SPEECH BY THE HON. TONY ABELA, PARLIAMENTARY SECRETARY IN THE OFFICE OF THE PRIME MINISTER, AT THE CONFERENZA DI STUDIO, ORGANIZED BY THE PROVINCE OF AGRIGENTO - SICILY
“THE SECURITY SITUATION IN THE MEDITERRANEAN ”
Excellencies, Ladies and Gentlemen,
Coming after a summer during which the security situation in the Mediterranean , particularly with relation to immigration, was in the newspapers virtually on a daily basis, today’s meeting is an important opportunity to take stock of the situation and to share ideas on how our two countries are managing this crisis.
Historically, the first thing we Maltese have learnt is that we cannot isolate ourselves from developments taking place in the region. Malta is, whether it likes it or not, at the heart of a region which has, for 1,400 years been split into two distinct cultural and political realities on its Northern and Southern shores. Malta itself as it is today is to some extent the product of this history. In the course of time the Island served as a fortress and bastion - the Punic Wars, the Crusades - and served as a military base during the two World Wars and most of the Cold War years.
With independence in 1964 successive governments endeavoured to change the island’s image from a fortress to a ‘centre for dialogue’ between the two shores of the Mediterranean . In fulfilling this role Malta draws upon its traditional links and knowledge of the region, which is the result of human movements and the settlement of Maltese communities in neighbouring countries to the north and south.
The Island is actively engaged in all the fora that concern developments in the Mediterranean region. It will be recalled that in 1975 Malta , almost single-handedly, insisted on the inclusion of the Mediterranean chapter in the Helsinki Final Act of the CSCE. It was the first time that the Mediterranean as a region started to be included in the international agenda. We were then speaking within the context of the cold war but the same analysis prevails today in terms of stabilization. It is our view that we can bring an equitable balance through dialogue and understanding to ease out suspicion and confrontation. It is for this reason that Malta ’s cooperative foreign policy agenda positions itself in favour of furthering the objectives of several regional and sub regional fora that exist.
The Mediterranean is a mosaic of good things and bad situations. The Mediterranean is a sea – an international waterway – that could serve to unite or divide the littoral states of the region. It is marked by the remnants of early occupation of the North by the South and the more recent colonisation of the south by the north. The region is also the source of the three main monotheistic religions – Christianity, Islam and Judaism – that have given a particular cultural background and distinctive way of life to those peoples and nations who adhere to each. The area is rich in human and material resources that could give to the region a more stable and appropriate living standards to all that live in it.
Unfortunately, divisions prevail in the region denying the countries of the region to collectively face an ever changing world. The speed with which globalisation, the information technology and communications are moving make it incumbent upon the states of the region to take on individual reforms in order to catch up with the new global village effect.
As a result of the impact of enlargement on its immediate neighbours, the European Union is putting into effect a European Neighbourhood Policy intended to create a ‘ring of friends’ made up of nations on the periphery of the Union’s borders. The main interest of this policy is the drawing up jointly with the individual country of an action plan that will enable each nation to progress at the speed that it can muster.
The European Neighbourhood Policy is complementary to the Barcelona process, which remains the dominant multilateral forum of the region. In order to consolidate the Barcelona process and the Neighbourhood Policy, the European Union is drawing up a ‘Strategy of Partnership in the Mediterranean and the Middle East’, the key objectives of which go in the direction of creating a zone of peace and progress, the resolution of the Arab-Israeli conflict, improved political dialogue, respect for Human Rights and the rule of law, cooperation in the fight against terrorism, WMD and non proliferation while supporting reforms in the political, economic and social fields.
These efforts have laid the groundwork for a medium to long-term future in which the Mediterranean may become substantially more stable and secure than it is today. Malta ’s commitment to these initiatives must be seen in this context.
Since 1995, when the Barcelona process began, however, we have been facing challenges of a much more immediate nature and these require measures that are powerful and effective enough to provide a full and adequate response to the problems that we are facing. I am referring, of course, to the issue of illegal migration.
