SPEECH BY THE HON. DR. JASON AZZOPARDI, CHAIRMAN, STANDING COMMITTEE ON FOREIGN AND EUROPEAN AFFAIRS, AT THE CONFERENCE ON THE DRAFT CONSTITUTION FOR EUROPE – BRIDGING THE GAP BETWEEN THE EU AND THE MEMBER STATES : THE ROLE OF NATIONAL PARLIAMENTS
Is a greater role of national parliaments necessary? The answer is yes.
Public support for the European political project cannot be automatically assumed. Participation to the European Parliament elections has been dwindling constantly from a high of 63.6% (9 countries) in 1979 to 45.7% (25 countries) in 2004. In recent years the involvement of national parliaments has been encouraged as a means of increasing the democratic legitimacy of decisions taken at European level.
Members of national parliaments are closest to the public and they have been elected to appoint and influence their governments. Thus, they should also form part of the decision-making process forged within the EU institutions. Scrutiny of policy and proposals emanating from Brussels is an important facet of the role of national parliaments in EU affairs.
Both the European Parliament (EP) and National Parliaments (NPs) have criticised openly the democratic deficit and endeavoured to reduce it. Until 1979, the EP and NPs were linked organically. Direct election to the EP broke those ties. The Maastricht Treaties helped ignite these ties by including two declarations:
· Respecting the NP’s involvement in the activities of the EU
· Cooperation between the EP and the NPs, by stepping up contacts, holding regular
meetings and granting reciprocal facilities.
Subsequently, this was annexed to the Treaty of Amsterdam and as a declaration to the Nice Treaty (2000) and Laeken (2001). Finally, the Convention on the Future of Europe adopted a Protocol on the role of national parliaments in the European Union.
We highly commend the recent initiative taken by the European Parliament in initiating the “Co-operation and Exchange Programme” aimed at strengthening direct contacts and dialogue between members and staff of the European Parliament and National Parliaments alike. I sincerely hope that this latest initiative will take off in a positive manner and produce concrete results and not end up as a talking shop. This is more relevant today as in recent years “national parliamentary diplomacy” has gained recognition and influence within international fora.
National parliamentary diplomacy should become the norm for our parliament, especially in the context of EU membership. Our national MPs should recognise the importance that such a tool could have in enhancing relations between national parliaments. Since May 2004, the workload of the Foreign and European Affairs Committee has increased enormously and so have the number of meetings with foreign dignitaries as well as other European parliamentary delegations such as Belgium, Denmark, Croatia, the Czech Republic, the UK and Italy.
In this context, the “Co-operation and Exchange Programme” launched by the European Parliament should act as a forum whereby inter-parliamentary exchanges are encouraged and to a certain degree institutionalised vis-à-vis the dominance of intergovernmentalism (the European Council) within the Union. This could act as a bridge in reducing the democratic deficit. Such a Programme should widen its remit and organise yearly conferences and encourage ties with national parliaments that are on the fringes of Europe both in the Mediterranean basin as well as South-Eastern Europe.
Sensitive issues common to the European Union and its outskirts such as immigration, poverty, poor economic growth, lack of proper infrastructure, ageing populations, security issues and others could be tackled through such a parliamentary forum or on a more multilateral level in the Permanent Conference of EU Affairs Committees (COSAC).
The present internet-based services aimed to support inter-parliamentary cooperation such as the COSAC website, IPEX (Inter-parliamentary cooperation EU Information Exchange) and ECPRD (European Centre for Parliamentary Research and Documentation) should open up their remit and involve those parliaments that are in the fringes of Europe. Simple technological tools such as the internet and e-mail should be used more widely in influencing the EU institutions bringing Brussels closer to the people.
The European Constitution
The “Treaty establishing a Constitution for Europe”, signed in Rome on 29 October 2004, must be ratified by all 25 Member States, according to their constitutional requirements to enter into force.
The Constitution will replace existing EU Treaties. It sets out what the European Union is, what is does and how it operates. It makes clear which powers the Union has been given by the Member States and which remain with them. It makes a number of important changes which will help the growing Union operate more effectively and efficiently in meeting the challenges of our time – such as fighting cross-border crime and promoting a more dynamic European economy. It gives a bigger role to parliaments, national and European.
From being the ‘losers’ of European integration, the European Constitution will enable national parliaments to play an increasing prominent role in governing Europe.
Importantly, through the Charter of Fundamental Rights, the Constitution will enhance the protection of individual rights in the operation of the European institutions and in the implementation of European law.
Bridging the Gap
Two important protocols mentioned in the Constitution aimed at bringing the Union closer to its citizens are the following:
· The Protocol on subsidiarity and proportionality
· The Protocol on the role of national parliaments
The Protocol on the Application of the Principles of Subsidiarity and Proportionality sets out how the important new ‘yellow card’ arrangement under which national parliaments will be able to challenge legislative proposals on the grounds of subsidiarity is to apply. The Constitution provides national parliaments with a key role in ensuring that the principle of subsidiarity is fully adhered to. In future, they will be able to review legislative proposals brought forward by the Commission, and where a third of Member State parliaments express concern, the Commission will be obliged to reconsider its proposal.
