Left arrow Mur Lura

Address by The Hon. Helen D’Amato, Parliamentary Secretary for the Elderly and Community Care, during a seminar organized by the ‘Bioethics Consultative Committee on “The Body as Passports; Biometrics and its Social, Ethical and Political Implications”

pr0636
Date Icon 28/04/2006

Distinguished guests and participants, 

Whenever I come across the word ‘biometrics’, I am invariably struck by the very close affinity that exists between this ground-breaking and avant-garde system of personal identification and the ageless field of health. As the central object of concern of medical science, the human body, with its many facets, is truly the most distinctive and immediately recognizable mark of a person’s identity. Since time immemorial, human beings have been able to identify each other on the basis of their faces, voices and many other distinguishable physical traits. 

In today’s complex and globalized world, the need to identify people quickly and unerringly is ever stronger. In the midst of the enormous everyday flow of people across national borders, people with serious criminal records need to be sifted out and barred from stepping on foreign soil. In the realm of finance, the increasing audacity of fraudsters who try all possible means to gain illegal access to the bank accounts of unwary individuals and organizations requires an ever sturdier security response.  

By using the individual’s unique bodily features as the basis of the identification process, biometrics promises to deliver a system of personal identification that is securer than any other technique and thus less vulnerable to the manipulations of identity thieves. The arguments brought forward by those advocating in favour of the use of this new technology are based on the fact that unlike the various passwords and cards that have been used to date, biometric data can be neither forgotten, nor stolen nor forged, hence claiming that biometric technology is the answer to the urgent security concerns of the twenty-first century. However, we have to acknowledge that concerns about identity thefts have still to be resolved and adequate safeguards should be in place.     

Alongside those who champion the potential of biometrics to make our lives more secure, there are many others who harbour deep misgivings about the intrinsic tendency of this technology to invade the privacy of citizens. In part, these fears are subjective and stem from the understandable reluctance of people to being physically probed for identification on the basis of biometric data,that is information about their bodies, stored in a database.  

Other concerns are more objective and relate to the perceived danger that such personal information may be misused by governments or powerful organizations to pry into the private affairs of citizens thereby diminishing the personal liberties of law-abiding members of the public. There is also serious apprehension at the possibility of biometrics being associated with severe miscarriages of justice, such as if a person’s DNA were to be planted at the scene of a crime, or an individual impersonating another without arousing suspicion by associating his biometrics with another’s identity.  

Some of the more immediate reservations that people have about biometrics are invariably linked to health. For instance, ordinary citizens are concerned that a biometric technology like retinal scanning could cause injury on the back of the eye. Even though this possibility has so far not been borne out by scientific research, this has done little to allay fears that it could really happen. Authorities and companies planning to introduce biometrics will first have to reassure people about the safety of these technologies and that these could not cause irreparable damage to the individual’s health and well-being.  

Also raising concerns is the possibility that biometric data might reveal sensitive health information. According to an EU-commissioned technical report called ‘Biometrics at the Frontiers: Assessing the Impact on Society’,  the claim that the iris exposes potential health problems is not scientifically founded, even though here again perception may be more detrimental than reality to the chances of biometrics ever becoming the standard instrument of personal identification. The authors of the report are less skeptical about the concern that retinal scanning could enable detection of a subject’s vascular dysfunction as well as of the scenario of face recognition being used to detect emotional conditions such as depression. 

While a clearer light needs to be shed on these points, one should not rule out the possibility of biometrics playing a prominent role in our country’s health care some time in the future. After all, a reliable means of personal identification is a necessary component of a modern and efficient health care system. Information about a person’s medical history is notoriously very sensitive data to which only select individuals should have access.  

On the other hand, in today’s highly complex and specialized health care it is very important that medical practitioners should be able to access patient files relatively easily so as to be able to offer the best care possible. This is all the more so when patients travel overseas to receive highly specialized care, a practice that is especially relevant in the light of the increasing cooperation among the member-states of the EU in the care of European citizens. 

I believe that the present skepticism that exists with regard to biometrics can only be met with the promulgation of clear and reliable information on the potential benefits of this new technology and the legal and technical safeguards that can be put in place to protect the privacy of individuals. Governments and authorities should involve their citizens in the debate and eventual introduction of biometrics in order to avoid being perceived as though they are trying to ram biometrics down people’s throats. Sounding the mantra of security will not suffice to dispel fears and concerns. Like the introduction of any foreign body in the organism of our society, we should be ever mindful of the risk of rejection.  

And it is with this in mind that we are meeting today to study, discuss and identify problems that may arise when this new technology is used more widely to complement the more conventional methods of identification. May I thus wish you a most fruitful and illuminating discussion of this very important and topical issue.  

Thank you.

Ixxerja din l-istqarrija Icon socials Icon socials Icon socials Icon socials

Stqarrijiet Oħra:

STQARRIJA MILL-MINISTERU GĦALL-AGRIKOLTURA, IS-SAJD U L-PROVVISTA TAL-IKEL  Il-Ministru Anton Refalo jżur il-proġett tat-trobbija u r-ripopolazzjoni tar-rizzi tal-baħar f’Torri San Luċjan

PR261957

STQARRIJA MILL-MINISTERU GĦALL-AGRIKOLTURA, IS-SAJD U L-PROVVISTA TAL-IKEL ...

STQARRIJA MILL-MINISTERU GĦALL-INKLUŻJONI U L-VOLONTARJAT U MILL-MINISTERU GĦALL-POLITIKA SOĊJALI U L-FAMILJA  Malta tlaqqa’ esperti Ewropej dwar l-inklużjoni tat-tfal b’diżabilità u s-sostenn lill-familji tagħhom

PR261956

STQARRIJA MILL-MINISTERU GĦALL-INKLUŻJONI U L-VOLONTARJAT U MILL-MINISTERU ...

Aktar Stqarrijiet Right arrow