STATEMENT BY THE MINISTER FOR ECONOMIC SERVICES THE HON. JOSEF BONNICI: HALF BAKED REPORT
Just five days before the end of the referendum campaign, the Leader of the Opposition, the Hon. Dr. Alfred Sant has come out with a so-called ‘assessment by anonymous persons’, which assessment is supposed to estimate the impact of EU accession on the price of food items in Malta.
Unfortunately this report has a number of methodological and technical problems which lead to a flawed assessment.
In order to claim that an impact assessment is being undertaken, one would have to examine in detail, the rational for changes in prices of food items. Instead of doing this, the Malta Labour Party report claims to have looked at prices of food items in three EU countries, namely Holland, France and Britain.
Then it claims to compare these, with prices in Malta and proceeds to simply assume that prices in Malta would be the same as those in these three countries, upon membership.
This approach is similar to that used by Mr Alfred Mifsud, some months ago, during a discussion on GDP per capita, corrected for the purchasing power of money in Malta and the EU. In that instance he assumed, without any supporting evidence, that prices in Malta are the same as those in Slovenia.
The unwarranted assumption made in this latest report published by the Malta Labour Party raises so many problems that it is no surprise that the authors have refrained from putting their name on this study. Amongst the many problems, one may mention the following:
- Why pick just three countries, Holland, France and Britain? On what basis can one assume that prices in Malta will be the same as in these three countries? Why ignore other countries with more similar characteristics to Malta such as Portugal, Spain or Greece. Does this mean that the other nine acceeding countries – most of whom have lower food prices than Malta – would also have their prices rise to the levels of these three countries? How can one claim this is a serious technical study, when one finds the following statement: "……. the most reliable criterion against which to set future price levels of many food items, is the price level prevailing for them at present in EU shops." Isn’t the Maltese public being taken for a ride with this assumption?
- The report provides no information about a crucial aspect of such a comparison of prices, namely that of comparing like with like. Not every piece of meat is the same! Indeed, the comparison of prices of goods across countries is not a straight forward exercise. Currently, this is done by Eurostat and the NSO as part of the exercise involving the so called purchasing power standards. This shows, for example, that prices in Malta are almost 80% of the EU average, whilst GDP per capita is 56%. In the Malta Labour Party’s report, no information is given about the items selected and how comparable they are across countries. Unless it is clearly established that the items are directly comparable, even the exercise of comparing prices becomes meaningless !
- The Malta Labour Party study also claims that it is making an adjustment for subsidies that the government will introduce in order to keep the price of items such as sugar, wheat, beef and others unchanged upon membership. No details are provided on how this is done. Nonetheless, there are grave errors clearly discernable. For example, after subsidies, sugar is shown to increase by 90% and flour by 123%. Yet before subsidies, the same price increase is shown! This is clearly wrong since the government has the stated policy to subsidise any difference in prices as a result of membership. The report itself mentions this and therefore one does not understand how such errors are made.
- Even from a technical point of view, there is a grave error committed in the conclusion. Putting aside the above points for the moment, consider the following statement: "If the subsidy effect is ignored, the per cent increase in the cost of living resulting from food price increases will be of the order of 10.39 per cent. Alternatively, the household budget will have to increase by Lm 10.39 on a total household spending of Lm 100, just to absorb increases in the price of food. Since the food spending under the 1994 HBS stands at Lm 29.2 out of a total spending of Lm 100, the rise in food prices is estimated to hover at about 35 per cent of total food purchases." The reasoning in this conclusion is wrong. If food prices are 10.39% higher, and out of a total of Lm100, there is Lm 29.2 spent on food, then a 10.39 per cent increase on food would mean an increase of Lm 2.92 and not the 35% mentioned, which would be equivalent to Lm 10.22!
If the ‘so called team of management and economic consultants’ can get even this pre ‘O-level’ arithmetic wrong, there is little confidence that other errors are not also lurking in the background, in the unpublished workings behind this report.
Furthermore, as noted in points 1 to 3 above, the approach, the assumptions made and the errors committed on subsidies leave this report with no basis to stand on, and therefore cannot be considered as providing any useful input to the important decision that the Maltese public has to make in a few days time.
Other Press Releases:
PR261933
STQARRIJA MILL-MINISTERU GĦAL GĦAWDEX Inawgurata Auberge du Chocolat, kunċ...
PR261932