Left arrow Go Back

ADDRESS BY THE HON. CENSU GALEA, MINISTER FOR COMPETITIVENESS AND COMMUNICATIONS, DURING THE SEMINAR ‘MARITIME AFFAIRS AND THE LISBON STRATEGY: THE EUROPEAN COMMISSION’S GREEN PAPER AND THE WORKERS’ DIMENSION’ – SLIEMA – FRIDAY, 4TH MAY 2007

PR0649
Date Icon 04/05/2007

The seminar was organised by the Academy for the Development of a Democratic Environment (AZAD), in collaboration with the European Centre for Workers’ Questions (EZA), and with the support of the European Commission.

When I received the invitation to address your seminar, I was pleasantly surprised. Naturally, I am quite used to being invited to address issues to do with maritime affairs as they fall under my portfolio. However, it is not often that a Minister for Competitiveness and Communications is asked to address representatives of trade unions and adult education centres. So, I welcome the occasion to discuss with you matters that are of direct and profound importance to European workers. 

As with the rest of our European partners, Malta is committed to the goals of the Lisbon Strategy, that is, to contribute to making the Europe the most competitive, green and knowledge-based economy in the world by 2010. I do not believe that becoming the most competitive economy in the world means that we need to dilute our commitment to solidarity; on the contrary. Solidarity can complement competitiveness. It gives people the confidence and the means to invest in their continuing education, which is essential for their productivity and employability. Solidarity helps create a physically healthier and more cohesive society – and that would enhance competitiveness, too.  

The Lisbon Strategy does mean, however, that we need to consider competitiveness and solidarity not just in a European context, but also within the framework of global networks. Sustainable development for Europe cannot be developed by Europe alone. In the Baltic, what happens in Russia will affect all the EU Member States as well; similarly, what happens in North Africa will affect the Mediterranean EU members. And what we know about climate change tells us that what happens in the polar ice-caps affects the entire world. It is in this context that the European Commission, on June 6, 2006, issued its Green Paper on a holistic European policy for maritime affairs. The term ‘maritime’ was used by the Commission to cover a wider sense than usual. It covers not only merchant shipping but also affairs to do with underwater and the seabed, and with the sea-to-land and sea-to-air interfaces. In short, it covers matters to do with tourism, climate change, fisheries, aquaculture, the energy and mineral resources of the sea, as well as the cultural resources on the seabed.  

Obviously, such wide-ranging matters do not fall within any single ministerial portfolio. Although the issues are wide-ranging, they are inter-related, in several and intricate ways. The nature of many maritime security problems has an ecological, economic and political (not to say, sometimes, military) dimension – whether the issue is, for example, the protection of fish stocks, the stewardship of marine mineral resources (like oil), the management of coastal areas or shipping. 

Maritime affairs promise to become more important as this century unfolds, and the sea becomes a more vital source of food, new knowledge and new economic opportunities. The sea’s bio-resources, energy, and minerals, to name only three areas, still need much research to be well understood. However, clearly they can help underpin a green, knowledge-based, competitive economy. At stake are the competitiveness of our economy, its sustainable development, and its strategic positioning for the future. The greater the importance assumed by matters to do with the sea in the 21st century, the more important it becomes for these affairs to be coordinated and governed in a holistic manner. Competing uses of the sea – by entrepreneurs, by fishermen, by leisure seekers, by researchers – to name just four different groups, need not just to be assessed but also planned in a rational and equitable way.  

Malta and Maritime Affairs 

When the Commission first announced that it was preparing a Green Paper on maritime affairs, Malta welcomed the news. Our dependence on the sea, not to mention our small size, made us acutely sensitive to the interdependence of states when it came to the governance of ocean-space. Indeed, almost forty years ago, Malta was the first country to advocate a holistic approach to the governance of the world’s oceans – its Permanent Representative to the UN drew the attention of the General Assembly to the need for a new comprehensive regime governing humankind’s activities on the oceans. This initiative, which culminated in the 1982 UN Convention on the Law of the Sea, was based on the fundamental premise that all the problems of the oceans are closely inter-related and need to be considered as a whole. Forty years on, the need for a holistic approach is evident. The consultation process throughout the European Union is entering its twelfth month. If progress is made in developing a holistic approach that respects subsidiarity and solidarity, it will mean that the sea will become a source not just of new wealth, but also of new kinds of employment.  