In spite of our size illegal immigration has not by any means spared the Maltese islands and it is a phenomenon which has affected Malta considerably for several years. In fact it can be said that due to its strategic position, Malta has been hit considerably during the last few years. The impact is even greater due to its extremely high population density (1,200 persons per km2). Indeed, just by way of example, on the basis of population statistics, it has been estimated that one arrival in Malta is equivalent to 114 and 149 arrivals in Italy and the United Kingdom respectively. Nevertheless, a great many changes have occurred since the year 2002.
During the year 2002 we received the highest number of illegal immigrants who reached Malta by boat, even though Malta was neither a country of transit nor a country of destination. A total of sixteen hundred and eighty six (1686) illegal immigrants of different nationalities, originating from the North African coasts, ended up in Malta in twenty one incidents (21) after they were on their way to Italy . This amounts to nearly 50% of Malta ’s average annual birth rate!
They were constrained to enter Malta after the boats they were travelling on ran out of fuel, after the people on the boats ran out of food or water or after the boat people found themselves in distress and had no option but seek help and to be escorted to Malta by the Armed Forces maritime patrol/rescue services.
The year 2003 brought with it five hundred and two (502) foreigners in twelve (12) incidents. These arrived here under the same circumstances and for the same reasons other boat people arrived during the year 2002.
This year, until the end of September, we have already experienced the arrival of almost nine hundred (900) boat people in thirty three (33) incidents and a case of an air lift of an illegal immigrant who was taken ill miles away from Malta . Most of these boat people were rescued in international waters and were saved and escorted to Malta after they found themselves in difficulties.
An analysis of the figures above, shows that whilst more incidents are experienced the number of persons on the boats is less than those originally experienced in former years.
However, this is not the full picture. Apart from illegal immigrants who arrive by boat, scores of illegal immigrants are detected during Police operations carried out around the island. This year, apart from approximately 900 boat people, scores of illegal immigrants were found. In most cases these were foreigners who overstayed their leave to land or where found without means to sustain themselves. During the year 2003 over seven hundred illegal immigrants were detected illegally in Malta . The amount was even higher during the year 2002.
A considerable number of the illegal immigrants discovered in Malta and most of those who arrive in Malta by boat opt to apply for refugee status.
The fight against irregular migration is on top of the Maltese agenda, not only because it undermines the security of the state but also because it is the obligation of Malta to find appropriate ways of suppressing such activities and implement concrete measures to bring to an end the continued enrichment of criminal elements involved in such migrant trafficking. In fact we brought the matter up during the informal Defense Ministers’ meeting held at Noordwijk, the Netherlands , in mid-September.
Preventive Police activities include quick exchange of information as well as joint intelligence and investigation activities. However, this is not a police issue only and all interested parties, including particularly the Armed Forces, are giving their share to address this problem. Irregular migration has exploded in recent years, especially within the Mediterranean region (which has been described as becoming the largest mass grave in the world). This, in our opinion is a clear signal of the urgent need for the authorities of all countries, and therefore countries of origin, receiving or transit countries, to enhance co-operation with a view to exploring potential solutions to the problem.
At this stage, one has to underline Malta ’s commitment to participate in multilateral initiatives aimed at combating illegal immigration. Indeed, within the margins of the 4+5 (CIMO) Ministers of the Interior Meeting held in Malta in September 2003, a quadripartite meeting was organised with a view to discuss the possibility of organising joint patrols in the central Mediterranean area aiming at strengthening regional cooperation between Italy, Malta, Libya and Tunisia, and at combating illegal immigration by sea. A follow-up technical meeting was subsequently held in Malta on the 5th March 2004 whereby, amongst other things, it was proposed that the Centre for Operational Co-ordination for this project would be set up in Malta and that a project proposal for utilisation of funds out of the EU Argo project should be submitted to the Commission. Due to reasons beyond our control no further progress has yet been registered on this initiative.
Malta , being a member of the European Union, the Council of Europe, and the International Organisation of Migration, as well as a signatory to the United Nations Convention related to the Status of Refugees, is committed to share its international obligations in addressing this humanitarian problem by pursuing international standards for the reception and assessment of asylum seekers. Thus, any foreigner who is found illegally in Malta and any person who arrives here by boat has the right and is given the opportunity to apply for asylum and to go through the whole process even in the case where removal orders were issued. Police officers dealing with illegal immigrants and boat people are all conversant with the rights of such persons and they clearly explain to them their rights when they are interviewed. When these foreigners show the desire that they want to apply for refugee status, the proper preliminary questionnaires are handed in to these foreigners to be filled in. The forms are then referred to the Office of the Refugee Commissioner from where the process starts. Since being set up on 1st January 2002 , 1,267 cases involving 1,544 people have been processed by this Office.
