Left arrow Go Back

Address by the Minister for Tourism and Culture, Dr Francis Zammit Dimech at the Radisson Business Times Breakfast on “Golf courses for tourism”

pr1380
Date Icon 28/09/2005

The tourism sector’s future is all about competitiveness. Competitiveness demands a strong emphasis on the product.

Between1999 and 2004 Five Star hotels increased from eight to 13, with two more due to open this year. During the same period beds in Five Star hotels went up from 2,878 to 5,040. There was also an increase in Four Star hotels from 46 in 1999 to 55 in 2004. Government embellished promenades in Sliema, St Julian’s, Gzira, Marsascala and Birzebbuga. St George’s Bay in St Julian’s was developed into a blue flag standard beach with all amenities and with management provided by the Malta Tourism Authority.  Malta ’s arterial roads were modernised to European standards. The Ministry for Tourism and Culture is in the process – through EU funding – of embellishing the roads from the Cruise Liner Passenger Terminal to Valletta and of embellishing Howard Gardens on the outskirts of Imdina. Through the intervention of the inter-ministerial committee on tourism the entire route from Luqa airport to Valletta is being embellished.
Wedepend for a quarter of our national product and for a third of employment on tourism.  This makes Malta the most dependent country on tourism within the 25 European Union States.
Whatis the relevance of golf in all this context? According to a study undertaken by the National Golf Foundation of the USA , golfers spend between $2,500 and $3,000 per trip and travel at least twice a year. In the USA, which has 16,200 golf courses and Europe with 5,700 golf courses it is usually only possible to play golf for seven months a year because of the weather during the rest of the year traveller golfers look for warm, relatively dry destinations in which to take a golfing holiday. Many European and Mediterranean countries with a high dependency upon holiday tourism have recently identified golf as an important feature of their respective tourism development strategies.
Golfis frequently seen as a significant attraction for the higher yield tourist. This sport is also recognised as a means of extending the tourist season into the shoulder and off-peak periods.
Many European andMediterranean countries with a high dependency on holiday tourism identified golf as an important feature of their respective tourism strategy. Three destinations in the Mediterranean region, which can be considered as our competitors, are Morocco , Tunisia and Cyprus .

·     Morocco , with the construction of 18 golf courses is becoming an important golfing destination.

·     Tunisia is rapidly gaining a reputation for being one of the Mediterranean ’s foremost golfing destinations.

·     Cyprus offers golfers challenging word class championship courses.

·     Spain and Portugal are also becoming increasingly popular with golfers from all over Europe .  

Thesecountries have long been popular tourist destinations and golf is an added attraction to the fine weather, sandy beaches and colonial architecture, with Malta losing out on this huge potential. A golf trip to Europe is particularly recommended not only for the golf but also for the sheer richness of cultures, landscapes and cities. Each European country has a strong and individual character for the tourist to explore, and Malta certainly has the right ingredients to successfully compete, and dare I say establish a competitive advantage in this regard because of its rich cultural heritage in addition to sun and sea.
Witha population in Europe that is progressively ageing and with golf particularly enjoyed by older people this is a significant visitor market sector for Malta . During the period 1994 – 2000 the proportion of tourists arriving in Malta aged 50 and over varied between 128,000 and 152,000. Thus this is a relatively stable visitor market. It is also estimated that the over 50’s represent roughly a quarter of all golf players globally.
Anindication of the seasonal pattern for a mature golf industry is given by the UK , which has the highest national rate of participation per capita in Europe with over 4000 golf clubs, out of which 2,600 are in the British Isles . Incidentally the UK is our prime tourism market. The peak season for outbound UK golf travel is the winter months of November through March as in the summer months UK golfers tend to play in their home country or take short breaks in northern France .
Whythree golf courses? Speaking to the people in the industry it is apparent that many golfers take one or two golf holidays a year, with each holiday lasting about three to four nights. This would allow the tourist to play two or three rounds of golf. Whilst the tourist might prefer to play a different course each time, if the course is challenging enough he would seek to play it at least twice. The representatives of the Marsa Sports Club themselves have repeatedly made the case for more than one golf course!
InMalta both the Government and the Opposition are in favour of three golf courses, two in Malta and one in Gozo. It seems that where we do not completely agree is about the siting of the other golf course in Malta . In August 1997 Government introduced a policy paper entitled “Golf Course Development in Malta ”. At the same time a Notice for Registrations of Interest in the Development of Golf Course was issued. 26 Registrations were received of which 12 were valid. Four of these applications indicated the Maghtab Landfill site as a golf course site. This was considered as a potential site but could not be considered for immediate development due to emission of gases and ground settlement. It is estimated that to clean up the site of all contamination and gases will take at least another ten years!
Thesites short listed at that time were the Verdala site in Rabat and ‘Il-Bisqra’, Mellieha on State owned land and the Ta’ Habel Bellu between Rabat and Zebbug predominantly on State owned land.  In Gozo the site chosen was at Ta’ Cenc.
Thepolicy framework for the location of golf course is provided for through planning policies in particular the Structure Plan for the Maltese Islands of 1992 and the Golf Course Development Policy Paper of 1997. Following the present Government’s announcement that there should be one golf course in Malta and another in Gozo, MEPA was asked to identify suitable sites for such development by end of October 2004. An exercise was undertaken to review a number of potential sites and come up with a shortlist of sites. Sites were assessed with regard to environmental and planning implications as well as in terms of golf course design requirements.
Itis estimated that for an 18-hole golf course at least 48 to 50 hectares of land should be available. Courses are best situated in undulating country with shallow rises. Ten sites were considered in Dingli/Siggiewi; White Rocks/Madliena area; Maghtab; Quarry areas in Mqabba; Tal-Gawhar in Safi/Zurrieq; Dwejra area in San Lawrenz; Ghajn  Melel in Zebbug, Gozo; Pembroke; Habel Bellu in Rabat; Ta’ Cenc in Gozo and Xaghra l-Hamra and Qortin areas in Mellieha. Of these, four sites were shortlisted in Malta and two sites were short listed in Gozo. The Xaghra l-Hamra site in Mellieha was chosen for further consideration. The selection of this site would require a careful balance between conservation and development. This is to ensure that the outcome would result in an overall net benefit. The Pembroke site could not be considered since the area in question, unlike that now proposed for development, is scheduled.
Theproposed site for the development of the golf course is located on a plateau above Ghajn Tuffieha/Golden Bay beaches in  the area known as Ix-Xaghra il-Hamra. One should immediately point out that the site recommended by MEPA as the most suitable for golf development is NOT the same area that Government had asked MEPA to consider. The site earmarked for the project has a total area of approximately 114 hectares whereas a typical 18-hole championship golf course would require between 40 and 50 hectares of land. Putting it simply, this means that the total area being considered is such that a good quality golf course can be designed while at the same time excluding any important ecological or cultural heritage sites as well as, and as far as possible, agricultural land.
Thegolf course project is being managed by the Malta Tourism Authority which set up a technical team to oversee the project. Architects, golf course designers and environmental consultants were engaged and a time table for the planning and environmental impact assessment process has been established with MEPA. Initial surveys have commenced. A Project Description Statement has been formulated and submitted to MEPA. The golf course will be designed by Hawtree Ltd, a firm with a long history and an excellent reputation in golf course design and construction. In line with best practice, the design of the golf course will proceed in tandem with and will be guided by the EIA process so that the environmental constraints identified through the latter will be incorporated in the former.
TheMinistry for Tourism and Culture together with MTA are committed to public participation in the process. They will endeavour to provide information on the process on a regular basis to further enhance the public’s involvement in this project. Further opportunities for public participation will be available as part of the planning and EIA process.
Governmentis committed to enhance product Malta . This not only entails the provision of upscale hotels but the necessary infrastructure for the embellishment of our islands and of projects that will attract high yield tourists. The golfers are just one section of these tourists. Golf courses provided additional facilities, added value for a holiday. Golf courses are also a potential element in attracting CIT visitors of whom we already cater for about 60,000 a year, each of which is equates to 3 average tourists in terms of spend.
Wehave to strike a balance. We will protect the environment, agriculture and our heritage. Equally, we have to protect our tourism industry which accounts for a quarter of our national wealth. For this to happen we must take decisions in the right direction.