However, the ‘yellow card system’ may produce unexpected results. If national parliaments submit different reasons, this might strengthen the hand of the Commission if it is minded to maintain its proposal unamended. It is also possible that national parliaments might submit flatly contradictory opinions in the name of subsidiarity. This, could increase the importance of national parliaments making at least some attempt to establish coherence between their positions.
The Protocol on the Role of National Parliaments encourages greater involvement of national parliaments in the activities of the EU and enhances their ability to express their views on legislative proposals and other issues of interest.
It provides for all legislative proposals and other important Council, Commission and Court of Auditors papers to be sent directly to parliament. It states that, in keeping with the new arrangements for national parliaments to act as subsidiarity watchdogs, parliaments can submit a reasoned opinion challenging a legislative proposal. It confirms that there should be a six-week gap between the notification of national parliaments and the placing of any legislative proposal on the Council’s agenda.
It also highlights the entitlement of national parliaments to be notified 6 months in advance of any European Council intention to use the ‘passerelle’ provision (to change from unanimity to QMV in a given area). In addition, the ECJ will have a jurisdiction to hear actions brought by Member States at the request of national parliaments on grounds of infringement of the Principle of subsidiarity.
Within the raison d’etre of EU national parliaments two schools of thought prevail with regard to scrutiny of EU pipeline acquis. There is the Westminster (UK) model that is document based as well as the Folketing (Danish) model that is mandatory.
The Westminster (UK) model
In the UK both the House of Commons and the House of Lords on the basis of documents provided by government, examine and give their views on proposals for Community legislation, and debate them where appropriate. The Government undertakes, subject to limited exceptions, not to agree to any proposal until each House has completed scrutiny. The European Scrutiny Committees in the House of Commons and the Select Committee on the European Union in the House of Lords (the “Scrutiny Committees”) have as their foundations two essential common features:
· The deposit of EU documents and explanatory memoranda
· The scrutiny reserve resolution
The two Committees scrutinise “EU documents”. The Explanatory Memorandum, is the Minister’s evidence to Parliament and is a public document. It enables the two Scrutiny Committees to assess the documents quickly and establishes at the outset the accountability of Ministers to Parliament and its Committees for their conduct with regard to them. An important aspect of the system is the Scrutiny Reserve Resolution. Both Houses have them. No Minister shall give agreement to any European Community legislative proposal, or for one of the instruments of Title V or Title VI of the EU, which is still subject to scrutiny.
Three main points may be highlighted from the UK parliamentary scrutiny. First, the discipline of Ministers having to submit Explanatory Memoranda, to respond in writing and sometimes in person, to questions raised by the Scrutiny Committees. Secondly, parliamentary scrutiny can contribute substantially to the transparency and openness of the Union’s legislative process. Thirdly, the work of the Scrutiny Committees can have a direct impact on the progress or content of legislation.
The Maltese scenario
Since Malta has become an EU member in May 2004, the Maltese Parliament has gained a new dimension, whereby our Parliament has become part and parcel of the EU decision-making process, especially throughout the whole negotiating process before any proposed legislation becomes part of the acquis and eventually transposed into Maltese law.
To this end, the Maltese Parliament on the 8 October 2003 by way of Motion 67 had amended the setting up of “The Committee on Foreign Affairs” to setting up the “The Standing Committee on Foreign and European Affairs (SCFEA)”. The SCFEA participates twice yearly at the Conference of the Community and European Affairs Committees of the Parliaments of the European Union – COSAC, a consultation and coordination body that adopts its decisions by consensus.
One of the aims of this Committee is to scrutinise all documents that originate from the EU institutions and assess their impact of legislative proposals. This work falls under the aegis of the Scrutiny Committee of the SCFEA. The core task of the Scrutiny Committee is to examine EU documents that are deposited, to assess their legal and political importance and to determine whether they are debated and analysed in more depth according to the importance and implications of the documents. With the aim of ensuring good scrutiny, the Committee has engaged four research analysts to assist it in scrutinising all the European Union’s pipeline acquis, general research and reporting support to the Committee.
The scrutiny process adopted by the Maltese Parliament is closely modelled on the UK Scrutiny System rather than the Danish model, which is mandatory. The scrutiny process in the House of Commons is document-based and includes all proposals or recommendations for legislation by the Council, and any document submitted by one Institution to another, thus bringing in Commission Green and White Papers, reports, EP amendments, Council Decisions and Recommendations. It also includes intergovernmental activity under the Common and Foreign Security Policy and on Justice and Home Affairs.
Though less than a year has passed since the Scrutiny Committee was set up, the Committee has already gained the needed respect from government Ministers. One of the most important functions of the Scrutiny Committee is that of Pre- and Post- Council Scrutiny. This is particularly important to review the extent to which the recommendations of the Committee were taken into account.
