ADDRESS BY THE HON. LOUIS GALEA, MINISTER OF EDUCATION, YOUTH AND EMPLOYMENT, AT THE CONFERENCE ON THE IMPLICATIONS OF THE BOLOGNA PROCESS AND THE LISBON STRATEGY FOR HIGHER EDUCATION INSTITUTIONS – ATTARD – FRIDAY, 12TH NOVEMBER 2004
“A Europe of Knowledge is now widely recognised as an irreplaceable factor for social and human growth and as an indispensable component to consolidate and enrich the European citizenship, capable of giving its citizens the necessary competencies to the challenges of the new millennium, together with an awareness of shared values and belonging to a common social and cultural space.”[1]
This extract from the Bologna Declaration of June 1999 encapsulates for me the importance of the Bologna Process. It is not the sole remit of academics or students, of Institutions and Governments. It is not just an education agenda, nor is it an economic agenda. There is a very strong social and cultural dimension to this process. The Bologna Process is a voluntary process belonging to a group of stakeholders with a strong sense of ownership of a valuable commodity – European Higher Education. When we look back to the origins of the Bologna Process – the Sorbonne Declaration of the previous year, the European Higher Education Area (EHEA) is seen as an area where “national identities and common interests can interact and strengthen each other for the benefit of Europe, of its students, and more generally, of its citizens.”[2] Now, bring these ideas forward, and you can see the increased importance of the EHEA. In March 2000, the Lisbon European Council set the EU the ambitious strategic goal to become by 2010 “the most competitive and dynamic knowledge-based economy in the world, capable of sustaining economic growth with more and better jobs and greater social cohesion.”[3] To realise this objective, leaders called for a “challenging programme for the modernisation of …education systems.”[4]
Let us look at the impact of the Bologna Process to the creation of the EHEA. In the midst of the four declarations – Sorbonne, Bologna, Prague and Berlin – and the ten action lines, there are common policies components, which underpin the objectives. These include:
Creation of the European Higher Education Area
The principal objective of the Bologna Process is the creation of the EHEA – it has been stated on each occasion by Ministers with responsibility for Higher Education. This extraordinary political commitment has helped shape and forces the dynamic of the Bologna Process. To have 40 Ministers around a table in Berlin actively setting and agreeing targets emphasises the centrality of the Bologna Process to the wider reform agenda in Europe.
Needs of the Labour Market
The needs of the labour market are reflected in the development of the degrees structure – the so-called two (and now after Berlin, three) cycle degree system. In Bologna, the declaration stated that “the degree awarded after the first cycle shall be relevant to the European labour market as an appropriate level of qualification.”[5] This orientation was further emphasised in Prague, while the Berlin Communiqué took this further step forward to articulate a vision for an overarching framework of qualifications – “first and second cycle degrees should have different orientations and various profiles in order to accommodate a diversity of individual, academic and labour market needs.”[6]
Diverse Student Population
Many of Europe’s Higher Education Institutions are now catering for a diverse student cohort, with the traditional full-time student who remained in the higher education system from the age of 18 to 21 or 23 no longer being the sole model. The principle of Life-Long Learning is now gradually but surely becoming the fundamental objective of education systems through the various declarations. The Berlin Communiqué very explicitly acknowledges this, and calls on all concerned “to enhance the possibilities for life-long learning at higher education level, including the recognition of prior learning. We (Ministers) believe that such action must be an integral part of higher education activity”[7]
There are many different models of funding higher education in the Bologna family – there are systems with no fees, fees or loan systems. Irrespective of the model, Ministers look for the appropriate conditions to be in place so that students can complete their “studies within an appropriate period of time without obstacles related to their social and economic background.”[8]
To a certain extent, this again links into the wider need within Europe to maximise human capital. For example, participation rates in Maltese Higher Education Institutions for students increased greatly and the evidence is that this trend is continuing. Such critically important public policy initiatives, including the promotion of equitable access for all, irrespective of background has caused institutions to review the methods associated with course delivery.
Mobility
Linked to the diverse student population, mobility is seen as vital within the EHEA. It has moved from being a mere statement in the Bologna Declaration to a key initiative in the Berlin Communiqué. It now talks of mobility for students, academic and administrative staff as being the basis of the EHEA, together with “its importance for political, social and economic spheres.”[9] However, mobility is fraught with obstacles – recognition of qualifications, financial instruments etc – and again, we Ministers in Berlin were determined to remove as much obstacles as possible.
Research
Research has now taken an increased role, and it is clear that the mission of higher education institutions are changing to reflect the close link between research and teaching. Again, the Berlin Communiqué emphasises the “importance of research and research training and the promotion of interdisciplinarity in maintaining and improving the quality of higher education and in enhancing the competitiveness of European higher education more generally.”[10]
The importance of research is further emphasised against the backdrop of Europe looking for 700,000 additional researchers in order to meet the 3% target for the European Research Area.
I also think that it is important to look at the meaning of the Bologna Process in the context of the stakeholders. Whilst I am anxious to emphasise that I do not speak on their behalf, I can see the impact of their involvement in the process, and, more importantly, see the reason for their continued involvement. In other words, if partnership is to be the hallmark of the Bologna Process, then it must mean something beyond mere involvement in meetings – it must deliver benefits to each of the stakeholders and offer the real possibility to influence the emergence of the EHEA. This partnership approach, in turn, should provide the model for each Member State in the Bologna Process.