I would like to assert that this project offers us a unique win-win opportunity. It offers the tourism industry the kind of project that offers present and new visitors an amenity that is offered by all our competitors. We owe it to the industry to move ahead, and not carry on discussing it for another decade simply because there are elements who are dead set against such development, even though no design details have yet been proposed to identify the specific take up of land, which can only be determined once the EIA studies are concluded and evaluated.  

Theproject will also provide precise space for real estate development to ensure its possibility.  This project offers environmentalists the opportunity of managing the landscape which is erroneously, if not maliciously, indicated by certain quarters as forming part of the development when in fact it does not. To this effect, NGOs have been invited to enter into a contract with Government that will establish precise footprints and parameters and lead to a professionally run natural park along all of the coastal zone, which although scheduled is as yet not managed at all and therefore not enjoyed, apart from facing degradation.  We also guarantee to take into account all environmental considerations and will only proceed with the project if the environmental impact assessment confirms that the project is feasible and can move ahead on a balance of all relevant considerations.
Golfindustry as a whole has become much more aware of environmental issues, and is now a matter of routine that new golf projects provide a number of environmental assessment studies. Alongside all this, over the last decade or so, the golf authorities have sponsored a number of golf-ecology programmes. There is a growing network of national, or regional golf-ecology projects and a fair amount of research underpinning all this. It is fair to say that today we know a lot more about the environmental impacts of golf and we can be more comfortable in the belief that by and large, golf courses are environmentally beneficial.
Itoffers farmers adequate safeguards through unbiased and genuine dialogue. Above all, it offers Malta and its people the opportunity of making a leap forward in the overall product that we offer our own and visitors alike.
Thatleap forward will be easier when we learn to discuss issues calmly rather than emotionally, objectively rather than from a biased perspective, when we genuinely and sincerely seek the common good rather than an opportunistic score board.
Share this Press Release Icon socials Icon socials Icon socials Icon socials

Other Press Releases:

STQARRIJA MILL-UFFIĊĊJU TAD-DEPUTAT PRIM MINISTRU U MINISTERU GĦAS-SAĦĦA   Aktar mediċini mill-Formularju tal-Gvern se jkunu jistgħu jiġu mibdija jew imġedda mit-tobba privati tal-familja

PR261948

STQARRIJA MILL-UFFIĊĊJU TAD-DEPUTAT PRIM MINISTRU U MINISTERU GĦAS-SAĦĦA ...

STQARRIJA MILL-UFFIĊĊJU TAD-DEPUTAT PRIM MINISTRU U MINISTERU GĦAS-SAĦĦA  Ċertifikazzjoni internazzjonali tal-ogħla livell għad-dipartiment tar-radjoterapija fiċ-Ċentru tal-Onkoloġija Sir Anthony Mamo

PR261947

STQARRIJA MILL-UFFIĊĊJU TAD-DEPUTAT PRIM MINISTRU U MINISTERU GĦAS-SAĦĦA Ċ...

More Press Releases Right arrow