STATEMENT ON THE OUTCOME OF NEGOTIATIONS DELIVERED BY RICHARD CACHIA CARUANA, CHAIRMAN, CORE NEGOTIATING GROUP, AT THE CONFERENCE ON THE RESULTS OF THE NEGOTIATIONS AT THE DOLMEN HOTEL, QAWRA - 30 JANUARY 2003
There were moments over the past three years when I could not imagine a time when Malta’s accession negotiations would be concluded. Nevertheless, we can now analyse the terms under which Malta will take its place as a Member State of the European Union.
Our preparations for membership have broadly followed two tracks.
On the one hand we have adopted the provisions of the acquis communautaire. I believe that the reforms instituted as a result of this considerable task were generally ones that we would have wanted and needed to introduce in any case. These include such areas as occupational health and safety, environment and transport. I also believe that it was more than useful to be able to apply the tried and tested standards existing in the European Union.
The other track is the one that I will be focussing on more specifically today and this deals with the arrangements that Malta has negotiated.
As most of you are aware, Malta negotiated 77 specific measures. These comprise:
- 1 permanent derogation on the acquisition of real estate by non-residents;
- 46 transition periods on technical issues where time for adaptations is required;
- 27 special arrangements which are specific to Malta’s case (including those concerning fisheries, agriculture and, of course, the financial package);
- the protocol on abortion;
- 2 declarations – one on neutrality and one on Gozo.
In fact, those who claimed that the European Union consists of a one-size-fits-all concept were no doubt disappointed when they saw the terms that were obtained by Malta.
We have clearly catered for all the areas where specific interests or needs exist. When we look at the terms negotiated on the acquisition of property, the movement of workers, hunting and trapping as well as fisheries, among others, it is clear that the agreements reached on these issues have been tailor-made for Malta, rather than the other way around. This, of course, clearly demonstrates the Union’s understanding of our concerns and its willingness to take them on board.
I cannot but emphasise that the Maltese negotiators were negotiating on behalf of all sectors of the population. The arrangements negotiated, for example, on a quota for olive oil and on certain aspects of road transport, are of very limited interest to the public in general, but of some importance to these involved in those sectors.
On the other hand, there were areas where different Maltese groups held opposing views. Perhaps the best example of this concerns the hunting and trapping issue and the conflicting views of the hunters and environmentalists. It was clearly necessary for us to find a solution that was fair to both sides, as well as to the rest of the population. The result is that hunting and trapping will certainly not be abolished – contrary to what was said in certain quarters. Moreover, they will be practised in a sustainable and responsible manner.
It is also worth noting that in some areas, it was decided to withdraw certain requests because Government felt that reforms should be speeded up. This occurred with the abolition of leaded petrol from 1 January of this year and with the decision to re-locate the gas bottling plant away from a residential area.
Although the negotiated package achieved is an excellent one for Malta, there are, naturally, one or two items I am not entirely pleased with. I say this because too often the EU debate has been portrayed as being black and white, all good or all bad.
I was, for example, disappointed that we did not achieve the sixth seat for Malta in the European Parliament. Malta has, however, reserved the right to raise this issue during the forthcoming Intergovernmental Conference, which will be held after accession and where we will be at the decision-making table.
I would also have prefered for Malta to retain its existing re-use regime for beverage containers. The final compromise is, however, acceptable and will see improvements right across the waste management spectrum.
Those who are not familiar with Malta and its peculiarities cannot understand that we have very particular views on our vulnerabilities, both real and perceived. Naturally, we are all too aware of them, which is why we negotiated so long and hard to achieve arrangements that were denied to other candidate countries.
These include the permanent arrangement on the purchase of secondary residences, the protocol on abortion, the declarations on Gozo and neutrality as well as the arrangement on the free movement of workers.
On abortion it had been clear all along that accession would not affect our position. In fact, we share our views on these matters with other current Member States. Since, however, there continued to be concerns that Malta’s position was not adequately safeguarded, it was felt that we should secure confirmation in the Accession Treaty. Similar concerns were addressed through the Neutrality Declaration.