A number of foreigners entering or found in Malta illegally opt to be repatriated. Most of the time they opt to do so after they are issued with a removal order. In such cases arrangements are immediately made by the Immigration Police to procure passports, where necessary, and tickets for repatriation to their country. Many times this is not a simple procedure since procurement of emergency documents is not easy.
It can be said that the repatriation process is a very expensive process as well. To carry out certain repatriations of foreigners in distant countries, for which we have no direct flights, we have also chartered aircraft. Such repatriations were carried out with success and in each case proper security escorts were deployed in accordance with International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO) regulations and procedures.
Those who apply for refugee status are kept in police or army accommodation centres and they remain in these centres until they are recognized refugees or given humanitarian protection. Once they are given such status they are released and taken to open centres whose responsibility is being passed on to the Ministry for the Family and Social Solidarity. Currently close to over five hundred refugees and persons with humanitarian status are being hosted in the two open centres at Hal Far. One is under the supervision of the Armed Forces of Malta and one is a centre where assistance is extended by the Police. This is a very big number, which takes a lot of Police and Army resources. These services are involved in the welfare of the refugee seekers from the very beginning. The Armed Forces of Malta that carry out patrolling of Malta ’s maritime border, detect or rescue most of the boat people, whilst still in open waters. These persons are then referred to the Police Immigration for identification purposes and for preliminary investigations. At this stage action is taken by the Police to alert the Health Authorities and to arrange for their accommodation, which unfortunately again has become a very difficult task and the problem is getting more and more complex. These persons have to be given all possible facilities and for this purpose officers from the police and the army are detailed to carry out such duties. Problems do not stop here, since regular transport of these persons has to be secured to clinics and the hospital everyday, food has to be procured, clothing to be made available and other needs attended to.
When requests for asylum are rejected by the Office of the Refugee Commissioner, those receiving the rejection are informed that they have the right to appeal from the first decision and if they so desire an appeal could be filed in fifteen days. Most of these who have their request rejected at the first stage generally opt to file appeals. These have the right to legal aid apart from being assisted by a number of lawyers who represent local NGO’s.
In the case where appeals are also rejected arrangements are generally made for those rejected to be repatriated. Again this is no easy task and it often takes months to have documents procured for these persons and very often also with no success. These persons tend to give incorrect identity details, which cannot be confirmed by the authorities in the countries where they claim to be nationals. In view of this problem a number of these foreigners had to be released, hopefully until such time that their identity is sometime confirmed.
Scores of illegal immigrants and foreigners who had their asylum applications refused have been repatriated. To give an example during the year 2001 six hundred and sixty six (666) were repatriated. During the year 2002 nearly twelve hundred (1200) foreigners were repatriated, whilst one thousand forty seven (1047) were repatriated in the year 2003. Three hundred sixty seven had been repatriated until the end of August this year.
In order to control illegal immigration further, state of the art document examination equipment has been introduced at our main points of entry, namely the seaport and the airport. Further sophisticated equipment will be introduced in two further phases and the further training of officers continued. Mention should also be made of a new Immigration Control System (with photo and fingerprint possibilities) which was introduced in May 2004 and for which the relevant officers have received the required training.
As mentioned above, illegal immigration is not just Malta ’s problem but indeed a European (and indeed global) one. Within the EU, particularly within the Justice and Home Affairs fora, a lot of initiatives are being taken to suppress and control this phenomenon. From our end in a European context we are doing our utmost, first of all to embark on immigration control procedures which exist in other EU States. Obviously, particularly in view of its particular circumstances, size and limited resources, Malta cannot be expected to carry such a considerable burden by itself. Malta ’s case is one that deserves priority since, as indicated above, its resources are being pushed to the limit. Malta ’s exceptional circumstances – the smallest EU country facing practically one of the harshest illegal immigration scenarios - have to be continuously emphasised. At the same time, it should also be stated that, even if the management of these asylum seekers were to become sustainable through EU financial assistance, Malta ’s unique physical and economic dimensions cannot sustain long term accommodation of recognised refugees working and settling locally. Thus, it is imperative that assistance and cooperation is offered to Malta by other EU member states and developed countries. Such assistance could take various forms, not least resettlement schemes, especially by countries presently in need of migrant labour.