Malta’s interest in maritime affairs stems not just from our existing maritime industries, but also from new areas that hold out the prospect of important economic growth. A conservative estimate puts the contribution to Malta’s GDP from the maritime sector at 15%. However, this product is contributed almost entirely from what might be called the ‘old maritime economy’ – such as shipping and fishing. In the medium and long-term, Malta would like to enter new areas of economic production. Shipping, coastal tourism, the fishing and aquaculture industries will continue to be, of course, an abiding concern. Government is also taking initiatives in other, newer maritime areas such as coastal management, which span a range of ministerial portfolios. The aim is to build up Maltese expertise – in production or services, training of personnel, research and the development of technologies that explore, exploit, conserve or manage the marine environment. 

Such considerations show how a holistic maritime policy would help implement the Lisbon Strategy in a manner appropriate for a maritime state like Malta. It is the way to incorporate our natural environment fully – since it consists as much of sea, as of land and air-space. Malta’s perspective, however, is influenced not just by our country’s characteristics because our national perspective cannot be divorced from an internationalist one. Some of the sea’s most important resources – like fish and mineral resources in the water column – do not respect national jurisdictions. Ecological standards adopted by one jurisdiction do not yield anywhere near their full benefit if they are not also adopted by neighbouring jurisdictions. Moreover, unlike land-based territory, some parts of the sea are ‘high seas’, lying beyond any national jurisdiction.  

These three considerations, to do with resources, pollution and high seas, indicate that Malta’s efforts cannot be secured unless in partnership with other states. Given the inter-related nature of maritime problems, and their relevance for Europe’s Lisbon Strategy, our partnership will have to develop not just in conjunction with those Member States that have a Mediterranean coast; but with all Member States, including, as Malta insisted prior to the publication of the Commission’s Green Paper, the landlocked states of Europe. As not all seas are the same,  European cooperation will need to take regional particularities into account. Malta has proposed that such particularities are best managed through a network for regional management that would respect the specificity of seas as different and sensitive as the Baltic and the Mediterranean. It would be a network operating within the existing international regulatory framework, and seeking to promote a stable and safe maritime order. It would bring together and consolidate the work and perspectives of such institutions and programmes as the General Fisheries Council for the Mediterranean, the International Maritime Organisation, the Mediterranean Action Plan, the Mediterranean Science Commission and the Intergovernmental Oceanographic Commission.  

We believe that such management would increase regional prosperity as well as enhancing each state’s competitiveness. In the Mediterranean context, we believe it would help foster trust and partnership between North and South, to which Malta is strongly committed. 

Maritime Affairs and Solidarity 

The cultivation of the new economy in the sectors to do with maritime affairs will require considerable investment in capital, infrastructure and human resources. The success of the holistic approach also calls for more than one kind of solidarity. One kind of solidarity would need to be shown with our non-EU partners, which in this context, would include seeking to reach maritime-related cooperation agreements with our non-EU neighbours, where possible. Malta has proposed that the Union should consider giving special development aid in those cases where non-EU neighbours would like to cooperate but are hindered by the cost of participating in certain initiatives. It is also clear, however, whether solidarity within the EU will also need to be practised in this field. Over the past year of consultation, the Green Paper has been considered from various perspectives – national, regional and sectoral. It is important that the new maritime economy, together with the classic forms of maritime employment, is considered from the labour perspective, too. The debate on the Green Paper would be greatly enriched by the views of workers’ organisations.  

One aspect of the debate needs to address the specific needs of workers involved directly in the maritime sector. There are areas of maritime employment where work conditions, for various reasons, continue to lag behind the established standards. One prominent example is employment in the maritime sector where working on a boat or ship, whether as a fisherman or a merchant sailor, involves discomforts and risks that cannot be easily addressed by standards devised for workers operating in buildings on land – both because sea vessels require special standards of their own, and because the legal authority of the standards do not apply in the same way as they do on land.

With respect to shipping, in many cases what matters is the flag that the ship flies. Malta knows this well: it has one of the largest shipping registries in the world, and naturally is not against raising the standards of the shipping industry; but it is very much aware that any European initiative that affects only the flags of Member States will simply result in ship-owners switching to a non-EU flag: they would still be able to enter European ports! All that would have happened would be a weakening of the collective European register, and therefore a weakening of Europe’s ability to use its influence to raise standards in the global shipping industry.