In the case of the free movement of workers, while the Government firmly believes that membership of the EU will bring about sufficient economic growth to cope with any possible, though unlikely, labour influx, there were concerns that Malta’s small labour market could come under pressure. In certain respects this is understandable, because this was also a fear that existed among the current Member States in relation to workers from the Eastern European candidate countries.
As a result of the negotiations, during the first seven years of membership, Malta will be able to monitor the influx of workers – also by retaining its work permit system. Should the need arise, we will be able to suspend the application of the acquis. After this period of time, we will be able to resort to Community measures to solve any critical situation.
The particular needs of Gozo were borne in mind throughout the negotiations on all chapters of the acquis. Nevertheless, owing to its inherent handicaps, primarily as a result of its double insularity, the possibility exists that while the economy of the Maltese Islands as a whole could, sometime in the future, grow beyond the threshold established for cohesion and structural funds, Gozo may remain below this level. It was important to ensure that any assistance that may be available to Gozo would not be compromised because of such a situation.
The permanent derogation negotiated on the purchase of property by non-residents is certainly one of the landmarks of these negotiations. Time and again we were told that no permanent derogations would be accepted by the Union, but we knew that our request was fully justified.
The system applied will be non-discriminatory, and here lies one of the inherent features of the Union: the EU is essentially fair and just with its citizens. The Member States understood that property in Malta is at a premium and that a full application of the acquis in this area, while fair in theory, would have been unfair to the Maltese themselves.
This spirit of understanding and appreciation of the situation on the ground was apparent in several other areas. In the negotiations on the fisheries chapter, the Union accepted the principle that the accession of Malta should not lead to a decline in the protection of living resources within the 25-mile conservation zone around Malta. The Union recognised Malta’s efforts to conserve fish stocks within the zone over the past 30 years.
With this objective in mind, technical experts from Malta and from the Commission succeeded in identifying a number of non-discriminatory conservation measures to ensure that the fishing effort in the management zone will be maintained at a sustainable level and that the conservation of fish stocks will be adequately guaranteed. This is to the direct benefit of Malta’s largely artisinal fishing fleet.
Among the most complex negotiations were those concerning indirect taxation. After months and months of discussions at technical and political levels, Malta was granted a transition period until 2010 for the maintenance of the VAT zero-rate on foodstuffs and pharmaceuticals, on the assumption that no other Member State will retain similar exemptions beyond that date. It is relevant to note that an identical request by another candidate state was met with a far reduced arrangement.
Although this was the item that got the most publicity in the taxation chapter, primarily because it dragged on until the last days of the negotiations, it was not the only taxation arrangement achieved. Special exemptions were negotiated for international passenger transport, inland passenger transport, inter-island sea transport, water and new buildings and building land.
The negotiations in the competition chapter also dealt with a variety of complicated issues. These included a transition period to allow the completion of the restructuring plan for the shipyards. More important for Maltese businessmen was the transition period allowing for SMEs to retain existing benefits, including tax exemptions, until 2011. Moreover, larger enterprises currently enjoying incentives under the Industrial Development Act will have those schemes converted in line with the acquis, but in a manner that will still provide for their legitimate expectations.
Additionally, as an Objective 1 region under the EU’s regional classification system, Malta will be able to retain an attractive investment package to effectively address the specific handicaps faced by companies operating in Malta.
During the negotiations, we approached the various chapters by first analysing where we were in line with the acquis, identifying those areas where we could achieve harmonisation before accession and then focussing on the exceptional items where a transitional or special arrangement was necessary.
An exception to this was the vast agricultural chapter. This sector was in dire need of reform. We were in a situation where Maltese agriculture was subsisting on protection and handouts which were, in themselves, preventing the further growth of the sector.
Our negotiations had two key objectives: that a suitable income would be guaranteed for farmers; and that the multifunctional role of agriculture would be encouraged and enhanced. The main instruments for the implementation of these measures are the Special Market Policy Programme and the Rural Development Programme.
