Left arrow Mur Lura

ADDRESS BY THE HON. LOUIS DEGUARA, MINISTER FOR HEALTH, THE ELDERLY AND COMMUNITY CARE, AT THE 10TH PLENARY ASSEMBLY OF ‘HOPE’ – THE STANDING COMMITTEE OF THE HOSPITALS OF THE EUROPEAN UNION - ATTARD – 4 JUNE 2004

PR954
Date Icon 04/06/2004

Merhba mill-qalb gewwa Malta. A warm welcome to Malta.  Merhba to the Tenth Plenary Assembly of HOPE - the Standing Committee of the Hospitals of the European Union. 

We feel honoured to be the first of the new EU members to host a Plenary Assembly of HOPE. I therefore consider it appropriate to thank the organizers of this plenary and the head of our delegation Dr. J. Cachia who have made this possible. I vividly remember John’s enthusiasm soon after the re-activation of Malta’s application for membership of the EU in 1999, for Malta to become an observer member of HOPE. I shared his enthusiasm aware that NGOs such as HOPE are highly regarded and are influential on the European health care scene. My government is looking forward to working in partnership with such organizations to ensure the future viability of high standards of health care for all, across Europe.

To the public in general May 1st. meant that Malta had at last found its rightful place amongst its European counterparts. We celebrated this hallmark event in our history with pride and a sense of fulfillment. With the inclusion of the new ten member states the dream of the total unification of Europe has become irreversible. It is now our task together to build Europe into the leading political, cultural and economic player in the world.

My Government is determined to make Malta’s membership of the European Union a success story.  In the health sector we are more than convinced that this is already being achieved. Malta has always striven to find a balance between effective health gain and meeting individual patient demands. The results of our health outcomes demonstrate that we have been successful. Twice WHO has over the past five years classified our health care system amongst the very top. WHO’s most recent comparative assessment still finds our health system comparing very favourably with the levels of the EU-15 states of the European Union. This is definitely not a result of any coincidence but is the fruit of deliberate policies pursued by the governments over the past years.

Malta has enjoyed a very good reputation for the high caliber of its professionals and for the provision of medical services since the arrival of the Knight Hospitaliers. At that time our country already boasted a state of the art hospital where patients were looked after as privileged guests to the extent that they were served their meals in silver plates. We are also proud to boast the oldest medical school in the Commonwealth. Malta’s reputation in the medical field was further enhanced during the Crimean War to the extent of becoming referred to internationally as the Nurse of the Mediterranean. 

Yet in spite of our success we have never rested on our laurels. Nor do we intend to do so now.

Several challenges face us today as a small island state coming to terms with the realities of modern medicine.  I bring to your attention the demographic transition that is affecting and will affect our health and pension systems in the next 20 years.  We must plan today the financial, human and technical resources required to care for the needs of our future elderly. 

The demographic transition will also affect health care employees and this means that we must step up our training initiatives now to ensure that enough caring staff is available in the future. 

Technology and pharmaceuticals are becoming more elaborate and costly. Innovations appear practically every day and this has pushed up the demand for quality and appropriate care. Our patients are becoming ever more informed, more empowered and more demanding.  We strive to live longer, to remain more independent yet resigned and fully aware that we shall be spending the last years of our lives in hospitals or nursing homes.

Against this background we must examine the short term and the long term implications of current EU health issues; foremost amongst which are: the working time directive, free movement of patients and professionals; waiting lists management and the directive on services of a general nature. More importantly we need to stand back and reflect on the impact of these issues on the principle of subsidiarity that has hitherto applied to health care systems. 

The debate on the implications of the Working Time Directive on hospital services has now reached a critical moment.  The study prepared by the HOPE study group and which will be presented during this Plenary Assembly comes at a very opportune moment in the debate.  Malta supports the recommendations made by HOPE in its document.  We believe we need to find a balance between human resource availability, costs and working conditions for staff.  We not only welcome the definition of inactive “duty” time as a reality that all hospitals face in order to offer the best service possible for patients within acceptable safety margins, but already practice it locally.  We agree that the opt-out facility must be retained primarily because we firmly believe that health professionals should retain their right to choose whether to work in excess of 48 hours. As the HOPE report outlines, the financial consequences of removing “opt-out” are very significant for nearly all EU member states.

