SPEECH BY THE HON. EDWIN VASSALLO, PARLIAMENTARY SECRETARY FOR SMALL BUSINESS AND THE SELF-EMPLOYED, AT THE THIRD SEMINAR ORGANISED BY THE MALTA INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT: “THE INSTRUMENTS TO FINANCE BUSINESS GROWTH” – VALLETTA - 9 JUNE 2004
Ladies and gentlemen, distinguished guests,
I am sure that after this series of informative and interesting seminars, you all now have a much better insight of the instruments that finance growth. I must admit that I am no technical expert in this field, and most probably I shall not be adding much in the way of academia, but I promise to give you as clear a picture as possible, of the realities of our market, with special reference to our small businesses and the self-employed. I shall proceed to briefly give an overview of the subject of access to finance in our small business sector, and then proceed to outline the strengths, weaknesses, opportunities and threats that our business sector faces.
Lack of access to financing is viewed as one of the most significant barriers to start-up and growth of small businesses. In fact, in our country this problem does not seem to be lack of availability, but rather lack of access. In other words, although the traditional commercial lenders do not lack supply of capital, there seems to be lack of know-how and ability to secure it by SME's.
It is a fact that traditional lenders view small business lending as less profitable than larger loans to larger firms. This is mainly because of the higher transaction costs, as well as the risk involved which are perceived to have a higher failure rate. In some respects, with the increase in competition brought about by globalisation and the opening of markets, it is becoming more difficult for firms to obtain debt financing, because they are less likely to have capital assets to act as collateral security for loans and because their needs are for working capital (for compliance costs, research and development, marketing, hiring, and so on.) This creates problems for traditional lenders who prefer to offer secured lending and has led to a need for new loan and quasi-equity products. It has also led to a growing interest in and demand for private investment, angel financing, venture capital and stock market listings.
In this regard, one of the key issues within my responsibilities as Parliamentary Secretary for Small Business and the Self Employed has been how to address this gap in accessing finance. Should Government become an active player in delivering financial assistance programmes to small firms? Or is it better for government to engage the traditional lenders in discussions in an effort to try and persuade, even facilitate these institutions to reserve part of their portfolio of lending to small firms with special needs, with surgical needs?
Access to finance is indeed also one of the pillars on which the European Charter for Small Enterprises is based. Improving access to finance throughout the entire life cycle of an enterprise is, as a consequence, a principle of this Charter, out of which clear lines of action on access to finance are outlined.
Clearly the European Charter in this area states, and I quote:
Tax systems should be adapted to reward success, encourage start-ups, favour small business expansion and job creation, and facilitate the creation of, and succession in, small enterprises. Member States should apply best practice to taxation and to access to finance initiatives.
Entrepreneurs need finance to translate ambitions into reality. In order to improve access of small enterprises to financial services, we will:
Identify and remove barriers to the creation of a pan-European capital market and the implementation of the Financial Services Action Plan and the Risk Capital Action Plan of the European Commission;
Improve the relationship between the banking system and small enterprises by creating appropriate access conditions to credit and to venture capital;
Improve the access to the structural funds and welcome initiatives by the European Investment bank to increase funding available to start-ups and high technology enterprises, including equity instruments.
In parallel, my Secretariat’s work plan for 2003-2004 which contains 54 initiatives, is entitled Towards the implementation of an Entrepreneurial Policy where YOU, the individual in business are a priority. It is inspired by the European Charter for Small Enterprises and I have endeavoured to transpose each line of action in the Charter to the local scenario, translated into a number of concrete objectives which I strived to achieve during the past political year.
In this regard I shall now present to you each line of action in the work plan under the taxation and financial matters, with an account indicating how effective we have been under each action to achieve the required objective, according to an implementation report published by the Small Businesses and Crafts Directorate some weeks ago.
Extract of initiatives from the Work Plan 2003
Initiative
39. VAT and tax collection systems must be business friendly. On the other hand, whoever is in business must understand the obligation to pay his tax dues. We cannot remain in a situation where the Authorities think that all those in business evade tax. At the same time tax evasion has to be eradicated. In this conflict everybody stands to lose. Both the State and Businesses will lose.
