Left arrow Go Back

SPEECH BY THE HON. EDWARD FENECH-ADAMI, PRIME MINISTER, AT THE 15TH INTERNATIONAL SYMPOSIUM OF THE DEMOCRATIC CONSTITUTIONAL RALLY - TUNIS, TUNISIA

pr1307
Date Icon 02/11/2003
Earlieron this year, at Thessaloniki a draft European Constitutional Treaty was presented to us, the Heads of State or Government of the twenty-five actual or proximate Members of the Union.  I am sure that no one among us had any doubts about the historic importance of the document.  But I suspect that not all of us would have given the same order of priority to the reasons that justified our common conviction of its importance.
Someof my colleagues who head governments whose main concern is institutional reform would, I suppose, naturally give pride of place to the proposed appointments of a full-time, fairly long-term Chairman of the European Council, and of a European Union Minister for Foreign Affairs.  These appointments will facilitate, or at least so it is hoped, the implementation of the Union’s Common Foreign and Security Policy more effectively than has so far proved possible.
Onmy part, given my Mediterranean background, I would tend to agree with those of my colleagues from the new borderlands of the European Union, in giving particular importance to the article on “The Union and Its Immediate Environment”.  It is a novel provision which, unlike many of the other articles, has not been lifted and refurbished from the previously existing treaties.
Thisnew article commits the Union to developing “a special relationship with neighbouring states”.  This “special relationship” is then specified in four ways.  First its aim is the constitution of “an area of prosperity” in terms of the added value accruing from what has been given a name intended to be capable of technical, legal definition: “good neighbourliness”.  Secondly, its foundation is said to be the values that the Union subscribes to in the Constitutional Treaty and which are presumed to be shared by the neighbours with whom the special relationship is sought.  Thirdly, its characteristic features are said to be three:
closeness,peacefulness and co-operation.  Finally the means to achieve the aim are described as “agreements” which may either consist in the attribution of reciprocal rights and obligations or in the joint undertaking of projects and activities.
Clearly,the article in the draft Constitutional Treaty only provides a niche which has now to be filled by concrete agreements.  However, I would like to stress at the outset that the discussion of the lines that such agreements should move along should never lose sight of the general aim.  That is the constitution of “an area” with determinate marks of identity, which transcends the geographical boundaries of Europe.
Thehistoric importance of what may now be called the “Neighbourhood” or “Immediate Environment” article in the Constitutional Draft lies patently in its being the clearest expression of a choice of identity that the European Union had to make and the surest indication of a definite vision of the world’s future that it had to give.
TheNeighbourhood Article makes it abundantly clear that the European Union should not be envisaged as an aim for its own sake; that is to say, its aim is not defensive, the enclosure of a notional “fortress Europe”.  Rather, the draft Constitutional Treaty recognises the European Union as a stage in a more extensive evolution towards the eventual setting up of a system of world governance.  In this sense, the Neighbourhood Article signals a certain kind of self-understanding – that the European Constitutional Treaty is to be the Constitution of a significant but not dominant part of a network; moreover, a network that is eventually to be linked up with others over the whole world.
Indeed,it is clear that, on its own, Europe has limited possibilities of making a decisive contribution to changing the face of globalisation  from its present unipolarity to a more universally humane profile.  The possibilities would be clearly enlarged if the “space” represented was Euro-Mediterranean, in its fullness.  The possibilities would be indeed of a higher order still if a complete Euro-African network was to come into being.

I use the word “network” advisedly.  The idea of a network has become very familiar, not only in relation to information technology and transport, but also to biological and social systems.  Networks are charged with facilitating communication and distributing common action.  If the Euro-Mediterranean space is to function such that it redresses the regrettable aspects of globalisation, then it must be organised in a novel political way.  The best image for this lies not in the traditional metaphors that have been used for political entities – such as that of an organism or a mechanism.  It is by the image of a network. 

A network is the most efficient way of organising exchanges, be they material, social, ideological or of any other kind.  And it need not be hierarchical, let alone pyramidal, in structure.  Rather, it is a system in which a variety of entities, from nation-states or federal-type institutions like the European Union, to non-governmental organisations, can share power.  This power can be shared not only vertically, but also horizontally, with different weight on different issues. 

