REPLY TO PRESS RELEASE ISSUED TODAY BY BIRDLIFE MALTA
PR0562
20/04/2007
In response to the Press Release issued by BirdLife Malta dated 20th April 2007, the Chairman of the ORNIS Committee would like to make the following clarifications:-
| (1) | A special meeting of the ORNIS Committee was called on 4th April 2007 with the specific aim of discussing the first draft of the methodology submitted by Professor Jean Claude Ricci, Scientific Director of IMPCF - France, which was intended to be used for the study entrusted to him in connection with the migration of Turtle Dove and Common Quail over the Maltese Islands in Spring and Autumn. IMPCF is an institute of international fame that has specialised in bird migration, by census, radar and bio-acoustics for more than 70 years. The Institute has made various studies in France and other countries. |
| (2) | Professor Ricci was present throughout the ORNIS meeting of the 4th April 2007 and took extensive notes of the remarks and concerns of the members of the Committee in connection with the draft methodology submitted by him. Subsequently two separate meetings were held between Professor Ricci and representatives of Malta BirdLife (MBL) and the Federazzjoni Kaccaturi Nassaba Konservazzjonisti (FKNK) during which the draft methodology was also discussed. Again Professor Ricci took note of any valid comments made during these two meetings with the NGOs. |
| (3) | At the ORNIS meeting of the 4th April 2007 it was agreed to adjourn the meeting “to a few days after receipt of the revised methodology. This should be held during the week between the 16th April – 20th April” – (quote from the minutes). |
| (4) | On 13th April 2007 Professor Ricci sent the Chairman of the ORNIS Committee a new document on the study, which contained a revised and improved methodology of the study based on the notes he had taken during the meetings referred at (1) and (2) above. |
| (5) | As a consequence to the decision taken by the ORNIS Committee at its meeting of the 4th April 2007 as indicated at (3) above, the Chairman called an urgent meeting of the Committee on the 19th April 2007 to discuss and, if the Committee, agreed to approve the new revised methodology by Professor Ricci so that it can be used and tested even during the spring season of 2007. |
| (6) | It was, therefore, very obvious that the main aim for convening the meeting of the 19th April was that of discussing the revised methodology by Professor Ricci and, if the Committee agreed, to approve it. During the said meeting the Chairman told the members that he had been informed that the paid observers had been directed as from Monday 16th April 2007 to start collecting data of the two migrating bird species in question from specified study sites around Malta and Gozo. These paid observers were recruited after the issue of a public call. The analytical assessment and computerised analyses of the collected data would be subject to the methodology that had still to be discussed and approved by the ORNIS Committee at its meeting on the 19th April 2007. |
| (7) | At the ORNIS meeting of the 4th April the Malta BirdLife representatives on the Committee had proposed that the Committee should not take a decision on the methodology during that particular meeting in order to have the time and opportunity to study the methodology in more detail and get further expert advice. The Chairman accepted this proposal and as a result he recommended, and the Committee accepted, that no vote was to be taken at the end of the meeting. |
| (8) | At the meeting of the 19th April it was considered that all members had been given enough time to study and respond to the two drafts as submitted by Professor Ricci. Besides the notes taken by Professor Ricci during his encounters in Malta, all subsequent written remarks by ORNIS members, MEPA, NGOs, and other interested persons, were passed to Professor Ricci for his consideration. His second draft document of the 13th April 2007, which was transmitted to all ORNIS members on receipt by the secretary of the Committee, had taken into consideration all that was relevant in the inputs he received during his visit in Malta and also the subsequent correspondence exchanged with him. In the circumstances, it was felt that at the ORNIS meeting of the 19th April enough discussion had taken place for a final decision to be taken on the methodology that had to be adopted for the study. The majority of the members present during the meeting agreed with this stand and a vote was therefore taken as to whether to adopt or reject the second and revised draft submitted by Professor Ricci. Of the eligible voting members five, including the Chairman, voted in favour and one against. |
| (9) | The Chairman ORNIS Committee would like to reiterate his appeal to all sides of the issue to join forces and cooperate in this study to make it a success for the benefit of all concerned. |
Other Press Releases:
PR261959en
PRESS RELEASE BY THE OFFICE OF THE SPEAKER The Speaker of the House of Rep...
PR261959