the expenditure was incurred. Furthermore, payments were not always supported by a fiscal document.
An audit ofthe Welfare Committee, covering the year ended 31 December 2005, revealed the following weaknesses:

•        The accounting treatment of capital expenditure and its release to the Income Statement in the year of completion is not always in full compliance with International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRSs); 

•        No formal budgeting process of a capital project was carried out prior to issuing the tender documents for initialisation of a project; 

•        No approval was sought or granted for variations that exceeded the 20% limit stipulated in the tender conditions in respect of various items in the original bills of quantity in the contract for Demolition, Construction and Finishing; 

•        The Committee lacks a formal plan of work schedule including proper cash flow budgeting; 

•        Inaccuracies were detected in a tender awarded following adjudication. In addition, enhancements were also added to certain items following adjudication.  

NAO facedlimitations on the scope of its audit in examining Customs procedures regarding withheld, seized and forfeited merchandise. Proper procedures regarding destruction of goods and valuation were not in place. Lack of security and stock control deficiencies were also noted.
A high levelof reliance was placed on the work carried out by the outsourced company managing the Training and Employment Exposure Scheme although the onus of this scheme lied with the Employment and Training Corporation.  Insufficient checks on invoices have been carried out though these were certified correct for payment.
Site visitsby the Malta Tourism Authority (MTA) were not always carried out to ensure that all the products and services, co-financed out of public funds, have been delivered on location and according to specifications, prior to the issuing of reimbursements to Final Recipients.  Late verifications on location at the start of the project were also ineffective.
Contributionsand licences collected by the MTA were based on incomplete information that was received from the Malta Maritime Authority and local Police Stations respectively which previously administered the foregoing revenue.

The full Report can be viewed on the NAO Website: http://www.nao.gov.mt with effect from 30 September, 2008.

Ixxerja din l-istqarrija Icon socials Icon socials Icon socials Icon socials

Stqarrijiet Oħra:

STQARRIJA MIS-SEGRETARJAT PARLAMENTARI FIL-MINISTERU GĦALL-ENERĠIJA, L-AMBJENT U R-RIĠENERAZZJONI TAL-PORT IL-KBIR  Imħabbra passi konkreti dwar il-ħarsien tal-annimali f’pajjiżna waqt laqgħa mal-għaqdiet volontarji fis-settur

PR261978

STQARRIJA MIS-SEGRETARJAT PARLAMENTARI FIL-MINISTERU GĦALL-ENERĠIJA, L-AMBJ...

STQARRIJA MILL-UFFIĊĊJU TAD-DEPUTAT PRIM MINISTRU U MINISTERU GĦAS-SAĦĦA  “Is-suċċess tas-saħħa pubblika jitkejjel ukoll minn dak li jirnexxilna nevitaw” – Id-Deputat Prim Ministru Ian Borg

PR261977

STQARRIJA MILL-UFFIĊĊJU TAD-DEPUTAT PRIM MINISTRU U MINISTERU GĦAS-SAĦĦA “...

Aktar Stqarrijiet Right arrow