ADDRESS BY THE HON. TONIO BORG, DEPUTY PRIME MINISTER AND MINISTER OF FOREIGN AFFAIRS, AT MEDAC’S 20TH ANNIVERSARY INTERNATIONAL CONFERENCE : “THE END OF THE COLD WAR AND MEDITERRANEAN 1989-2009” - ST.JULIAN’S – FRIDAY, 4TH DECEMBER 2009
Distinguished Guests, Ladies and Gentlemen,
It is an honour for me to address you here today on the occasion of two anniversaries - both 20 years in the making. The first event is one that altered the path of history – a watershed moment that captured the imagination of citizens around the world. The fall of the Berlin wall was not only sudden but also unexpected. A Europe without a wall was not on anyone’s agenda. What came after was at best unscripted. The second event is the 20th Anniversary of the Mediterranean Academy for Diplomatic Studies which has contributed in no small way to the education and training of diplomats from across the Mediterranean and beyond.
These two anniversaries bring us here today. Before I commence my intervention allow me to spare a few words of thanks and appreciation for the good work of the Academy. Over the last two decades this institution has transformed itself into a centre of excellence.
Ladies and Gentlemen,
| Twenty years ago Presidents Bush and | Gorbachev met in Malta in the so-called shipboard summit. This paved the way for the successful conclusion of the Conventional Forces in Europe (CFE) Treaty in 1990 and the Strategic Arms Reduction Talks (START) in 1991. As a spokesman for Gorbachev declared this summit also ‘buried the Cold War at the bottom of the Mediterranean’. In the eye of a forceful storm that hit our shores over that weekend, the two leaders laid the foundations of a new post-Cold War era. This was a symbolic reflection of the turn of events that had started a month before in Berlin with the fall of the Wall during the night of the 9th November 1989. On an West-East basis things have turned for the better e.g. the lifting of the Iron Curtain, German Reunification the emergence of independent Baltic States |
| Still, 20 years later we are still asking | ourselves whether or not the Cold War has indeed been buried or merely submerged in this great sea. A generation of intellectuals and politicians have spent millions of words analysing the shape of post-Cold War politics. Would it be Samuel Huntington’s ‘Clash of Civilisations’ or did the end of the Cold War spell the ‘end of history’ as Francis Fukuyama expounded? To my mind the end of the Cold War left a quagmire in international politics that has taken us 20 long years to start understanding fully. The era that emerged was not one of global peace as one would have hoped, but one that brought with it a new type of conflict that the international community struggled to come to terms with. The East-West rivalry made way for a multi-polar world plagued by failing states and insurgent internal conflict. Complex conflicts replaced the super power confrontation that held the world with abated breath for decades. This time round, foreign policy makers were at a loss – how to prevent another Bosnia at Europe’s doorstep? What went wrong with the debacle in Somalia and the genocide in Rwanda? What type of conflicts was the world facing? |
Ladies and Gentlemen,
In hindsight, the Cold War gave the world certainties that no longer exist. Of course I do not wish to go back to those timers. But it is true that prior to 1989 the main threats to global peace were a result of a direct East-West confrontation. Everything was discussed and decided within this parameter and it is within this praxis that the international system functioned. The day the wall came down changed all this. People power led to the fall of a system many felt uncomfortable with. The changes ran deep and political upheaval was palatable. If the Cold War spun insecurity then this new era was to be the era of global security. What happened however was that the cracks within the international system that had been plastered over by the Cold War were put into evidence. Even though security was established in a East West axis, the world now faced some of the bloodiest conflicts since WW II in Europe and across the globe. Not only this, but September the 11th created a new spectre for the world – that of international terrorism. If 1989 was the year for wild euphoria, two decades later we are adopting a cautious optimism in the world.
