INTRODUCTORY SPEECH BY THE HON. DR MARIO DE MARCO DURING CONFERENCE ORGANISED BY THE GWU ENTITLED “SOCIAL DIALOGUE FOR A RESPONSIBLE MANAGEMENT OF SEASONAL MIGRATION IN PERIOD OF ECONOMIC CRISIS IN THE TOURISM SECTOR”
pr1603
02/09/2010
| Good morning Ladies and | Gentlemen, and thank you for inviting me to address you at this conference organised by the General Workers Union on the subject of Social Dialogue, particularly with respect to the responsible management of seasonal migration in the tourism industry. |
| We are all aware of the | developments taking place across the European Union in terms of the proposed directive regarding the entry and residence of third country nationals for the purpose of seasonal employment. Besides being aware, we are also conscious of our responsibilities in terms of the well-being and treatment of these third country nationals, in line with the principles established in the Hague in 2004 that recognise that legal migration will play a very important role in the strengthening of the European Economy. |
| Across the European | Union in general, seasonal employment is a phenomenon which requires the injection of quantities of third country nationals given the structural necessities of a number of European economies which are showing a clear inability to satisfy such seasonal demands through the internal European labour market. |
| The phenomenon of | seasonal variations in the demand for labour is not limited to the hospitality industry only but spans across a wide range of industries ranging from primary to service oriented ones. However, in spite of great strides in the tourism industry to reduce the impacts and extremes of seasonality, the tourism industry continues to be seasonal, as people’s travel interests feature preferences for travel during certain times of the year in favour of other times. |
| Furthermore, tourism | seasonality varies according to the location and type of tourism attractions offered. Thus, while tourism demand for Mediterranean destinations features a peak during the Northern Hemisphere summer between July and September, peak demand for skiing resorts such as the Alps is during the Northern Hemisphere winter between January and March. Inversely, destinations such as Australia, New Zealand and South Africa feature Southern Hemisphere summers between December and March! All this goes to show that the seasonality debate is not as straightforward as it sounds, given the vast regional variations that influence the phenomenon. |
| Seasonality in the | Labour Market often also features strong sectoral inter-relationships. Thus seasonal workers will migrate from one country or region to another in response to multi-sectoral working opportunities that change with the seasons. Thus agricultural workers could be busy at certain times of the year when the tourism industry does not require their services, but free during peak summer after harvest times have passed to perfectly slot into peak tourism demand. |
| Given these scenarios, | and the recognition that third country nationals are playing a very important role in giving a service where the local labour market cannot satisfy demand, it is important that the spirit of the EU Directive of ensuring the safeguarding of such migrant workers from exploitation whilst also protecting EU nationals from having to face unfair competition from an unregulated source of third country workers is adhered to. It is here that I congratulate the General Workers Union for taking this initiative to organise this conference to explore ways of how the principle of social dialogue can be utilised to ensure that the implications of the EU Directive are practically applied to the Maltese situation. |
| Allow me now to expand a | bit on the situation in Malta. This small island archipelago continues to consolidate itself as an important component of the Mediterranean tourism offer. In spite of the challenges brought about by lack of economies of scale, lack of natural resources and a location which is far away from the traditional source markets, over the past years we have managed to achieve growth which is far higher than European and regional averages. |
| During the first seven | months of this year, for example, inbound tourism to Malta has increased by an impressive 12.2%. The validity of our performance becomes even more special when it is benchmarked against competitors such as Spain which by the end of July was still -0.4% below last year, the Balearic Islands, still at -2.4% over last year, Cyprus, still at -0.3% over last year and Tunisia which is slightly up by 0.5% over the first seven months of 2009. Malta’s to-date performance until July is also much healthier than that of Turkey (+6.7%) and Croatia (+6.3%). |
| We have emerged from the | crisis that impacted international tourism between late 2008 and mid 2009 in a very energetic manner. Whilst most of our competitors continue to struggle, some of them following years of decline, we are currently at the momentum of the two years of record growth of 2007 and 2008. Without bombarding you with too many figures, I would simply like to emphasise that during the first seven months of this year, the number of tourists visiting the Maltese islands has increased by 12.2%. This means that we have attracted almost 77,000 more tourists than January to July last year to reach in excess of 710,000 tourists. Had it not been for the turmoil caused by the Icelandic volcanic eruption last April we would almost be on par with our record year of 2008. |
| Overnights in | accommodation establishments have increased by 11% given that reductions in average length of stay are stabilising following a period of decline caused by the attraction of a younger, more frequently travelling visitor. Very importantly, expenditure by tourists during the first seven months of this year is up by a staggering €87 million. This is an 18.1% increase. This is good news not only for the Exchequer, but also for businesses and workers alike. Everybody agrees that as a result of its high multipliers, the tourism euro percolates deep into people’s pockets. These results have not come by sheer luck or due to some global upsurge in business. They have come because we have worked very hard for them in spite of a global economy which is still sluggish at best, in spite of encouraging indicators for the future. |