Our Prime Minister, Dr Lawrence Gonzi has had occasion of meeting the Libyan leader Col. Muammar Gaddafi, as has the Italian Prime Minister Mr Silvio Berlusconi. During these meetings, solutions were sought to put an end to the influx of illegal immigrants. Our Minister of Justice and Home Affairs has had meetings with his Italian counterpart Minister Giuseppe Pisanu to discuss the ‘welcome’ policy of both countries. Malta hopes that Prof. Rocco Buttiglione will be confirmed as Commissioner for Justice and Internal Affairs, because he, like us, feels the pulse of our two countries, Italy and Malta , who have to face this crisis.
Italy is the closest European State to Malta and it can be said that both countries are affected similarly in relation to illegal immigration originating form the Northern coasts of Africa . Unfortunately, there are on and off cases where certain persons in Malta are also involved in the illegal transport of foreigners from Malta to the Sicilian coasts. These are not necessarily Maltese nationals, but are all persons whose only interest is to live on the misery of certain foreigners who are impelled to clandestinely proceed to some European country in search of a better future. Malta is committed to fight with all available means such abuse; indeed amendments to the Criminal Code have been recently made to allow more effective law enforcement to address this human tragedy. These carry with them penalties of long-term imprisonment and heavy fines. Indeed, on account of these legislative amendments, it is to be pointed out that a number of persons have been prosecuted for offences related to illegal immigration in Malta .
Indeed cooperation with our Italian counterparts has always been at the highest level. The cooperation is not only through the exchange of views during meetings and bilateral discussions, but also through investigative operations which in our opinion has already given and will further give us positive results.
Investigations into illegal immigration involving both Italian and Maltese officers have been going on for over two years. As a result of the investigative activities undertaken, a number of local persons (Maltese and foreigners) who were involved in this activity have already been identified. Some have been extradited and already served their sentence. Others will soon be subjected to the same procedures. Action is still being taken to uncover more persons involved and we are sure that results of these investigations will be a deterrent to this problem.
One cannot but mention the very good cooperation which exists between the Maritime Unit of our Armed Forces and the Italian Maritime services. In many cases, boats with migrants are initially spotted by Italian Navy maritime patrol aircraft and Italian fishing trawlers. This information is communicated to the Rescue Coordination Centre (RCC) Malta through the Maritime RCC (MRCC) Rome via tried and tested communications channels. Depending on the circumstances of the case, many times, AFM boats and aircraft are deployed and information gathered by these boats and aircraft is relayed back to MRCC Rome.
In cases when these boats are in distress in Malta 's Search and Rescue Region, the AFM assumes the function of coordination of search and rescue efforts. Once a rescue is carried out survivors are taken to the nearest safe port, be it in Malta or Italy .
When boats are in navigation and do not make landfall in Malta, the necessary information is relayed to MRCC Rome by RCC Malta so that the craft are intercepted by Italian Coast Guard units once the immigrants’ boats attempt to enter Italian waters or try to land in Italy.
By way of conclusion, Malta is committed to continuously strive to strengthen its border controls and to ensure that abuses by criminal networks involved in this type of horrendous crime are effectively detected and consequently adequately punished. As evidenced in the past, Malta ’s immigration authorities are more than willing to continue exchanging information with their international counterparts aimed at fighting illegal immigration. All our efforts have to be directed towards addressing this human tragedy of our times – whilst protecting those in need of help due to persecution on account of their political or religious beliefs, no efforts must be spared to bring to justice the traffickers who are exploiting their difficult situation and who are after all putting their lives to risk.
Translation of speech given in Italian
DOI 22.10.2004
48.16 Kbytes Last Modified on 22nd October, 2004
HOME | GOV.MT
HELP | LINKS | SITEMAP | SEARCH
Other Press Releases:
PR261947
STQARRIJA MILL-UFFIĊĊJU TAD-DEPUTAT PRIM MINISTRU U MINISTERU GĦAS-SAĦĦA Ċ...
PR261946