Theconcepts of an effective Euro-Med network as a significant entity in global transactions, and even of a Euro-African network, are not completely Utopian.  The Electronic Revolution has brought about their practical possibility in the form of a knowledge-based society.  The correlation of economic development with life-long knowledge acquisition is today generally accepted; and hence, the project of a ‘knowledge-society’ can be adopted over large areas comprising a great diversity of initial conditions – such as obtain on both the continents to the north and the south of the Mediterranean.
TheEuropean Commission has sought to spell out its understanding of the status of “good neighbourliness” and the President of the Commission has elaborated on the Commission’s prospectus.  It is now our task to respond with our point of view.  Very briefly, in Malta, we envisage that the development of a Euro-Mediterranean space which can have a positive and transforming impact on globalisation needs to move on at least three levels: cultural, political and economic.
Thefirst is the cultural level.  Its emblem is at present the so-called Euro-Mediterranean Foundation for dialogue between cultures.  Incidentally, Malta is one of the countries offering to host this foundation; the Ministers of Foreign Affairs are due to settle this issue at a meeting in Naples in December.  It is our belief that the most effective means for the enhancement of cultural exchanges and pan-Mediterranean communication will be electronic.
Meanwhile,Malta is hosting the Euro-Med Youth Platform that seeks to co-ordinate for reciprocal advantage the activities of Youth Organisations in the area.  There are many lessons that can be learnt, I believe, from this experience.  A most interesting observation made by the Youth Platform is that it proved easier and more fruitful to organise itself with the involvement of non-Mediterranean country organisations than without.
Onthe other hand, it is painfully obvious that the greatest weakness in the Euro-Med context has been the bilateral nature of most European dealings with the Mediterranean countries.  Europe presents a single front; the Mediterranean countries line up as very scantily related individuals.  It is clear that there has to be a strong enhancement of intra-Mediterranean exchanges if a holistic development is to be envisaged.
Hardlyany one doubts that in the present world context cultural exchanges deserve top priority.  As Paul Valéry once invited us, we should conceive the Mediterranean as “a machine with which to produce civilisation”.  In our age of maximum human mobility, cultural production happens also to be quite lucrative.
Forvarious reasons over the last years, there has been a lot of incitement to both European and Mediterranean countries to build up military power.  Whatever the response to the charge that Europe is unable to have a determining impact on the dire problems of the Mediterranean because of military weakness, it will remain the case that the Euro-Mediterranean will only play its proper part in the world through its use of the two other main dimensions of power – economic and above all, cultural.
Thisstate of affairs need not destroy the ambition to make the Euro-Med area a model for a future system of world governance.  The creation of a political unit that draws its vigour from cultural diversity would be a demonstration of considerable strength; a strength that is of course of a different nature from military might, but for that very reason a better model of the viable, equitable forum of world governance that we would so like to see evolve in the fullness of time.
Sucha model can only be polycentric.  For the Euro-Mediterranean world to become a competent actor on the world’s stage it must include the integration on equal footing of its Muslim component, whether in the shape of states with a Muslim cultural tradition, or of the large and growing Muslim communities in the European countries.
Thesecond level of operations is the political.  It can be symbolised by the Euro-Med Parliamentary Forum that was set up through a preparatory meeting held in Malta in 1998.  The Naples meeting of Foreign Ministers is also to decide on the transformation of the Forum into a Euro-Med Assembly.
Productiveexchanges between the law-makers of the Mediterranean have also taken the shape of conferences of speakers or Presidents of Parliamentary Chambers of the region, the fourth session of which will meet in Malta next February.  Another form of communication at this level is the meeting of Euro-Med Women Parliamentarians, the second session of which was hosted in Malta in 2001.
Thesemeetings do not achieve any legislative purpose and might indeed be said to be nothing but talking shops.  However, precisely because of their meeting in a particular locality, as opposed to the virtual communication envisaged as dominant at the cultural level, the Parliamentarians remind us of the importance of territorial as well as economic and social realities.  While the Euro-Mediterranean space that is in the process of construction will necessarily be intensely transactional, the localised encounters at the Parliamentary level highlight the perspective of the Mediterranean as a Common Heritage.  Their real value appears when they are seen as one level of a multi-level systematic approach.
