Ministry for Justice and Home Affairs replies to comments attributed to United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights
The Ministry for Justice and Home Affairs refers to comments in the international media attributed to the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights, Navi Pillay, and specifically his reference to the assistance provided by Maltese authorities to a rubber dinghy carrying 5 persons last month.
The facts in relation to that incident, which apparently, the High Commissioner is unaware of, are as follows:
- The rubber dinghy carrying 5 persons referred to by the High Commissioner was first spotted on Wednesday 19th August when the said dinghy was well-inside the Search and Rescue zone of Libyan responsibility. The Maltese Rescue Coordination Centre (RCC) directed a naval vessel of the Armed Forces of Malta (AFM) towards it.
- Once intercepted, the 5 migrants on board were found to be in good spirits and in good health. More importantly, the persons on board refused to be rescued by the Maltese military vessel and insisted on continuing their voyage towards the northwest and the Italian island of Lampedusa. Their dinghy was in a good condition and seaworthy. An aerial still photograph already published by the AFM of this dinghy clearly shows that there was no evidence that it had been carrying ‘scores of migrants’ mentioned by High Commissioner Pillay.
- The AFM crew were thus left with no other option other than providing the persons on board the dinghy with any humanitarian assistance that they required and supplied them with food, water, fuel and lifejackets so as to reinsure the occupants’ safety. The dinghy then continued its voyage on its own steam.
- The AFM surface vessel continued monitoring the dinghy so as to be in a position to intervene should its occupants require any assistance or rescue. On the morning of Thursday 20th August, as the dinghy was approaching Italian territorial waters, the Maltese authorities informed the Italian authorities through the European Patrolling Network about its presence. The dinghy was then intercepted by a patrol boat of the Italian Guardia di Finanza and its occupants taken ashore to Lampedusa.
- It must be noted that at no time did the AFM patrol boat lose contact with the dinghy from the moment it was intercepted until the immigrants were recovered by the Guardia di Finanza.
The statements of the High Commissioner for Human Rights regarding this case seem to be based on the same misinformation that had appeared in the Italian media over the past weeks. One would expect an official in High Commissioner Pillay’s capacity to check the facts with the relevant authorities rather than passing a judgement based on the second or third hand information that appears in the media.
From the timeline of events above it is amply evident that the Maltese Authorities acted well within their international obligations and standards of conducts at sea. The action taken by the Maltese authorities in this case proved effective since the 5 occupants in the dinghy that was first spotted all made it to land safely.
It should also be made absolutely clear that forcefully rescuing the occupants of the dinghy against their express wishes and in the absence of a real and imminent danger of loss of life, as the High Commissioner is suggesting, would be an illegal exercise of jurisdiction.
Finally, it is worth reminding that Malta has consistently been abiding by its international SAR responsibilities for decades. It will continue doing so in the years to come.
Other Press Releases:
PR261987
STQARRIJA MILL-MINISTERU GĦALL-INKLUŻJONI U L-VOLONTARJAT Imfakkar il-65 a...
PR261986en