Ladies and Gentlemen,
| With the end of the Cold War conflict trends | on a regional level have become more important. This, together with the global threat of terrorism is the shape of things to come. Only the strongest alliances for peace and security could stem the spiral of violence that has resulted from the disintegration of failed states and the rise of insurgent terrorist and guerrilla groups across the world. This scenario has given way to an unparalleled human tragedy with at least 28 million people dead in more than 150 major armed conflicts fought mainly in the third world since 1945. This estimate could be as high as 40 million civilian and military deaths. Civil wars increase infant and adult mortality as a result of disease, famine, displacement and collapse of health and other services, land mines and poisoned wells. To give you an idea of the extent of the human tragedy, in the year 2000 alone internal conflicts generated 21 million refugees and 25 million internally displaced persons. In countries such as Angola, Eritrea, Mozambique, Rwanda, Somalia and Sudan up to half the population have been forced to flee. This, coupled with the economic and environmental costs that accompany any internal conflict has created a human tragedy. |
| Writing before the end of the Cold War, | Edward Azar, an American academic born in Lebanon, using his own country of birth as a clear basis for his writings, referred to these internal conflicts as Protracted Social Conflicts (PSC). The term refers to conflict situations which are characterised by the ‘prolonged and often violent struggle by communal groups for such basic needs as security, recognition, and acceptance, fair access to political institutions and economic participation’. |
| In a post-Cold War world one can in hindsight | look at Azar as somewhat of a visionary. Under the veil of the nuclear threat of mutually assured destruction, here is a man who had already worked out the elements of what was to come. Fundamentally, if one looks at the much used theory of needs expounded by the economist Maslow, it is the search for basic human needs leading to more sophisticated needs that drive groups to insurgency and thus civil war. In many ways, such reasoning is a confirmation of the values that democracy brings to the table. These, together with the fundamental principles of human rights have become the corner stones of our democracies. Democracy too has been transformed post-1989. It is no longer a monolithic concept but rather a pluralistic one that has today found greater appeal even within the hardest societies to penetrate. |
Ladies and Gentlemen,
| Today, 20 years later and with the benefit of | hindsight the world is certainly better prepared, but nonetheless wary in the wake of violent protracted social conflict. These, together with the constant and palatable threat of terrorism across the world have led to a strangely less secure world that one would have wished, though much better that the one we lived in twenty years ago. |
| Our Mediterranean region unfortunately has | not been able to escape this predicament. Our shores which are not alien to conflict, are still plagued with a variety of problems that in spite of the end of the Cold War is seemingly intractable. During the Cold War, the Mediterranean region was without a shadow of a doubt subject to the laws of the spheres of influence. Certain pan-Arab Nationalist leaders played this to perfection and highlighted the importance of the region to the world. The post-Cold War era was to bring an era of renewed hope and peace to the region but this has eluded us. The West was too absorbed with the reintegration of the East to pay much attention to its Southern flank. The Mediterranean remained a backwater of Europe despite is obvious importance, as history is our witness, in the guarantee of security to Europe. Malta, at its centre has always pushed the idea that security in Europe cannot be achieved without security in the Mediterranean. |
Ladies and Gentlemen,
| How has the changing geo-political and | geo-strategic scenario in the post-Cold War world affected the Mediterranean? The end of the Cold War brought about a dramatic change in security scenario on an international stage. As I have outlined before, the East-West security dilemma changed into a multi-polar one. The Mediterranean became one of these poles and remains so till today, as a proper unifying force across the Sea has so far eluded us. |
| Today, more than ever this region needs a | unifying basis in order to ensure the bringing together of ideas and interests for the good of all. A region often referred to as the ‘cradle of civilisations’ has led to an interesting melange of cultures, religions and ideologies. Co-existence and co-dependence have always thrived across the region which at best could be described as fluid. Fluid due to the lack of stability it presents in certain areas. For example the Palestinian/Israeli conflict, uncontrolled illegal migration from North Africa, illegal drugs and arms trafficking together with arms build-ups and the predisposition for terrorism. These elements together with the differences in religion, history and the widening income gap between the Northern and Southern flanks of the Mediterranean, have led to further instability and insecurity across the Sea. |
| The collapse of the East-West schism has | increasingly led to a new North-South divide that plays out clearly in the Mediterranean. If not carefully watched the situation could implode due to its inherent complex nature. It is most definitely in Europe and the wider world’s interest to look at the Mediterranean as a whole and work towards its stability and prosperity. |
