SPEECH BY THE HON. TONIO FENECH, PARLIAMENTARY SECRETARY IN THE MINISTRY OF FINANCE, AT THE MALTA/UK VAT FRAUD CONFERENCE – ST JULIANS - 6 APRIL 2005
Your Excellency,
Ladies and Gentlemen,
It is my pleasure to welcome you to this conference on Missing Trader Fraud and would also like to thank the organisers and co-hosts of the conference, Her Majesty’s Customs and Excise, for choosing our beautiful island as a venue and for inviting me to join you this afternoon. This is the second time in ten months that the Maltese VAT Department is hosting a forum on the subject after the organisation of the Fiscalis Seminar in June last year, reflecting both our commitment and determination to make more effective the combined efforts that are required to combat this crime.
As the one of the major sources of revenue for Governments, ranging from an average of 35% to 50% of tax revenues of respective member states, it is of significant importance for us all to ensure effective compliance and that we have the adequate tools at hand to combat fraud in this area. In Malta , indirect tax revenue, which includes Value Added Tax and Customs and Excise Duties, constitutes around 45% of total tax receipts. During 2004 the VAT Department collected a net intake of VAT amounting to over EUR 350 million, which for an economy for the size of Malta is quite significant. Furthermore, the harmonisation of our VAT legislation with the 6th EU Council Directive has now given VAT a significant role in today’s trading activities between our country and the other member states.
Undeniably VAT has proved to be a tax systems that has had the least negative impact on spurring business growth as it seeks to tax consumption rather than the production of income. It has assisted Governments in their efforts to reduce the burden of taxation in favour of productive activities and thus encourage economic growth. Undermining VAT means pushing Governments to opting for easier means of collecting revenue, which however may not bring the desired economic results. Thus our efforts to combat fraud need also to be seen in this light. Effective VAT compliance and enforcement can bring about tax rates reductions particularly in income taxes which when at too high levels tend to discourage investment and growth.
Together with the other EU Member States, Malta is now facing new challenges. The fight against VAT fraud is no longer a local issue; it is now an EU wide issue especially in the fight against Intra-Community VAT Fraud.
The phenomenon of Carousel Fraud has been increasing for the past 10 years following the introduction of the so called Transitional Regime of VAT in the internal market of the European Union, as a uniform means of collecting consumption tax among the EU Member States.
Consequently this tax evasion has had a negative affect on the economies of the various Member States. For this reason, we augur that participation in this conference takes place with the spirit of cooperation and coordination on an EU wide basis with the scope of meeting a common strategic objective to the common good.
Obviously, no one is pleased to pay taxes. And it is not surprising to hear how imaginative minds try to conceive original ways of going around the system. Or worse, using a taxation system for the scope of criminal activity.
We are aware that tax fraud in VAT does not only create a distortion in competition and the economy in general but also deprives the state from the necessary revenue to sustain a welfare system for its citizens. Our Government is committed to fight tax evasion as this would create social injustice. Therefore together with other countries, Malta supports initiatives taken to curb irregularities or reduce abuses in tax evasion or fraud.
It is clear that this is a Community wide issue that requires greater effort to come across and investigate and stop such an illicit activity. One needs to make use of all available resources and other tools such as shared data and other important information. In this regard mutual co-operation is essential.
We are encouraged to note that a number of member states are taking initiatives to organise fora of such particular importance. These would serve as a stepping-stone in enhancing co-operation between our countries. Experiences are shared, and contacts are made between tax officials who all have a common aim. They would also serve to define a common strategy to fight abusers.
As always, this is not enough. Results can only be achieved with the serious and coordinated implementation of practical measures. I understand that a number of such measures have already been discussed, such as for strategy identification and implementation using success experience in member states, laws that are more focussed on administrative cooperation across member states, structure building to cope with the phenomena especially specialised people and international units against tax evasion and fraud, best practice dissemination feeding back to strategy, international information systems and databases that are more amenable to fraud control, and more. However, the fight against this type of fraud and tax evasion is an ongoing process and requires a commitment beyond that of just a few member states.
You will find that Malta is not only keen to participate but to also give our contribution and commitment as a member state. We want to be part of the drive against tax fraud and evasion, and to be seen to be part of this drive.
This is in line with our drive to increase our share of the international financial market and to attract more foreign direct investment to our shores. Our experience is that when a country establishes fiscal and business rules, and then abides by them and enforces them, a sense of seriousness, stability and certainty is introduced. This is more than just a perception. It attracts the better and more serious institutions to invest in the country, institutions that would rather be associated with respected countries where an investment is appreciated and better protected. Fiscal morality is, therefore, a principle of good governance that must be pursued across the board rather than in a selective manner.
We were always conscious that our entry to the EU would enhance credibility, especially with the timely introduction of tax and other economic related directives and systems. We have implemented the VIES system, we have set up our Central Liaison Office and our Anti-Fraud Units whilst implementing VAT as a tax regime well ahead of membership.
However, it would be a shame if now we were to allow the new challenges facing us as a member state to weaken our structures and success rate. With the removal of trade barriers and the unrestricted movement of goods and people across internal EU borders, there is the danger of Carousel Fraud and other forms of evasion becoming rampant. Ultimately, it is our collective responsibility to protect the serious and honest taxpayer from paying the price of dishonesty, and inefficiency. This would be a social injustice that would also do nothing to protect national finances for the greater good and standard of living of our citizens.
I therefore augur that this conference would be a success in achieving its objectives, and to act as the springboard to definitive action through the formation of the specialist network necessary through you, the participants. I believe that all our countries stand to benefit, bar none, in this single market.
I also augur that you find space and time to relax and enjoy Maltese hospitality after your fruitful time in this conference.
Thank you.
Other Press Releases:
PR261947
STQARRIJA MILL-UFFIĊĊJU TAD-DEPUTAT PRIM MINISTRU U MINISTERU GĦAS-SAĦĦA Ċ...
PR261946