THE COST OF FUEL: THE FACTS
The Ministry for Investment, Industry and Information Technology refers to uninformed commentaries that have been made since the budget speech, attempting to cast doubt on the Government’s grounds for the introduction of a fuel surcharge.
The Government is publishing the report by PricewaterhouseCoopers of 15 November 2004 on the effect of fuel input costs on the results of Enemalta’s Electricity Division.
This report provides ample factual information to counter the doubts created by the cynical use of irrelevant numbers by various segments of the media.
In the meantime, the Ministry wishes to refer to two specific allegations, which surfaced over the weekend on this matter.
The first allegation was made by the Deputy Leader of the Opposition, the Hon. Charles Mangion, who tried to throw doubt on the increased price of fuel for Enemalta by quoting NSO total figures for fuel importation which show that total imports of fuel increased by Lm2.2 million between January and September 2004.
Dr. Mangion failed, however, to point out that NSO data refers to both Enemalta fuel and fuel for bunkering. Dr Mangion may wish to personally verify with NSO the fact that whilst importation of bunkering fuel has decreased by Lm6.3 million the cost of imports by Enemalta have increased by Lm8.5 million. It should be pointed out that this cost only reflects 9 months of the year and includes at least 5 months when the price of oil was relatively stable.
The second allegation was published by MaltaToday and seeks to argue that it is not true that the cost of fuel for Enemalta has increased. The Ministry would like to point out that the conclusion that Enemalta will next year need to recover an additional Lm16.1 million was not reached by this Ministry or by Enemalta but by PricewaterhouseCoopers and based on Future Prices as of this month.
The PWC study, which is being published today, was explained at length by PWC representatives at the MCESD. It was later repeated – in a shortened form – at a press conference held by this Ministry on Friday 26 November. MaltaToday was not present at the press conference even though it was invited.
Just in case MaltaToday also doubts the competence of PWC, the Ministry is publishing the average monthly prices PLATTS Mediterranean (the reference price used by Enemalta for its purchases) for 2003 and 2004 of Gas Oil, Light Sulphur Fuel Oil and High Sulphur Fuel Oil.
In order to make the right comparisons, one should note that Gas Oil is mostly used in summer and accounts for some 10% of consumption whilst High Sulphur Fuel Oil was phased out completely – for environmental reasons – in February 2004. The attached tables show clearly that:
· Gas Oil and Low Sulphur Fuel Oil (the only two fuels now used by Enemalta) have registered a higher price each month since March 04 compared to the same month last year, except for two blips for LSFO in July and August;
· November 2004 prices compared to January 2004, show that Gas Oil is now 57% higher than it was in January whilst Light Sulphur Fuel Oil is 15% higher;
· Last year’s average price for High Sulphur Fuel Oil (which was the main fuel utilised) was $139. This year’s average price for Light Sulphur Fuel Oil (to which we have switched to achieve EU Clean Air norms) is $168 – on a monthly basis the variance is some 30% higher – we could, of course, have continued to burn High Sulphur (and the increase would have been less) but is then almost certain that the Government would be criticised on health and environmental considerations;
· In simple words – the price Enemalta pays for fuel is more expensive this year than it was last year or any other year for that matter.
In support of its allegation, MaltaToday publishes data derived from the Rotterdam Quotations-Barges FOB, which is absolutely of no relevance to Malta because:
· Enemalta does not buy at Rotterdam prices but at PLATTS Mediterranean which are the prices available in this region;
· The prices shown by MaltaToday are daily spot prices and not monthly averages which is the system used by a consumer the size of Enemalta;
· The source figures are averge prices on a particular day of all European countries whilst what concerns us is the specific position of Enemalta – averaging out averages is a sure way to get confused results!;
· Simple logic dictates that if crude goes up (be it Brent, Texas, Russian, Iran, Libya, OPEC or whatever the source and there are different prices for each) so will the refined product – MaltaToday seems to want to square a circle by stating that whilst crude has gone up the refined product has remained stable;
· If MaltaToday were right then the UK, Ireland, Italy and all other European countries who all have invariably increased utility pricing are taking their consumers for a ride as well – unless, of course, it is only Malta which is special!
Incidentally, just yesterday the third utilities price hike in the UK this year was announced. It would be interesting to know whether in the opinion of MaltaToday the British are being taken for a ride!
Tables follow
PricewaterhouseCoopers Report pdf pr1843a
DOI – 30.11.2004
14.98 Kbytes Last Modified on 30th November, 2004
HOME | GOV.MT
HELP | LINKS | SITEMAP | SEARCH
Other Press Releases:
PR261947
STQARRIJA MILL-UFFIĊĊJU TAD-DEPUTAT PRIM MINISTRU U MINISTERU GĦAS-SAĦĦA Ċ...
PR261946