CLOSING SPEECH BY THE HON. DR. CARMELO MIFSUD BONNICI, PARLIAMENTARY SECRETARY IN THE MINISTRY OF JUSTICE AND HOME AFFAIRS, AT THE EUROMED JUSTICE SEMINAR ON ”IMPLICATIONS OF DUAL NATIONALITY” – FLORIANA - 16TH NOVEMBER 2006
Distinguished Jurists,
Guests and Colleagues.
It is a pleasure to be here, at the end of this four-day seminar held in Malta, to deliver this closing speech to such a distinguished group of professionals. My Ministry is indeed proud of this Seminar, one which yet again was successfully organized by Euro-Med, and here a special word of appreciation must go to Mr Eduardo Sanchez Monjo, Director of the Euro-Med Justice Programme and of the European Institute of Public Administration, and Ms Alejandra Martinez Boluda, Acting Coordinator within the same institution. A seminar, which has brought you together in order to exchange experiences, knowledge and good practices on this important and vital subject. A matter which is also an issue of fundamental human rights in today’s modern legal environment. I am sure that there can only be a positive outcome to the many hours that you have spent discussing in open debates and working groups – at the end of the day, increased cooperation and international judicial mutual assistance in civil matters is in our best interest. And this, both on a practical level and on an academic one. Nationality is also part of citizenship and this brings forward not only economic or political powers, but also has a special mark.
The chosen topic, focusing on the implications of dual nationality, is most appropriate to our country, which through limitation of size and economy, in the past had to lose many of its youths who chose to seek their fortunes abroad. Had we not had the concept of dual nationality in place in our laws, many emigrants and their future generations could have lost their Maltese identity in the legal and in the basic social roots.
Malta had remained a single nationality State for a period of 25 years, that is, from Independence in 1964 up to 1989 when the citizenship amendments introduced dual citizenship for the first time, directed mostly in respect of Maltese emigrants.
Malta became an independent State on 21 September 1964. Accordingly, the Constitution of Malta was enacted by the Malta Independence Order 1964 and Chapter III of the said Constitution is dedicated to citizenship. The Constitution established that persons born in Malta before the 21stSeptember 1964, one of whose parents was also born in Malta, became automatically citizens of Malta on the 21st September 1964 (jus soli/jus sanguinis). It established further that persons born in Malta after independence acquired Maltese citizenship by mere birth in Malta (jus soli).
The principle was then also established that a Maltese citizen shall not have any other nationality and that if a person who is a citizen of Malta possessed any other citizenship whilst still a minor, that person had to decide which citizenship to retain between his eighteenth and nineteenth birthday. Moreover Maltese citizens who, when of adult age acquired the citizenship of some other country, ceased to be automatically citizens of Malta. Furthermore, foreigners who acquired Maltese citizenship by registration or naturalisation had to renounce any other citizenship held by them within six months or three months as the case may be. Acts which, though deemed to protect our concept of nationality, were serving as a humiliating experience – at times also a source of family problems.
It has to be pointed out that a number of related legislative amendments were made in 1965, when the Maltese Citizenship Act was introduced, in 1970 when the Immigration Act was enacted, and in 1974, when Malta became a Republic. However, up till 1989, in so far as dual citizenship is concerned the position under Maltese citizenship law remained relatively unchanged. This first step was not very easy to achieve because initially the persons concerned had to satisfy a number of criteria. Moreover, the consent of the other country had to be accepted, as otherwise it would have been futile to regain Maltese citizenship and then lose the citizenship of the country of emigration. These conditions could, perhaps, though some have considered them rigorous; nevertheless many former citizens of Malta qualified to be reinstated as citizens of Malta.
The significant changes to Maltese citizenship legislation, in particular where dual nationality is concerned, were effected in February 2000. By means of new provisions in the Maltese Citizenship Act, dual or rather multiple nationality, was made the rule rather than the exception it was previously. Government indeed decided that it was time to make substantial and more liberal changes in our citizenship legislation and allow Maltese citizens to possess another nationality or other nationalities. This measure affected the national status of thousands of first generation Maltese, born outside Malta to Maltese migrants, who could be found in countries which allow dual citizenship – the majority of whom reside in Australia, the United Kingdom, Canada and the United States of America. It should be noted also that, since the year 2000, non-Maltese citizens who are registered or naturalized as citizens of Malta are no longer required to renounce any other citizenship held by them, as was previously the case. Thus these persons could hold also dual or multiple nationality.
In conclusion, I note with a sense of personal appreciation that one of the sub-topics which has been included in the seminar has been the solving of family disputes through mediation. Such acknowledgement emanates from the fact that the Ministry for Justice and Home Affairs has been on the forefront on this matter. Indeed, it is relevant to point out that we have enacted the Mediation Act, in 2004, in order to encourage and facilitate the settlement of disputes in Malta through mediation, to establish a Malta Mediation Centre as a centre for domestic, family, civil and commercial fields and international mediation and to make provisions regulating the conduct of the mediation process.
I have to point out that Mediation does not present any great complications in one’s efforts to understand it. It is a process by which a person, independent and impartial, “super partes”, intervenes between the two persons that have already initiated, or are about to initiate, a case of separation, the end in view being to lead them towards a settlement. The mediator undertakes the task of the intermediary, to bring together and reconcile, instead of allowing the two parties to fall out and draw further away from each other. In this manner, help is given to both parties to understand where they are heading. This means fewer hasty decisions, taken in anger or impulsively, as each party would know what is at stake and what can be awarded, and can better understand the consequences, even on the financial side.
Mediation presents a number of advantages on which we have to build and rely so that the citizen could incur lesser fees, waste less time and solve problems through a system which fosters participation towards an agreement rather than confrontation. Mediation is different from the Court or from Arbitration, however all three can co-exist together.
Our experience of mediation, especially in family matters, has been a success as our recent statistics show. I wish you all a safe journey back home and trust that you will cherish your memories of this Seminar, as well as those of your stay in Malta.
Other Press Releases:
PR261958EN
PRESS RELEASE BY THE MINISTRY FOR THE ECONOMY, TECHNOLOGY AND STRATEGIC PRO...
PR261958