| Besides a geo-strategic shift there has also | been a great shift in the type of security threat the region is facing. The threats in the Mediterranean in general terms can be seen to be of a non-military nature including economic, social, demographic and environmental. This has led to a reinterpretation of the definition of security as merely military. The post-Cold War has also put into evidence the interdependency of the Mediterranean states and therefore a solution to all things Mediterranean can only be found in collaboration with the States bordering it. |
| On a conflict level, the Mediterranean can be | seen to harbour a large number of regional conflicts the most significant being that between the Greeks and Turks, the Arab-Israeli Conflict as well a the occupation of Cyprus and the Kurdish issue. The end of the Cold War and the subsequent EU enlargement has made it possible to approach many of these issues with renewed energy in hope of a lasting solution. In the case of the Middle East conflict, it is disheartening to see how little progress has been made in the search for a lasting solution which we all agree will take the form of a two-state solution with security guarantees. It is our belief that more should be done on an EU level as well as on a regional level in order to bring the two sides together, working together for a solution. The recent impasse that has been seen in the Union for the Mediterranean does not augur well for the region. |
Ladies and Gentlemen,
| The longer it takes for a search for a | solution in the Middle East, the more we are giving way to the formulation and spread of fundamentalist movements using the veil of Islam as their excuse. Often the Palestinian cause is quoted as the main motivator for fundamentalist movements often engaging in terror tactics spreading fear and distrust. Unless more is done in order to bridge the economic divide across the Mediterranean, the occurrence of fundamentalism will only increase seeing that more often than not support for radical groups can be found in areas which are economically depressed and hard-up especially amongst the youth that see no other means for escape. |
| Islamic fundamentalism becomes an even bigger | concern when coupled with the additional security threat of the proliferation of weapons of mass destruction to the region. Whereas during the Cold War the world had the assurance that despite the reality of a possible nuclear strike this could only come from one of the two super powers - today this is not so. The acquisition of this war-making capability has become one of the most important geostrategic developments the Mediterranean is facing in the post-Cold War era. The question here lies in whether rogue states or insurgent groups possessing the capability will be in a position to use these weapons and at what cost. In many ways such knowledge makes cooperation amongst states and across the Mediterranean more urgent and ever more needed especially on an economic level which will ensure more stability to the region and thus a prevention of a widening of the income divide especially at this crucial time when even the wealthiest of states are bearing the brunt of the global recession. |
| It is at such times of global economic | hardship that latent conflicts emerge as potential threats and must be treated with caution and proper planning in order to avoid a full blown conflict. This can easily be seen in the case of water scarcity across the region as well as access to energy supplies. |
| Far from the ideological conflict that held | the world to ransom for so many decades the Mediterranean, twenty years later, has to contend with its own set of problems which today we can say constitute the Mediterranean reality. The Cold War left in its wake a set of issues which if left unchecked can easily lead to a new North-South confrontation which will once again threaten European stability. |
| This is already being felt in the issue of | irregular mass migration that has been witnessed by all Southern European states especially Malta, Italy and Spain. Boat loads of migrants reach the European Union’s shores each year, each one with their own story to tell of hardship and each one in search of a better life. The numbers only increase yearly creating not only logistical problems in the host nation, but also societal issues such as racism and xenophobia are on the rise not only in Malta but also across the continent. In truth, the only real solution would be the economic development of the South in order to stem the flow of immigrants which once again cannot be achieved unilaterally but only through a concerted effort across the region, North-South, East-West. |
| This issue, coupled with the slow progress | that has been registered in the democratization process as well as the lack of and in some cases complete disregard for human rights has only strengthened the breeding ground for fundamentalist groups that threaten, even by their own existence, the fragile peace that has been in existence since the end of the Cold War. |
Ladies and Gentlemen,
| The elements that have emerged as | de-stabilising forces have only been put more into evidence by the end of the East-West confrontation. The drive to create a regional security organisation have, so far eluded us. Despite all we will still work in order to search for the right formula that will bring the states of the Mediterranean together with their European and African neighbours into a mutually beneficial relationship. |
| The time for the Mediterranean has most | definitely come. No longer can we stand by and see how things develop. Complacency can never be the answer. As regards the Middle East conflict, a strong movement within Europe and the Mediterranean must work together with the US and the rest of the world to solve the impasse and bring the Israelis and the Palestinians back to the negotiating table. At the same time the border states of this unique Sea need to come together on issues of common concern. Only then can we pull out of the insecurity in the region. |
Other Press Releases:
PR261991
STQARRIJA MILL-MINISTERU GĦALL-AGRIKOLTURA, IS-SAJD U L-PROVVISTA TAL-IKEL ...
PR261990