The state has the right to collect amounts due to him but this must be done in a just manner, avoiding tax collection procedures which are prejudiced against the entrepreneur. Until this comes into effect we cannot expect to see justice being done between both parties. For this purpose we need to reach a point where both parties understand the obligations and responsibilities they have towards each other.
In the 2002 Budget, government has started a process of fiscal simplification that needs to continue and be developed so that with time we will have a society where both the state and businesses realise how they can better support each other.
Implementation of Initiative
· The Small Business and Crafts Directorate have collected all the issues which were received by the Call Centre. These were forwarded to the Parliamentary Secretary responsible for VAT and Income Tax, and were subsequently discussed with a view to finding solutions. It was agreed that these meetings would be held on a regular basis.
· The Parliamentary Secretary put forward proposals to the Tax Compliance Unit with the aim of facilitating the financial environment of small business.
Initiative
40. Schemes will be set-up offering financial incentives to businessmen who are also employers especially with regards to the training of employees.
Implementation of Initiative
· Entrepreneurs situated in MDC industrial estates were invited to attend at information seminars regarding fiscal and other incentives in the Business Promotion Act.
· Legal Notice 128 of 2003 regarding incentives by the Business Promotion Act was published.
Initiative
41. There is a need for financial incentives for those businesses that do not qualify for assistance under the Business Promotion Act. Such schemes are necessary to fill the void created when the Banking Sector started to change its priorities looking less favourably at Small Businesses.
Implementation of Initiative
· B.O.V. has proposed a number of schemes addressed to specific sectors including women in business
· 3 schemes were launched by MaltaEnterprise:
· support schemes for the food processing sector
· support schemes to assist compliance
· support schemes to assist entrepreneurs and craftsmen at the
Ta’ QaliCraftsVillage.
Initiative
42. There will be an analysis of the practices by the Banks, Institute for the Promotion of Small Enterprises, and the Malta Development Corporation to study Financial Accessibility for people in business. We will ensure that people who are in need of financial assistance will find it. For this purpose the annual seminar on financial assistance will continue to be organised.
Implementation of Initiative
· A number of meetings were held with MaltaEnterprise, H.S.B.C., B.O.V. and A.P.S. regarding the possibility of developing micro-loans products
· B.O.V. is preparing special schemes for small entrepreneurs. MaltaEnterprisehas issued a call for proposals for a number of support measures targeting micor-enterprises and SME’s.
Initiative
43. I.P.S.E will launch a scheme for those who are leasing industrial space from the M.D.C at the CraftsVillagein Ta’ Qali.
Implementation of Initiative
· A number of meetings were held with the Commercial Banks and IPSE on this theme.
· A scheme of assistance was launched by Malta Enterprise to each and every prospective tenant in the Ta' Qali Crafts Village .
Initiative
44. Persons developing industrial areas in the Micro Enterprise Parks will be assisted through the Business Promotion Act together with other schemes that will be co-ordinted by the commercial banks for this purpose.
Implementation of Initiative
· No agreement has as yet been reached in this area.
Initiative
45. The possibility of setting up local credit rating system and credit insurance will be explored.
Implementation of Initiative
· The MaltaAssociation of Credit Management (MACM) has been set up as a voluntary initiative by entrepreneurs to provide credit information.
Initiative number effectiveness rate
Initiative 39 60%
Initiative 40 65%
Initiative 41 40%
Initiative 42 60%
Initiative 43 80%
Initiative 44 10%
Initiative 45 75%
Total 55.71%
I shall now, as promised earlier, move on to give you an insight into the strengths, weaknesses, opportunities and threats which in my view, are being faced by our small business sector.
The strength of our small business sector is evident by the way in which it is growing. According to data published by the National Statistics Office the number of small businesses has been increasing year after year, thus showing clearly that this sector is a growth sector and one which is performing well with minimal, if any, state aid (vide doc. 1). Small businesses are also earning more per enterprise and this indicates that the value added provided by this sector is growing. (vide doc. 2).
The weaknesses of this sector are mainly that this sector is highly fragmented, is facing considerable compliance costs and lacks adequate information on current legislation, including standards and health and safety directives and other regulations that affect the business environment.