 The work of fishermen has always been dangerous, but there is an added element of insecurity today. The sustainability of fisheries is at risk. It can only be adequately addressed if the appropriate standards are adopted by all the coastal States of a sea; adequate protection of the livelihood of EU fishermen requires that the EU enters into regional management agreements with non-EU States. There is also a second kind of insecurity: the tensions between fishing boats of different nationalities have sometimes escalated into armed confrontations – a dramatic indication of how different the working conditions at sea may be from those on land. 

In addition to people who work at sea, there is a mixed group of workers on land, living or working in tourism in coastal areas, which also requires some special attention. The numbers involved should not be underestimated. Nowadays, whenever we hear the phrase ‘demographic shift’ we tend automatically to think of the problem of the ageing population. However, there has been another demographic shift in Europe over the past few decades: a shift from the continental heartlands to the coastal areas, which are now the most heavily populated. Many of these areas depend on tourism as a major source of income, and in some, it is practically the only source of income. The seasonality of some kinds of tourism raises special considerations for the workers involved in it. But most critical of all is the dependence on the ecological security of the sea: should there be an ecological collapse, the economic damage would be immense. In a sea like the Mediterranean, a concern with ecological security is a pressing one. The southern, North African and Middle Eastern coast is heavily populated, too, and in a context of significant demographic growth and urbanisation that is placing heavy pressure on municipal services. Once again, since an adequate approach to ecological security should involve all the relevant coastal States, the protection of EU workers in this regard requires the EU to attempt to reach agreements with non-EU States on ecological standards. 

Maritime Affairs and Social Dialogue 

All these considerations indicate that the stakeholders in maritime affairs today are many and various. As their interests may very often be conflicting, wide consultation and debate over guiding principles, best practices and possible coordinating mechanisms is needed. It is no coincidence that the consultation period for this Green Paper, which is almost thirteen months, is the longest such consultation period ever dedicated by the Commission to a Green Paper. Malta, too, is organising a national consultation on these issues. The process of coordination and consolidation began well over a year ago, with the consultation of the various ministries and authorities with an interest in maritime affairs: a non-exhaustive list would include not just the Ministries for the Environment and for Tourism and Culture, but also those for Foreign Affairs and Home Affairs; not just the Malta Maritime Authority, but also the Resources Authority, and the Planning Authority. A Maritime Permanent Forum was set up within Government, under my chairmanship, to tackle the relevant issues and questions.

 This February a national conference was organised, through which we reached the second phase of this process of coordination and consolidation: the initiation of a wider consultation, outside Government and the authorities, with stakeholders among local councils, the private sector and NGOs. In conducting this social dialogue, our aims are threefold. First, we want to enrich our sense of the range of interests and points of view. We have a good idea of what many if not all of them are. But it makes a difference to see them represented together. The process of constructing a holistic policy involves bringing, the various voices together early on. It gives a clearer idea of what harmony needs to be orchestrated.  

We are also aware that the views of stakeholders are continually developing and are likely to continue to do so. So we want to hear not only from those organisations and individuals who have already articulated views on the questions we and the Green Paper are discussing but we are also interested in meeting with those organisations and individuals who may not currently have a well-defined view of their particular interests in relation to the whole, but who may soon be articulating important views on the subject.  

May I add that seminars like yours, which bring together representatives of workers and adult education centres from around the European Union, are important for our consultation process. As I have already said, Malta’s perspective has to be an internationalist one. Government also believes that the success of the Lisbon Strategy needs to be accompanied by a commitment to solidarity. Your discussions and debates during this seminar will help enrich our understanding both of what internationalism must mean, and what kind of solidarity is required. You have my very best wishes for a fruitful weekend of discussion. Thank you.

Share this Press Release Icon socials Icon socials Icon socials Icon socials

Other Press Releases:

STQARRIJA MILL-UFFIĊĊJU TAL-PRIM MINISTRU  Il-Prim Ministru Robert Abela jinawgura investiment ta’ €50 miljun f’San Ġiljan

PR261960

STQARRIJA MILL-UFFIĊĊJU TAL-PRIM MINISTRU Il-Prim Ministru Robert Abela ji...

PRESS RELEASE BY THE OFFICE OF THE SPEAKER  The Speaker of the House of Representatives Meets Ambassadors of Guatemala, Lebanon and Vietnam

PR261959en

PRESS RELEASE BY THE OFFICE OF THE SPEAKER The Speaker of the House of Rep...

More Press Releases Right arrow