Address by the Deputy Prime Minister and Minister for Justice and Home affairs, the Hon. Tonio Borg at the Justice and Home Affairs Council in Luxembourg - Tuesday 12th June 2007
Mr President,
Dear colleagues,
In the past years I have addressed this Council on the human tragedy unfolding in the Central Mediterranean, at the same period of the year, practically involving the same annual number of fatalities. A conservative estimate is that 600 persons died on the doorstep of Europe last year trying to reach the Continent. A similar number will undoubtedly lose their lives again this year.
The recent incidents which were grossly misreported in the international press have again drawn attention to this area of Europe`s borders but such interest - till now - has degenerated into an exercise of finger pointing, a typical example of burden shifting rather than burden sharing. For instance, an incident 60 nautical miles off Libya and 120 nautical miles off Malta is described as one “off the coast of Malta” not that of Libya.
The answer which no one has given after these incidents is the following: which country should accept immigrants saved from the international waters off a non-EU state in an area where rescues are supposed to be coordinated by this same non-EU state?
This question is a very different one to that concerning who is responsible for rescuing lives at sea; for this latter question the answer is simple and clear: the vessel which is nearest to a distress signal is in duty bound by international law to go to the rescue. But this answer is being mixed up with that of the first question concerning who takes responsibility for receiving these persons once they are no longer in danger?
Of course, these issues have arisen because when the Safety of Life at Sea rules and conventions were drafted, they were not intended for this type of rescuing operations of boats laden with immigrants trying to cross the seas to Europe, but to mishaps at sea where international coordination might be necessary to rescue people from sinking ships or crashed aircraft.
A cursory look at the map which has been attached to the Dossier distributed, will indicate the vast seas in the central Mediterranean and the exact location of recent incidents in the Libyan controlled search and rescue zone. They are clearly outside Malta`s 250,000 square kilometre search and rescue region. Just for the record, Malta’s zone is not a small zone – it is the same size as the land area of the United Kingdom.
The Maltese authorities in the past weeks, as always, in spite of their limited resources have rescued hundreds of immigrants on their way to the European mainland who found themselves in difficulties. I need not give any assurances about rescuing life at sea – the obligations on all are clear – and my country needs no lessons on such matters .
Over the past fifteen days alone Malta has rescued and brought ashore 237 illegal migrants in ten separate incidents, and 350 persons have been saved from certain death since the beginning of the current year. Since 2002, over 7,000 persons, most of them in imminent danger, were rescued and brought over to Malta. That is like 1.4 million being rescued by the German Coast guard over the same period.
Firstly, in the so called tuna pen incident, immigrants spent slightly over 24 hours standing or sitting on the walkways of a tuna pen 60 miles off the Libyan coast and therefore well within its search and rescue area. The Libyan authorities promised on three occasions that they would send first a helicopter and then a patrol boat to assist; notwithstanding these assurances it transpired that they sent nothing. The captain of the private vessel was nevertheless given instructions by Malta to take the persons onto his vessel if they were in danger. They were eventually taken on board a large Italian vessel and transported to the Italian island of Lampedusa which, in any case, was closer to the incident than Malta.
Secondly, it is patently not true that the Maltese authorities refused to accept the corpses of persons who drowned in Libyan SAR and were picked up by a French military vessel. Indeed Malta’s Foreign Minister personally called the French Ambassador informing him that Malta was ready to accept such corpses even if Libya would not co-operate in that respect. He said that Malta would not create an issue about this, but that it would be wrong to “let the Libyans off the hook” and that he requested that Libya would be asked to take responsibility for its search and rescue area.
Thirdly, the Spanish trawler incident raised the question which I have already mentioned of who is responsible for accepting immigrants when they have been rescued from the international waters coordinated for rescue purposes by a non-EU state.
The proposal or rather assumption that Malta should take responsibility for receiving these immigrants is as nonsensical as it is unreasonable. We do not believe this to be “a legal bureaucratic argument”, but one which has serious ramifications. If a person is rescued from the Search and Rescue Area of a non-EU state, why on earth should Malta be targeted as the country responsible for receiving these immigrants especially when they are no longer in danger? Under which law, tradition or custom is one Member State ‘designated’ by another as responsible to receive these illegal immigrants? I would have thought that last year’s similar incident would have indicated that only burden-sharing can cater for such situations.
In other incidents involving issues unrelated to immigration, we member states rightly rallied behind any other member state which was unjustly treated by a non-EU country; in immigration matters, however, the rules appear to work differently.
You might have by now noticed that we are, to put it mildly, extremely irritated by the way we have been treated on this matter. However, I prefer to look ahead and try and find a solution, based on consensus, for similar incidents in the future.
My proposal is that, as a first step, an agreement be reached as soon as possible so that, in the future, should an EU vessel save lives at sea in a search and rescue area belonging to a non-EU state, and the latter refuses to co-operate in receiving such rescued persons, then such immigrants should be directed to the nearest EU Member State and then be immediately transferred to one of the 27 member states of the European Union on a strictly proportional basis and according to a system agreed beforehand.
This means that the EU member state nearest to the location of the incident will temporarily accept such immigrants until they are transferred to another EU Member State in accordance with such system. Any asylum application will be treated by the authorities of such designated member state of destination, which will also be responsible for repatriation should such application fail.
The system of assignment shall be agreed beforehand based on different criteria the most important ones obviously being size of territory and population.
Furthermore, UNHCR should be approached by the Commission to accept that the number of such immigrants so received who, after due processing, are considered to be refugees or persons eligible for humanitarian status, would be deducted from the refugee/immigrant humanitarian quota which such receiving EU country would have agreed with UNHCR.
This arrangement should, we believe, not only apply to the Mediterranean region but to any maritime region which lies in Europe`s neighbourhood.
Until such rules of engagement are agreed, the area between the North African coast and the SAR area of MS will unfortunately remain a free-for-all zone as it is today; such rules on the other hand would give comfort to vessels rescuing immigrants knowing fully well that a pre-arranged scheme will guarantee a country of destination which will accept them
Finally, I would like to remark that the request for participation in Frontex operations in the central Mediterranean region has till now received, to put it mildly, a miserly response. The surveillance of European` s southern borders cannot be left in the hands of the peripheral states only. In all probability had a decent Frontex operation been in place, the incidents which I have just mentioned might have been avoided.
In the past I have campaigned, and will continue to lobby in the future, in favour of a burden sharing which is real and is replete with meaning that is to say; that any border state unduly burdened by a sudden influx of immigrants be allowed to share part of its burden with other member states. Am I therefore asking too much in proposing that at least persons saved at sea by EU vessels in areas falling under the responsibility of third states be shared between the Member States? .
Malta will certainly not allow itself to be anointed, by circumstances or sheer lack of solidarity, the lonely sentinel of Europe`s southern borders. I am confident that the EU will give its due attention to this area of Europe`s doorstep teeming with dead bodies on its southern border.
Other Press Releases:
PR261966en
PRESS RELEASE BY THE MINISTRY FOR ENERGY, THE ENVIRONMENT AND THE REGENERAT...
PR261966