Statement by the Ministry for Economic Services: Longer list, lower credibility
PR252
25/02/2003
| At last Sunday’s Malta Labour Party mass meeting, the Leader of the | Opposition the Hon. Dr. Alfred Sant chose, yet again, to read out a list of companies that, according to him, will be affected negatively by Malta’s EU membership. This list has progressively become longer whereas, in the process, the credibility of the Hon. Dr. Sant has sunk lower and lower. |
| At least, gone from the list is the name of Rotos | Ziraya. Dr. Sant had earlier claimed that this company would be negatively affected by EU membership when, in fact, the company had already ceased its operations, even before Dr. Sant’s pronouncement. |
| On the other hand, Dr. Sant has still chosen to | include, in his list, the name of Pharmamed. This, even though the directors of this company had immediately refuted his claim, and nothwithstanding the fact that the web-site of Pharmaco (Pharmamed’s parent company in Iceland) is clearly stating the very opposite to what Dr. Sant contends. |
| Namely, Pharmaco are very happy to proclaim on their | web site that Malta’s EU membership will increase the value of their investment in Malta since it will enhance their company’s ability to develop products for, and sell within, the EU. The very opposite to what the Leader of the Opposition has stated. |
| Another company that still appears on Dr. Sant’s | list is General Soft Drinks. It is ironic that whereas, just a couple of weeks ago, Dr. Sant was claiming that this company would be forced to close-down after membership, he is now, so to speak, raising the alarm because this company wants to build a new factory on, what Dr. Sant is claiming to be, agricultural land. |
| As often happens, Dr. Sant is being both inconsistent | as well as misinformed and incorrect. The truth is that General Soft Drinks is planning on investing and expanding and not on contracting. It intends to launch a number of new products and is looking at export opportunities. The truth is that this company has submitted a proposal to the MDC for the construction of a brand new factory but the site being assessed for this project is not an agricultural site, but an industrial location. (i.e. The earmarked site is totally distinct from the site that was the subject of controversy seven years ago). |
| By now, Dr. Sant’s strategy should be very obvious | for one and all to see through it. His devious objective is to instill doubts and even fear in the minds of workers by naming individual companies. |
| What he is trying to do is to give the false | impression that he has some insider knowledge about these companies that is being kept hidden from the workers concerned. His belief is that such doubts will persist, even though many directors have spoken out to publicly refute his allegations, and even though the FOI has condemned his tactics. |
| His strategy is to instill doubts and even anxiety in | the minds of workers, even though this could destabilise and harm some of the enterprises by name and therefore work directly against the interests of the employees involved. |
| What Dr. Sant did not bargain for, is that | representatives of the workers involved would themselves speak out against his orchestrated misinformation campaign, as Ms. Margaret Mercieca did so effectively last Sunday. |
| What Dr. Sant did not bargain for is that some | people, like Mr. Peppi Azzopardi, had managed to read through some of the GWU commissioned reports and these people are vouching that these very same reports clearly identify the advantages of membership and the benefits that it represents for the manufacturing industry in Malta. |
| If Dr. Sant’s concern had been genuine, he could | have, very well, identified certain alleged problems relative to a given sector or line of manufacturing and expounded on them, instead of targetting individual companies. |
| However, Dr. Sant realizes that such a sectoral | approach would also make it easier for those who do not share his views to respond to his claims. This is exactly what happened when he pointed the finger at the clothing sector. |
| His allegations have been soundly refuted and, | contrary to what Dr. Sant had claimed, documented arguments have been produced to show that clothing companies would secure their export market through membership but would face a most uncertain future under the partnership option. |
| In reality Dr. Sant does not have any choice. If he | tries to engage in a factual, reasoned debate, he knows that there are overwhelming arguments in favour of EU membership. So his only option is to avoid any kind of meaningful debate and instead resort to intimidating, finger pointing and generic predictions of doom and gloom. |
Stqarrijiet Oħra:
PR261933
STQARRIJA MILL-MINISTERU GĦAL GĦAWDEX Inawgurata Auberge du Chocolat, kunċ...
PR261932