MyGovernment is, of course, eager to continue to fulfil the role that Malta has played in the Euro-Med process since 1995.  This role has been not merely to avoid the polarisation of positions, but also to propose a number of mediating initiatives.  For instance, in 1997, when the elections in Israel had produced an aggravation of the political situation in the region, Malta provided the only possible venue for the holding of the second Ministerial meeting with the participation of all twenty-seven partners.  In the same spirit, Malta has continued to promote confidence-building measures, such as the twice-yearly seminars for mid-career officials - of which the fifteenth session is underway in Malta at the present moment - and the postgraduate courses at the University of Malta on Human Rights and Democratisation.
Thesehigh-level encounters are providing a constructive and conceptual basis for the surmounting of differences between western and other approaches, while always retaining full respect for both the universality of human nature and for cultural diversity.
Thethird level is that of the partnerships primarily commercial and economic envisaged in terms of formal agreements between the European Union and the non-European Mediterranean.  In this context, at the moment the prime focus of attention is the Euro-Med facility for Investment Promotion.  The increase of foreign investment in the Mediterranean is probably the most urgent requirement for the creation of a truly Euro-Mediterranean space with due weight in the global situation.  But it is not the only economic stimulant that is needed.
TheNeighbourhood or Immediate Environment Article was proposed for introduction into the Constitution by my Government’s nominee at the European Convention essentially for reasons of rational and integral economic development of Euro-Mediterranean space.  In the course of the debate on the external action of the Union, Malta maintained that such action in the non-European Mediterranean world must be deployed in an altogether singular way and through specifically designed instruments, if it is to yield maximum economic and other results.
Thereason is the fact that, between the European and the non-European parts of the Mediterranean there lies the Sea: an interface and factor of communality, rather than a frontier and barrier between north and south; a rich repository of resources, both natural and cultural, that can best be managed in a holistic manner, that is through cooperative endeavour between the European and non-European sides of the same sea.
Anagency that could, for instance, eventually bring about the co-operative and holistic management of those resources that are best managed collectively, such as those of the sea beyond the limits of national jurisdiction, would be creating a highly effective network in favour of peace and development in the area.
Thereis actually a juridical vacuum here since most of the Mediterranean is deemed at law to be high seas.  It is practically impossible to establish two hundred mile Exclusive Economic Zones in the area or for it to be completely sliced up as the North Sea has been.  The bilateral joint fishing zones and the conservation areas that have been set up by some countries are equally clearly inadequate to the need.  The establishment of a Mediterranean common sea heritage management system may be the only rational prospect open to European Union initiative with the co-operation of non-European Mediterranean partners.
Itmay be the only way to ensure that the totality of human as well as mineral and biological resources of the entire Euro-Mediterranean sphere is brought to work harmoniously together, without anyone seeking to destroy the distinctiveness of the other.
Ladiesand Gentlemen,
I have indicated the three levels on whichthe process of Euro-Mediterranean re-integration needs to occur.  Firstly, communication needs to be re-established with the intensiveness which modern technology makes possible without, however, any accompanying loss of humanity.  Secondly, the law-makers must learn to collaborate in devising the means by which the desires of their subjects can be fulfilled.  Finally, at the third level it needs to be realised that, in a knowledge society, true and effective partnership can only be established if there is a communion of values, the only basis on which mutual trust can be built.  There will only be steadfastness in human communication if there is faith in its having a transcendent foundation.
Share this Press Release Icon socials Icon socials Icon socials Icon socials

Other Press Releases:

STQARRIJA MILL-UFFIĊĊJU TAD-DEPUTAT PRIM MINISTRU U MINISTERU GĦAS-SAĦĦA  Inawgurat bust ta’ Ġorġ tal-Mużew fl-Isptar Mater Dei b’tifkira tal-ħidma tiegħu fost dawk vulnerabbli

PR261936

STQARRIJA MILL-UFFIĊĊJU TAD-DEPUTAT PRIM MINISTRU U MINISTERU GĦAS-SAĦĦA I...

PRESS RELEASE BY THE MINISTRY FOR ENERGY, THE ENVIRONMENT AND THE REGENERATION OF THE GRAND HARBOUR  ERA launches anniversary publication: A decade of protecting Malta’s natural future

PR261935en

PRESS RELEASE BY THE MINISTRY FOR ENERGY, THE ENVIRONMENT AND THE REGENERAT...

More Press Releases Right arrow