The threats facing the small business sector are mainly evidenced in the implementation report above which indicate that more still needs to be done across Government to walk the talk in that small enterprises are the backbone of the economy and are a key source of jobs and a breeding ground for business ideas. Small businesses and the self-employed are not a monopoly of my Secretariat or the directorates under the Ministry’s responsibility, but they are rather the responsibility of all Ministries across Government. In this regard, synergy across Government is required for the best possible environment for small business and entrepreneurship to be created.
As you may have noticed, I have switched the order of the SWAT analysis in order to end this discussion on a positive note, because indeed I believe that notwithstanding, the future for small businesses is bright, maybe even the brightest it has ever been.
Malta ’s accession process to the EU has been the driving force for new ideas. It has helped our country to understand better that we should look at small enterprises and the individual in business under a different light. As a Government we are sharing experiences and best practices in the small business sector with other new and established member states. It is essential to be flexible enough so as to learn from other countries, that like us are doing their utmost to develop entrepreneurial policy.
An entrepreneurial policy helps us to better understand how a small business operates. A change in mentality in the way we look at the business sector is needed, just as the business sector is changing the mentality in which it operates, by raising standards, by networking and by the way it obtains finance.
The opportunities are there for all. Getting more out of the single market is also a priority area of the Small Business Charter. The Commission together with the member states are pursuing the reforms underway to have across the EU a true internal market, which is truly user friendly for small businesses, in critical areas for development of small businesses including electronic commerce, telecommunications, utilities, public procurement and cross-border payment systems and access to finance.
For these opportunities to materialise, we must not only ensure that our small businesses have every chance to grow, enter new markets and compete on a level playing field locally and within the EU, but above all, we need to listen to small businesses. I have kept a full and regular schedule of meetings and public consultation with people in business, in local councils, in commercial areas and in industrial estates. I endeavour to remain close to all those who want to talk to me, any day and everyday – especially in this critical transition period. In this respect, I believe we have established an important trait, which implies that whoever is responsible for small business and the self-employed cannot remain behind a desk but must go out and experience first-hand what is happening in the commercial sector. Ladies and gentlemen, distinguished guests,
I am sure that after this series of informative and interesting seminars, you all now have a much better insight of the instruments that finance growth. I must admit that I am no technical expert in this field, and most probably I shall not be adding much in the way of academia, but I promise to give you as clear a picture as possible, of the realities of our market, with special reference to our small businesses and the self-employed. I shall proceed to briefly give an overview of the subject of access to finance in our small business sector, and then proceed to outline the strengths, weaknesses, opportunities and threats that our business sector faces.
Lack of access to financing is viewed as one of the most significant barriers to start-up and growth of small businesses. In fact, in our country this problem does not seem to be lack of availability, but rather lack of access. In other words, although the traditional commercial lenders do not lack supply of capital, there seems to be lack of know-how and ability to secure it by SME's.
It is a fact that traditional lenders view small business lending as less profitable than larger loans to larger firms. This is mainly because of the higher transaction costs, as well as the risk involved which are perceived to have a higher failure rate. In some respects, with the increase in competition brought about by globalisation and the opening of markets, it is becoming more difficult for firms to obtain debt financing, because they are less likely to have capital assets to act as collateral security for loans and because their needs are for working capital (for compliance costs, research and development, marketing, hiring, and so on.) This creates problems for traditional lenders who prefer to offer secured lending and has led to a need for new loan and quasi-equity products. It has also led to a growing interest in and demand for private investment, angel financing, venture capital and stock market listings.
In this regard, one of the key issues within my responsibilities as Parliamentary Secretary for Small Business and the Self Employed has been how to address this gap in accessing finance. Should Government become an active player in delivering financial assistance programmes to small firms? Or is it better for government to engage the traditional lenders in discussions in an effort to try and persuade, even facilitate these institutions to reserve part of their portfolio of lending to small firms with special needs, with surgical needs?
Access to finance is indeed also one of the pillars on which the European Charter for Small Enterprises is based. Improving access to finance throughout the entire life cycle of an enterprise is, as a consequence, a principle of this Charter, out of which clear lines of action on access to finance are outlined.