The Special Market Policy Programme provides for the removal of levies by accession and their replacement with direct income support and restructuring assistance. This financial assistance, which is co-funded by the EU, will allow local production to compete in the single market.
In this context, Malta has also negotiated a special safeguard clause that will apply for the five years following accession. This will permit measures to assist farmers in the event of serious difficulties, particularly where these difficulties are liable to persist.
The Rural Development Programme provides a framework to build, over the medium to long-term, a new agricultural sector that is integrated with the rest of the economy. It will also include technical assistance and agri-environmental measures such as the maintenance of rubble walls.
The agricultural chapter is a striking example of the extensive discussions held with the private sector during the negotiations: three formal consultation sessions at Ministerial level; six meetings of the Malta-EU Steering and Action Committee, with a total of forty-seven Special Interest Members from the sector; in addition to the many informal and other technical meetings.
As you are all aware, the very last thing negotiated was the financial package. The amounts agreed upon have been well publicised, but they deserve repeating, especially since attempts have been made to make the money disappear.
During the first three years of membership, Malta will pay just under Lm74 million as its share of the EU budget. This amount comprises a share of VAT receipts, customs duties and certain other payments.
During the same period, Malta will receive approximately Lm12 million for the agricultural sector, Lm33 million for projects, Lm13 million from various community programmes, as well as Lm97 million as budgetary compensation.
This clearly means that Malta will be a net beneficiary to the tune of just under Lm81 million.
This arrangement, I repeat, covers the period 2004 to 2006. The next budgetary period will extend to 2013 and the budget will have to be negotiated between all the Member States of the European Union. Malta will be around the table then and the decision will require unanimity.
It would take too much time to go into all the other details of the negotiations. Malta negotiated adaptation periods in many other areas to allow both the public and the private sectors sufficient time to adapt to the requirements of the acquis or else to build adequate capacity to implement its provisions.
These transitional arrangements generally concerned areas where Malta aspires to the standards established by the EU but where, for a variety of reasons, we either lag behind or we simply do not yet have the resources.
The areas that spring to mind are solid waste management, sewage purification, the length of the working week and the building up of emergency fuel stocks.
The negotiations were concluded on 13 December 2002. If, however, anybody thought that this would mean that it’s all over, they would be greatly mistaken. A lot remains to be done.
| At the moment we are involved in the final stages of | the drafting of the Accession Treaty. This requires that the terms negotiated must be put into Treaty language, which is quite a complex process. |
| Simultaneously, the Accession Treaty is being | translated into Maltese, as well as the other 21 Treaty languages. All these texts must be reviewed and, in some areas, discussed in some detail with the EU institutions. |
| The Accesion Treaty will be submitted to the European | Parliament, which will hold a debate and take a vote of assent on each new Member State next March. The Treaty will then be signed at a formal ceremony that is to be held in Athens on 16 April 2003. From this point on Malta will have observer status, and hence certain membership rights and obligations, in over 250 EU committees and working groups. |
| Following the signing ceremony, the current and new | Member States will launch their individual ratification processes. All the acceding states will be holding referenda on accession, although the case of Cyprus is particular. |
| Throughout this period and right up to the date of | accession, we will be engaged in the monitoring of the commitments made during the negotiations. In fact, next week a Commission delegation will be in Malta to meet its counterparts on a technical level. |
| We are continuing our work with the enthusiasm that | comes from a sense of making history. The achievements that have been registered during this process are considerable and I can confess that, at the outset, even I thought some of them were unattainable. |
| The past three long years have been marked by the | hard work of public servants and members of trade unions, business and other associations alike. They have, however, also been marked by a tremendous "team effort", which led to the successful outcome of negotiations and which will lead also to Malta’s successful membership of the European Union. |
Other Press Releases:
PR261933
STQARRIJA MILL-MINISTERU GĦAL GĦAWDEX Inawgurata Auberge du Chocolat, kunċ...
PR261932