| From the seasonality | perspective, our efforts at reducing the impacts of this scourge have enabled us to become one of the Mediterranean’s least seasonal destinations. In 2009 for instance, our three peak summer months accounted for 37.1% of our incoming tourism. This compares very well when compared to Cyprus’ 40.7% and the Balearic Islands’ more extreme 47.6% dependence on peak summer inflows. Having a lower dependence on peak summer inflows, means that higher shares of tourists are attracted during the low season. In this case, Malta’s success in attracting 35.6% of its tourists during the low season of October to March is very healthy when compared to Cyprus’ 27.1% and the Balearic Islands’ very low 18.3%. This is why Maltese tourism businesses and resorts remain open all year round whilst many places amongst our competitors close down for the winter. While the economic benefits of our approach are undisputed, the positive influence on seasonal demand for labour cannot be ignored. Generally speaking, our approach keeps seasonal variations to a minimum, thus ensuring that the Maltese hospitality industry continues to maintain a solid base of full-time employees on a year round basis. |
| Our statistics on | Gainfully Occupied people in hotels and catering establishments indicate some very interesting facts. First and foremost, the statistics tell us that full time employment is not subject to intensive seasonal variations, thus proving that the majority of full time workers are able to retain their job all year round. In 2009, full time employment in hotels and catering establishments ranged from a low 9,300 employees in December to a high 9,950 in July. |
| Besides full time | employment, the industry also generates numerous opportunities for part-time employment. Besides offering flexibility to the employer, part-time employment opportunities are also useful in attracting traditionally under-utilised segments of the Maltese workforce, such as females by allowing them to merge and balance a working timetable with the pressures of raising a family. Part time employment in hotels and catering establishments in 2009 ranged from a peak of 9,148 in July to a low of 7,761 in January. Such a variation indicates a strong correlation with seasonal peaks and troughs and most definitely includes inflows of migrant seasonal workers during the peak summer months when the local labour market is less available. |
| When we analyse seasonal | employment dynamics, we do not stop at the absolute figures alone. In an industry such as tourism, the labour force and its attitude to work forms a very important component of the visitor experience. Ultimately, most of our visitors interact with the front liners working in our industry, not with our managers and directors. And it is this human interaction that is as important as the destination’s physical offer when it comes to influence tourists’ evaluation of their Malta visit. |
| And here, an interesting | indicator emerges. Surveys of tourists visiting Malta carried out by the Malta Tourism Authority, evaluate, amongst others, the levels of service given by employees in the various establishments. For the purpose of this speech I shall be quoting our analysis of tourists’ rating of employees in hotels and catering establishments last year. I shall also be comparing and contrasting the ratings of our off-peak visitors with those of our peak-season visitors. |
| What emerges from the | analysis is very interesting. Whilst during the whole year more than three out of every four of our tourists rate the service given by such employees to be very good or good, such a rating drops from a high score of 80% in the off-peak to 73.8% in the peak. This implies that the influx of less-trained seasonal employees during the peak dilutes and reduces the quality of service given. This is in direct contrast to the peak prices which establishments charge during the high season. I am referring to these figures for obvious reasons. The level of service given by employees depends on many variables, foremost amongst which one can list training, experience, supervision and working conditions. The proper handling of seasonal employees in tourism, be they local, from the rest of the EU or from third countries can play a major role in improving our peak season offer. |
| This is where the social | partners: the trade unions and the employers together with Government can work even further together to understand these issues and channel efforts aimed at addressing shortcomings. |
| Ladies and Gentlemen, | over the past years, Government has played a major role in ensuring that the Maltese tourism industry continues to strengthen and grow on the basis of the three solid pillars of sound product development, sustainable accessibility and highly cost-effective and targeted marketing. We are adapting very successfully to a rapidly changing traveller profile and have been one of the least affected European-Mediterranean destinations during the global economic crisis. |
| However, tourism is no | easy industry. Today’s successes are no guarantee for tomorrow’s business as competition becomes more intense, customers less loyal and trends ever changing. Tourism is a service industry based on the principle of giving pleasure and satisfaction to visitors who work hard during the rest of the year in expectation of a well-deserved break or breaks depending on one’s means and interests. It is an industry whose success depends heavily on everyone’s inputs, not the inputs of a select few. |
| I thank you for this | opportunity to inaugurate your conference and wish you every success in your deliberations for the common good of improving our tourism offer to the benefit of our economy and people. |
Other Press Releases:
PR261991
STQARRIJA MILL-MINISTERU GĦALL-AGRIKOLTURA, IS-SAJD U L-PROVVISTA TAL-IKEL ...
PR261990