Clearly the European Charter in this area states, and I quote:
Tax systems should be adapted to reward success, encourage start-ups, favour small business expansion and job creation, and facilitate the creation of, and succession in, small enterprises. Member States should apply best practice to taxation and to access to finance initiatives.
Entrepreneurs need finance to translate ambitions into reality. In order to improve access of small enterprises to financial services, we will:
Identify and remove barriers to the creation of a pan-European capital market and the implementation of the Financial Services Action Plan and the Risk Capital Action Plan of the European Commission;
Improve the relationship between the banking system and small enterprises by creating appropriate access conditions to credit and to venture capital;
Improve the access to the structural funds and welcome initiatives by the European Investment bank to increase funding available to start-ups and high technology enterprises, including equity instruments.
In parallel, my Secretariat’s work plan for 2003-2004 which contains 54 initiatives, is entitled Towards the implementation of an Entrepreneurial Policy where YOU, the individual in business are a priority. It is inspired by the European Charter for Small Enterprises and I have endeavoured to transpose each line of action in the Charter to the local scenario, translated into a number of concrete objectives which I strived to achieve during the past political year.
In this regard I shall now present to you each line of action in the work plan under the taxation and financial matters, with an account indicating how effective we have been under each action to achieve the required objective, according to an implementation report published by the Small Businesses and Crafts Directorate some weeks ago.
Extract of initiatives from the Work Plan 2003
Initiative
39. VAT and tax collection systems must be business friendly. On the other hand, whoever is in business must understand the obligation to pay his tax dues. We cannot remain in a situation where the Authorities think that all those in business evade tax. At the same time tax evasion has to be eradicated. In this conflict everybody stands to lose. Both the State and Businesses will lose.
The state has the right to collect amounts due to him but this must be done in a just manner, avoiding tax collection procedures which are prejudiced against the entrepreneur. Until this comes into effect we cannot expect to see justice being done between both parties. For this purpose we need to reach a point where both parties understand the obligations and responsibilities they have towards each other.
In the 2002 Budget, government has started a process of fiscal simplification that needs to continue and be developed so that with time we will have a society where both the state and businesses realise how they can better support each other.
Implementation of Initiative
· The Small Business and Crafts Directorate have collected all the issues which were received by the Call Centre. These were forwarded to the Parliamentary Secretary responsible for VAT and Income Tax, and were subsequently discussed with a view to finding solutions. It was agreed that these meetings would be held on a regular basis.
· The Parliamentary Secretary put forward proposals to the Tax Compliance Unit with the aim of facilitating the financial environment of small business.
Initiative
40. Schemes will be set-up offering financial incentives to businessmen who are also employers especially with regards to the training of employees.
Implementation of Initiative
· Entrepreneurs situated in MDC industrial estates were invited to attend at information seminars regarding fiscal and other incentives in the Business Promotion Act.
· Legal Notice 128 of 2003 regarding incentives by the Business Promotion Act was published.
Initiative
41. There is a need for financial incentives for those businesses that do not qualify for assistance under the Business Promotion Act. Such schemes are necessary to fill the void created when the Banking Sector started to change its priorities looking less favourably at Small Businesses.
Implementation of Initiative
· B.O.V. has proposed a number of schemes addressed to specific sectors including women in business
· 3 schemes were launched by MaltaEnterprise:
· support schemes for the food processing sector
· support schemes to assist compliance
· support schemes to assist entrepreneurs and craftsmen at the
Ta’ QaliCraftsVillage.
Initiative
42. There will be an analysis of the practices by the Banks, Institute for the Promotion of Small Enterprises, and the Malta Development Corporation to study Financial Accessibility for people in business. We will ensure that people who are in need of financial assistance will find it. For this purpose the annual seminar on financial assistance will continue to be organised.
Implementation of Initiative
· A number of meetings were held with MaltaEnterprise, H.S.B.C., B.O.V. and A.P.S. regarding the possibility of developing micro-loans products
· B.O.V. is preparing special schemes for small entrepreneurs. MaltaEnterprisehas issued a call for proposals for a number of support measures targeting micor-enterprises and SME’s.
