Address by the Hon. Tonio Borg, Minister for Justice and Home Affairs at the Business Breakfast entitled "Fraud and Forensics", organised by the firm Ernst and Young – St. Julians - 5th November 2003
pr1323
05/11/2003
Ladies and Gentlemen,
| It gives me great pleasure to be here amongst you at | this short event which shall, however, discuss an important subject. Economic Crime is a threat to society in general and the country `s economy in particular. I thank the firm Ernst Young for inviting me to this event. |
| The term fraud as explained in the firm`s guide to Fraud | Risk and Prevention covers several areas ranging from credit card fraud, false accounting to corruption in the private sector, dishonoured cheques and misappropriation. This vice with multifarious effects and consequences, is becoming increasingly common, marking modern trends in criminal behaviour; it almost evokes a certain respect by law officers and law enforcement officials; unlike the crude and vulgar violence of robbery and burglary. Such crime is erroneously considered to a soft kind of misdemeanour; but pernicious and dangerous; it remains. |
| Burgling a residence and issuing cheques which are | bound to bounce, may appear to be so different in purpose and action; but they achieve the same goal - the illegal subtraction of one`s property, always at the expense of the law abiding citizen. This year in the first nine months 117 cases of fraud, forgery, embezzlement and misappropriation were reported to the Police. There were 51 reports relating to bounced cheques, stolen and forged cheques and plastic card fraud made up 51 reported cases. The total number of reports received by the Economic Division amounted to 281 cases; by no means alarming but enough to keep everyone on the alert. |
| But fraud in its general meaning is a crime against | public trust; modern development in technology relating to commerce and banking transactions have given rise to modern misuse and abuse of the new methods of doing business; it endangers the viability of these modern means of doing transactions; unlike the violent usurpation of property, it effects are as serious and devastating because fraudulent actions are a breach of trust an exploitation of the vulnerability of others, a misuse of an essentially good and efficient means for a wrongful end. |
| It was with this in mind that last year Government | introduced radical reforms to our Criminal Code; the main thrust of these amendments which came into effect on 1st May 2002 was twofold; to align our legislation with the provisions of the United Nations Convention Against Transational Organised Crime which Malta ratified in September this year, and to modernize our Criminal Code provisions to meet new challenges and trends in criminality, particularly in the economic crime area. |
| In fact Act III of 2002 granted wide investigative | powers to the Police to freeze assets, if the secrecy banking veil over transactions, suspected of being linked to serious crime , introduced such new crimes as trading in influence, corruption and bribery in the private sector (until then only corruption in the public sector was a crime) the crime of conspiracy was for the first time acknowledged in our criminal law; besides the punishment for crimes against public trust including fraud of whatever type and misappropriation were increased. |
| Representations have been made to government | regarding dishonoured cheques and whether the time has come to introduce a bill in parliament criminalising the mere act of issuing a cheque which is not honoured; and failing to provide funds for its encashment within a specific period of time. The arguments in favour of such course of action is that the delivery of goods against payment by cheque is an act of trust; and that dishonouring cheques, while hitting all kinds of businesses, usually targets the small and medium size establishments with devastating consequences. This proposal is currently being studied and no final decision has been taken; but it is good food for thought and a decision will be taken on the matter. |
| An effective means of discovering and revealing abuse | is through whistle-blowing; that is to say employees and third parties should be encouraged to report their suspicion of fraud or irregular activity without fear of reprisal. The new White Paper on the Public Service and the new draft Public Service Act attached to same recognize the concept of whistle blowing and empower the Merit Protection Commission to take action to defend whistle- blowers and provide protection against victimization. This concept is relatively new though other legislative measures had been introduced to encourage the discovery of fraud and corruption. |
| A vigilant attitude is always needed in matters | relating to crime; whether by the State and the law enforcement agencies on the macro level; or corporate institutions for their own benefit and that of the community on a micro level. |
| In Malta attitudes have changed; economic crime is | being taken more seriously; the Police Force harbours within its structure an Economic Crime Unit which though in its relative infancy is producing results. It is important that members of the judiciary at all levels become even more conscious of the serious nature of crimes of fraud to be punished as severely as other serious crimes. Government in enacting legislation last year has shown the way: all those involved in applying the law need to become aware of the importance of applying appropriate punishments for fraud not only as a deterrent, but also as means of applying justice. |
Other Press Releases:
PR261936
STQARRIJA MILL-UFFIĊĊJU TAD-DEPUTAT PRIM MINISTRU U MINISTERU GĦAS-SAĦĦA I...
PR261935en