Malta has successfully managed patient mobility over the past decades. Therefore this is not a new phenomenon for us as local economies of scale have made us seek abroad the specialized care that could not be offered locally.  Our tangible positive experience, primarily in the form of a mutually beneficial bilateral agreement with the UK, has been extensively reported upon in several HOPE and EU presentations. The treatment abroad programme has also been important in guiding local service development and investment.  The relationship has facilitated skills transfer between centres of excellence in the UK and our professional staff.   It has brought to our shores expertise and services that one would not normally expect or find in a population of our size. 

Indirectly it has led us to constantly review and update the basket of services on offer for our citizens in the public health care sector. We believe that together European countries must question the evidence base of what we are offering today, we must assess the effectiveness of the treatment and care options; we must ensure value for money as a foremost consideration.  What is at stake, if we do not undertake this painful process, is the sustainability of the health care system.  HOPE can help to bring together top European experts who can together determine the protocols and guidelines on which essential services should be offered and guaranteed. 

The issues concerning waiting list management are multiple.  European health care systems are built on social models with great attention to equity and solidarity. Malta fears that the current excessive focus on unplanned patient mobility as an EU health policy issue is not in line with the values of equitable and sustainable health care systems that underpin all European health care systems.

Allow me to make a few remarks on the proposal for a directive on services. We do not agree with the view that medical care is regarded purely as a service commodity in the manner that is implied in the General Services Directive.  We offer a health care service based on social solidarity whilst the directive assumes self-employed economic activity as a basis for the definition.  Therefore immediately in the first definition we have a lack of sensitivity as to what constitutes a health care service in our philosophical concept.  There are positive ideas in the directive, which ensure quality and access, such as single point of contact, the right to information and electronic procedures. But we feel that the general direction should be to safeguard health care systems from being grossly unbalanced by the market in the absence of continued guaranteed funding and as such believe that health services should not form part of this Directive.

Furthermore certain difficulties arise as we lack definitions of basic concepts such as what really constitutes “medically unacceptable waiting time”? This and similar critical questions should not be determined by Courts of Law or by other sectors.  European Ministers of health should take the driving seat in leading and giving direction. It is because of this belief that we consistently support the creation of a high level structure to address and tackle health care issues between Member States at a European level.

This we can do after listening to the experts that can guide us, give us suitable definitions, protocols and guidelines that make both financial and social solidarity sense.

Linked to this, expertise such as that found within HOPE can be instrumental in guiding an effective approach to the application of the Open Method of Coordination to health care. We believe that such coordination should be gradual and should take into account the varying levels of resources and economic backgrounds across the enlarged EU when setting benchmarks for health care. Furthermore we believe that benchmarks and standards should be outcome oriented rather than input oriented.

As you will be able to see for yourself in a few hours, we are constructing a new state of the art acute teaching hospital, the Mater Dei Hospital.  Government views this not only as confirmation of its determination to continue to guarantee the best standards in healthcare to our people but also as an investment for the increasing future needs. It is because of this belief that we will be concentrating our efforts on new management structures, improved work practices, a reformed work ethic. We therefore do not envisage the new hospital as a project that consists exclusively of beautifully laid out care facilities containing the most advanced medical technologies. Our vision goes well beyond that. We consider healthcare provision as a social service that embodies and reflects our Christian principles and values, a service centered on the particular needs of each and every individual, his family and his careers.

With all these challenges facing us I am fully aware of the responsibility of the discussions and the decisions this Plenary will be taking. I am also very confident of the positive outcome of the assembly and therefore wish you all the very best during your short stay with us and I look forward to meeting you tonight in a more relaxed atmosphere.

Thank you for coming to us to share your experiences with us.

Ixxerja din l-istqarrija Icon socials Icon socials Icon socials Icon socials

Stqarrijiet Oħra:

PRESS RELEASE BY THE MINISTRY FOR EQUALITY AND CIVIL RIGHTS Malta records one of the strongest improvements in gender equality in the EU

PR261938en

PRESS RELEASE BY THE MINISTRY FOR EQUALITY AND CIVIL RIGHTS Malta records o...

STQARRIJA MILL-MINISTERU GĦALL-UGWALJANZA U D-DRITTIJIET ĊIVILI Malta tirreġistra wieħed mill-akbar avvanzi fl-ugwaljanza bejn il-ġeneri fl-UE

PR261938

STQARRIJA MILL-MINISTERU GĦALL-UGWALJANZA U D-DRITTIJIET ĊIVILI Malta tirre...

Aktar Stqarrijiet Right arrow