In one of the first steps of post-Council scrutiny, Deputy Prime Minister and Minister for Justice and Home Affairs Hon. Tonio Borg, has been asked twice to brief the Committee on the progress in the Justice and Home Affairs Council regarding the proposal on a Framework Decision to strengthen the criminal law framework for the enforcement of the law against ship-source pollution that Malta was strongly opposing. Minister for Competitiveness and Communications Hon. Censu Galea, also addressed the Committee on this issue.
Moreover, in the coming weeks various Ministers will be giving presentations to the Committee as part of post-Council scrutiny, Minister for Tourism and Culture Hon. Francis Zammit Dimech will give a presentation on a meeting that was held between the EU Ministers for Education and Culture to discuss the educational and cultural priorities of the EU.
Parliamentary Secretary in the Ministry of Finance Hon. Tonio Fenech will give a presentation on the recent ECOFIN meeting which discussed the reform of the “Growth and Stability Pact.” that was held on the 8th March. Minister for Rural Affairs and the Environment Hon. George Pullicino will be giving a presentation on the “European Fisheries Fund” which was discussed during the European Parliament Committee meeting on Fisheries on 1st February this year.
The members of the newly set up Standing Committee are all giving their utmost in this learning curve, keeping in mind the national interest. One must point out that Maltese parliamentarians are not full-time politicians and the members of this Committee are few in number, compared to the number of their counterparts in other Parliaments, yet the volume of EU-related work is quite demanding and always increasing. In this regard, co-operation by all the parties, from our permanent representative in Brussels, the Ministries themselves and last but not least the Committee members themselves, is vital for us to safeguard our country’s interests.
From being active in legislating, national parliaments have been left with the tasks of instructing and holding the government accountable. National parliaments could be considered as the last line of defence for the common man in the street. The same could be said for the Maltese Parliament and specifically the Standing Committee on Foreign and European Affairs.
Malta being so small, both in population size and land mass could be an advantage for our parliament. The Committee has a duty to monitor how our citizens, the business community and other sectors could be affected by the new EU legislation. The domestic budgetary politics is increasingly being affected by the EU, partly by the general economic guidelines and partly by the obligations stemming from EU policies. While the tasks of the national parliaments have been reduced, their responsibilities have increased.
Our MPs are criticised by Joe citizen as being detached from the changes brought about by EU legislation. The Committee could bridge the gap by bringing to the fore such concerns. It does so when analysing thoroughly the Minister’s Explanatory Memorandum within the relevant working groups. The Committee members have the right to consult any interest group, NGO or any other institution that might be affected by the EU pipeline acquis.
However, I would like to point out the important role and respect that the Committee has gained since EU membership. In this regard, I cannot emphasise enough the spirit of cooperation and determination of all the Committee members. The newly found and established feeling of consensus and collaboration within the Committee, bodes well. In this regard, I must point out that we are doing politics with a capital P.
The year 2004 has been a very hectic and eventful year for the Standing Committee as well as the Scrutiny Committee attached to it. This is evidenced by the number of times the Scrutiny Committee and Working Groups were convened and the progress that is being achieved. Moreover, it is pertinent to note that since the Standing Committee on Foreign and European Affairs Committee (previously Standing Committee on Foreign Affairs) was set up more than ten years ago, the Committee held an average of eight meetings a year. This has now risen to 40 during the last year, the highest since its inception. This year, the Committee intends to increase this record with the intended aim of positively influencing the social and political milieu of our nation.
I reiterate once again the importance of “national parliamentary diplomacy”. The Committee’s recent visit to Libya in November 2004 and last month’s visit to China was an example of this. The visit was well received by the Libyan Government during which an agreement was reached to establish a permanent Parliamentary relationship between the two sides. Other important issues that were discussed during the visit to Libya were illegal immigration and the issuing of visas between the two countries.
During the visit to China, the Maltese parliamentary delegation and the Chinese National People’s Congress explored ways on enhancing the existing parliamentary cooperation. We also had fruitful discussions in enhancing cultural exchanges between the two countries as well as encouraging Chinese tourism towards Malta, especially in areas such as the teaching of English to Chinese students. The Maltese delegation also visited Lenovo, the biggest computer company in China and one of the largest in the world. During this visit, I encouraged Lenovo to use Malta as a hub to be able to penetrate the North African market considering that our country already enjoys strategic relations with Microsoft, Oracle and Hewlett Packard.
Conclusion
When setting up a system for EU scrutiny it is important to give particular attention to the political and constitutional arrangements of the country as an effective system is designed around the needs and circumstances of the country.
Democracy at European level can only be strengthened by allowing the national parliaments a greater role. It is only in this way in reality that we can achieve the Common objective – to bring the Union closer to the people so that they can understand, identify with, and actively take part in the European integration process. With vim and vigour, humility and determination, I am proud to say that the Committee is developing into a crucial tool enabling us to influence the political future of our nation.
Other Press Releases:
PR261947
STQARRIJA MILL-UFFIĊĊJU TAD-DEPUTAT PRIM MINISTRU U MINISTERU GĦAS-SAĦĦA Ċ...
PR261946