Initiative
43. I.P.S.E will launch a scheme for those who are leasing industrial space from the M.D.C at the CraftsVillagein Ta’ Qali.
Implementation of Initiative
· A number of meetings were held with the Commercial Banks and IPSE on this theme.
· A scheme of assistance was launched by Malta Enterprise to each and every prospective tenant in the Ta' Qali Crafts Village .
Initiative
44. Persons developing industrial areas in the Micro Enterprise Parks will be assisted through the Business Promotion Act together with other schemes that will be co-ordinted by the commercial banks for this purpose.
Implementation of Initiative
· No agreement has as yet been reached in this area.
Initiative
45. The possibility of setting up local credit rating system and credit insurance will be explored.
Implementation of Initiative
· The MaltaAssociation of Credit Management (MACM) has been set up as a voluntary initiative by entrepreneurs to provide credit information.
Initiative number effectiveness rate
Initiative 39 60%
Initiative 40 65%
Initiative 41 40%
Initiative 42 60%
Initiative 43 80%
Initiative 44 10%
Initiative 45 75%
Total 55.71%
I shall now, as promised earlier, move on to give you an insight into the strengths, weaknesses, opportunities and threats which in my view, are being faced by our small business sector.
The strength of our small business sector is evident by the way in which it is growing. According to data published by the National Statistics Office the number of small businesses has been increasing year after year, thus showing clearly that this sector is a growth sector and one which is performing well with minimal, if any, state aid (vide doc. 1). Small businesses are also earning more per enterprise and this indicates that the value added provided by this sector is growing. (vide doc. 2).
The weaknesses of this sector are mainly that this sector is highly fragmented, is facing considerable compliance costs and lacks adequate information on current legislation, including standards and health and safety directives and other regulations that affect the business environment.
The threats facing the small business sector are mainly evidenced in the implementation report above which indicate that more still needs to be done across Government to walk the talk in that small enterprises are the backbone of the economy and are a key source of jobs and a breeding ground for business ideas. Small businesses and the self-employed are not a monopoly of my Secretariat or the directorates under the Ministry’s responsibility, but they are rather the responsibility of all Ministries across Government. In this regard, synergy across Government is required for the best possible environment for small business and entrepreneurship to be created.
As you may have noticed, I have switched the order of the SWAT analysis in order to end this discussion on a positive note, because indeed I believe that notwithstanding, the future for small businesses is bright, maybe even the brightest it has ever been.
Malta ’s accession process to the EU has been the driving force for new ideas. It has helped our country to understand better that we should look at small enterprises and the individual in business under a different light. As a Government we are sharing experiences and best practices in the small business sector with other new and established member states. It is essential to be flexible enough so as to learn from other countries, that like us are doing their utmost to develop entrepreneurial policy.
An entrepreneurial policy helps us to better understand how a small business operates. A change in mentality in the way we look at the business sector is needed, just as the business sector is changing the mentality in which it operates, by raising standards, by networking and by the way it obtains finance.
The opportunities are there for all. Getting more out of the single market is also a priority area of the Small Business Charter. The Commission together with the member states are pursuing the reforms underway to have across the EU a true internal market, which is truly user friendly for small businesses, in critical areas for development of small businesses including electronic commerce, telecommunications, utilities, public procurement and cross-border payment systems and access to finance.
For these opportunities to materialise, we must not only ensure that our small businesses have every chance to grow, enter new markets and compete on a level playing field locally and within the EU, but above all, we need to listen to small businesses. I have kept a full and regular schedule of meetings and public consultation with people in business, in local councils, in commercial areas and in industrial estates. I endeavour to remain close to all those who want to talk to me, any day and everyday – especially in this critical transition period. In this respect, I believe we have established an important trait, which implies that whoever is responsible for small business and the self-employed cannot remain behind a desk but must go out and experience first-hand what is happening in the commercial sector.
Other Press Releases:
PR261938en
PRESS RELEASE BY THE MINISTRY FOR EQUALITY AND CIVIL RIGHTS Malta records o...
PR261938