Left arrow Go Back

SPEECH BY THE HON. TONIO FENECH, PARLIAMENTARY SECRETARY IN THE MINISTRY OF FINANCE, AT THE “EURO TAX SEMINAR” ORGANISED BY THE MALTA INSTITUTE OF TAXATION – BIRKIRKARA – WEDNESDAY, 3 NOVEMBER 2004

PR1715
Date Icon 03/11/2004

Ladies and Gentlemen,

It gives me great pleasure to address once again a seminar organised by the Malta Institute of Taxation, and I would like to thank the President and the Council for giving me this opportunity of conveying to you some thoughts on the crucial subject of taxation.  The themes to be dealt with today are set at an extremely high professional level, and I am sure that they will be found to be very useful to you tax practitioners in translating into practice the new rights, duties and obligations devolving upon us all following Malta’s adhesion to the European Union.  Aiming for high professional standards is the only way in which our country can move forward.

As had long ago been made clear by Government, membership of the E.U. was not a one off occasion: we were not bachelors the day before, and happily married thereafter.  Carrying this analogy further, membership of the Union , like marriage, must be worked upon diligently to render it a success.  The Malta Institute of Taxation is undoubtedly rendering an important service to the country by its continuing exposition of E.U. standards and requirements.

We are today fast approaching Budget Day for 2005.  Clearly I cannot make any forecasts: in any case details are still being worked upon.  There is no secret, however, about the main lines which the Budget will take.  Clearly the matter of the public deficit must continue to be addressed with vigour and determination.  At the same time, we must nourish the economy which is after all the source of our finances.  Although the ultimate beneficiaries of Government Revenue is the general public that benefits from social security health, education and pensions and all the other initiatives taken by Government, taxes sustaining that revenue are looked upon very negatively.

Our tax systems, rates and base may be the focus of much popular criticism however when compared with other EU member as reported by Eurostat in its report “Structures of the Taxation Systems in the European Union” covering data between 1995 and 2002, when comparing total taxes, direct and indirect and including social security contributions Malta as a percentage of GDP Malta places the 21st.  

In reality we have generous social assistance regime with a low tax burden on the economy as a whole implying that effective revenue collection is required to sustain budgetary commitments. 

Since Government Revenue mainly comes from taxation – by whatever name it is called – tax practitioners have a vital professional and social role to play.  One can indeed state that the Government depends upon you to ascertain that the cash flow which Parliament has legislated for actually materialises.  Of course, the responsibility for so doing lies first and foremost on the Revenue Departments themselves, but there can be no question that departmental efforts must be complemented by the work of the practitioners.

All of us will readily understand that the timely collection of revenue is of paramount importance in safe-guarding the positive outcome of Government’s programme and in this context perhaps it will not be amiss make a couple of observations on the relationship between the Tax Authorities on the one hand and the Tax Practitioner on the other.

Co-operation and mutual assistance between tax officials and the tax practitioners, especially in the area of tax investigations and audits, will lead to an early conclusion of such audits to the benefit of everyone.  When a tax audit case is concluded expeditiously the tax official can go on to the next case, the tax practitioner is free for other assignments whilst the taxpayer is spared the cost and stress of being under investigation for longer than is absolutely necessary.  The longer it takes to conclude a case the higher the additional tax and interest due if it results in a tax assessment.

Hence I feel that in the course of tax audits, Tax Practitioners should not fall into the trap of delaying in meeting the legitimate requests by the tax departments, whether it is for meetings, documentation or clarifications about their clients, on the false perception that such an approach could perhaps help in some way their client.  This approach only leads to higher additional tax and interest to the taxpayer.  Furthermore good communications between the tax practitioner and his or her client is of the utmost importance when it comes to discussing a client’s tax position with the authorities. 

On their part, tax departments should be receptive to the cogent reasoning and argumentation made by tax practitioners on behalf of their clients and should not treat such presentations in a high-handed manner. Submissions and presentations made by tax practitioners should be analysed for fact and sound reasoning and not discarded outright if these do not fit in with the tax official’s particular approach to the tax audit.

I am totally against the notion of either side of the so-called tax fence calling itself ‘us’ and the other side ‘them’.  My cherished view is that this fence should be abolished once and for all, and that the representatives of Government and of the taxpayers should co-operate at a strictly professional level to meet our social obligations without having to increase the fiscal burden further, thus stifling economic growth.

I appreciate that tax legislation has embodied in it certain features which may be draconian in nature.  However, I am sure you appreciate that this is necessary as the temptation to defraud the public purse may otherwise be too easy to fulfil.  What we however need to avoid is excessive draconian measures, or excessive draconian implementation. 

We need to educate the tax payer that the Government is only looking at the collection of its fair share of tax rather then the pound of flesh.  This is a professional exercise which can only be brought to a successful conclusion by professionals who know what is required of them, who have the necessary professional ability and training, and who are guided by the highest professional ethics.  Both Government and the Institute are clearly working towards this end.

In conclusion, may I support the call made by the Court of Appeal some time ago to the effect that operators in the field of taxation, be they Government employees or tax advisers, have to be guided by the highest ethical standards.  Government has strict rules in this respect, and the Institute’s Code of Conduct and Ethics leaves little to be desired.  Let us make a collective effort to implement this principle which must be held to be over-riding in all our activities.

Thank You

DOI  03.11.2004

12.92 Kbytes Last Modified on 03rd November, 2004

HOME | GOV.MT 

HELP | LINKS | SITEMAP | SEARCH

Share this Press Release Icon socials Icon socials Icon socials Icon socials

Other Press Releases:

STQARRIJA MILL-UFFIĊĊJU TAD-DEPUTAT PRIM MINISTRU U MINISTERU GĦAS-SAĦĦA  Ċertifikazzjoni internazzjonali tal-ogħla livell għad-dipartiment tar-radjoterapija fiċ-Ċentru tal-Onkoloġija Sir Anthony Mamo

PR261947

STQARRIJA MILL-UFFIĊĊJU TAD-DEPUTAT PRIM MINISTRU U MINISTERU GĦAS-SAĦĦA Ċ...

STQARRIJA MILL-MINISTERU GĦALL-EDUKAZZJONI U L-ISPORT  Aktar minn 1,800 student jiggradwaw mill-Università ta’ Malta

PR261946

STQARRIJA MILL-MINISTERU GĦALL-EDUKAZZJONI U L-ISPORT Aktar minn 1,800 stu...

More Press Releases Right arrow