Starting off, from a Minister’s perspective. The Bologna Process provides an impetus for reform of higher education. In that context, this path is charted, while at the same time respecting national boundaries and authority. But there is a strong correlation between pressures for reform at the national as well as at the Bologna levels. This is perhaps felt more strongly in countries other than in Malta, Ireland and UK where our degree structures have traditionally reflected the Bologna model. However, the Bologna Process has been central to the package of legislative reform in France Italy to name but two. However, the reference in the Berlin Communiqué, which recommends the ratification of the Lisbon Recognition Convention, generated the momentum for Malta to complete this task. It also should provide the momentum for the development of a National Template for the Diploma Supplement. The model of partnership evident in the Bologna Process is also reflected in the establishment of the National Steering Committee, which oversees the implementation of the Bologna Process in Ireland.
From the Institutions perspective, I would suggest that they have secured the principle of institutional autonomy within the emerging EHEA. The Bologna Declaration explicitly states:
“European higher education institutions, for their part, have accepted the challenge and taken up a main role in constructing the European area of higher education, also in the wake of the fundamental principles laid down in the Bologna Magna Charta Universitatum of 1988. This is of the highest importance, given that Universities’ independence and autonomy ensure that higher education and research systems continuously adopt to changing needs, society’s demands and advances in scientific knowledge.”[11]
Higher Education Institutions further elaborate on this role, with the Graz Conference, which was hosted by the European University Association (EUA). Many of its priorities can be seen in the Berlin Communiqué. The Graz Declaration talks of avoidance of over regulation, and the need to develop common reference points and course descriptors. It looks for, inter alia, consolidation of the European Credit Transfer System (ECTS) and the qualification framework. These are objectives and challenges, which have been taken up in the Berlin Communiqué. For example, Ministers have sought an elaboration of an European Framework of Qualifications. They have also encouraged further progress with the objective of ECTS becoming not only a transfers mechanism, but “an accumulation system to be consistently as it develops in the emerging European Higher Education system.”[12]
The role of the students was underlined, mainly in the Prague Communiqué, which I supported:
“Ministers affirmed that students should participate in and influence the organisation and content of education at universities and other higher education institutions. Ministers also reaffirmed the need, recalled by students, to take account of the social dimension in the Bologna process.”[13]
This affirmation is but one element of the role of students, as represented by the National Union of Student in Europe (ESIB). Notwithstanding public policies, the influence of students is very evident throughout the Berlin Communiqué. For example Malta stresses the need “for appropriate studying and living conditions.”[14] The influence also extends into areas of governance. Again, the Berlin Communiqué states:
“Students are full partners in higher education governance. Ministers note that national legal measures for ensuring student participation are largely in place throughout the European Higher Education Area. They also call on institutions and student organisations to identify ways of increasing actual student involvement in higher education governance.”[15]
Furthermore, the Communiqué contains commitments in areas such as the Diploma Supplement, instruments of mobility (including portability of national loans and grants) – these are very real actions, which we support as a country and which reflect students concerns.
It is also important to note that each of these stakeholders play a critical role in the proceedings of the Bologna Follow-up Group, and its structures. Their representative organisations host conferences and seminars on issues directly related to the Bologna Process.
I feel that it is also important to mention the role of the EU Commission. Their undoubted influence is also evident, and the complementarity of the Bologna Process with their recent communications on Higher Education is there for all to see. Their most recent document on education and training acknowledges this. More importantly, it confirms the Bologna Process as the principle means to achieve the European Higher Education Area. Specifically, it states:
“ The creation of a coherent, compatible and attractive European Higher Education Area in accordance with the Bologna Declaration of 1999 is the main structural means for meeting the challenges and has increasingly involved the Community in recent years. The goals of the Bologna Process mirror in many ways the objectives of the Union’s own programmes in the field of higher education, including at doctoral level, so a closer association is natural and necessary.”[16]
In illustrating some of the principal objectives of the Bologna Process, it is also important to confirm what it is not. On a number of occasions, members have expressed concern at attempts to impose models in terms of curriculum content and national procedures, and these concerns come more to the fore when developments such as European Framework of Qualifications is discussed.
Essentially, the diversity of our systems is also our strength – it is the foundation for the Europe of Knowledge, built on “intellectual, cultural, social and technical dimensions of our continent.”[17] No one in the Bologna Process is pressing for member States to forego their national identity or academic autonomy as we strive for the EHEA in 2010.
The importance of the Bologna Process cannot be overstated – we have set ourselves ambitious targets, indeed, three priority actions lines for implementation by 2005. Our failure to reach the objective of 2010 will be judged by the learners in time to come. A recent article[18] in the Economist notes that American universities were best placed, with their reserves of talent and money to compete with the new academic powerhouses of India and China. While we can debate the merits of philosophies that underline the different education systems, the fact remains that the Bologna Process remains the main vehicle for Europe and Malta in Europe to challenge this notion.
DOI 12.11.2004
[1] Bologna Declaration, June 1999
[2] Sorbonne Joint Declaration, May 1998
[3] European Council, Lisbon 2000
[4] ibid
[5] Bologna Declaration, June 1999
[6]Berlin Communiqué, September 2003
[7] ibid
[8] ibid
[9] Berlin Communiqué, September 2003
[10] Berlin Communiqué, September 2003
[11] Bologna Declaration, June 1999
[12] Berlin Communiqué, May 2001
[13] Prague Communiqué, May 2001
[14] Berlin Communiqué, September 2003
[15] ibid
[16] The New Generation of Community Education and Training Programmes after 2006 – Com (2004) 156 March 2004
[17] Sorbonne Joint Declaration, May 1998
[18] ”Who pays to Study?” Economist January 2004
34.29 Kbytes Last Modified on 12th November, 2004
HOME | GOV.MT
HELP | LINKS | SITEMAP | SEARCH
Other Press Releases:
PR261947
STQARRIJA MILL-UFFIĊĊJU TAD-DEPUTAT PRIM MINISTRU U MINISTERU GĦAS-SAĦĦA Ċ...
PR261946