Address by the HON. DR. JOE BORG, MINISTER OF FOREIGN AFFAIRS, at the 6th MEETING AT MINISTERIAL LEVEL ACCESSION CONFERENCE WITH MALTA – Luxembourg - 10 June 2002
This meeting comes at a time when the sense of anticipation at the successful completion of our efforts is keenly balanced with a clear awareness of the work which still needs to be accomplished to reach our goal.
At this point the political underpinnings of the Union's enlargement need to be firmly restated in the effort to ensure that the final phase of the accession process remains within the scope and time frame intended for it.
Enlargement to the remaining Central, Eastern and Southern parts of Europe is a necessity not an option for a viable and effective European Union. It is an exercise of completion rather than one of extension. The technical work which needs to be undertaken in this regard is an important means to a higher end, and not an end in itself.
It is in this spirit that Malta is approaching the work which needs to be finalised over the next few months. We see two dimensions to this work.
On the one hand the member states of the Union will be finalising their own common positions on some of the major issues which still need to be negotiated. These relate in particular to Agriculture and to post enlargement financing. The road map defined in Nice eighteen months ago, and which has served its purpose very well, rightly reserved these matters to the final phase of the negotiations.
On post enlargement financing the common position which has already emerged leaves open until a later stage the more specific aspects of the question. On Agriculture, Member states will hopefully be submitting their common position on the main aspects of this chapter before the end of the current presidency.
The issues involved are very complex and particularly sensitive ones and their resolution will require flexibility and resourcefulness from both member states and candidate countries. It is important that the basic understandings which have guided the negotiations so far will continue to apply also in these areas.
I am thinking in particular of three related aspects of these understandings. One is the notion that on accession the new members will share and participate in both the rights and responsibilities of membership on the basis of full equality with the older members. The second is the recognition that a period of adjustment may be necessary in identified cases, relating both to the new member states and even to current members, and that provisions for such adjustments are possible as long as they do not seriously interfere with the basic workings of the Union. Thirdly there has also been a general understanding throughout the negotiations that the constant internal evolution of the Union, while immediately relevant to the accession process, will not be allowed to intrude in the negotiations proper in a way which either obstructs or retards them.
The manner in which these understandings will continue to apply, in areas where the interests and sensitivities of current member states are especially real and visible, in itself constitutes a critical measure of the political commitment towards enlargement.
From Malta's point of view our concerns under the Agriculture chapter are related primarily to our objective to maintain and enhance the viability of our extremely small but vital agricultural sector. One of the more sensitive issues for us in this regard is the manner in which the long standing measures of protection for our agriculture could be progressively and safely replaced by measures of encouragement and support which are more in line with the methods and procedures of the Common Agricultural policy.
The questions which arise in relation to Maltese agriculture are in reality largely marginal to the broad issues covered by the Common Agricultural Policy. We are hopeful that the basic objectives we are seeking can be well appreciated by the Member states, and that appropriate solutions will be identified in due course.
Malta's concerns on the issue of post enlargement financing are also of a nature which does not directly relate to the major issues which need to be resolved in this area. Our basic objective is to ensure that any anomalies which arise at the extreme end of the broad formulas which are being contemplated will be rectified to leave room for a fair and equitable net beneficiary status for Malta.
The other dimension of the work which needs to be finalised over the coming months concerns the efforts by the candidate countries to fulfil the commitments already undertaken in the negotiations and to resolve the remaining issues.
As far as Malta is concerned the fulfilment of our commitments in the adoption and application of the acquis is proceeding very satisfactorily. I expect that the reports which the Commission will be submitting first to the Seville Council and subsequently to the October Council will amply confirm this.
With regards to individual chapters under negotiations, I will first deal with the five chapters which are on the agenda today.
Agreement on two of these chapters, those concerning Free Movement of Capital and Justice and Home Affairs, was reached at deputies level some months ago. We are today confirming the provisional closure of these two chapters.
Under the Capital Movement chapter Malta has negotiated a permanent but non-discriminatory measure of constraint on the purchase of secondary residences. In the case of a small territory such as Malta issues relating to the acquisition of real estate assume more than their normal sensitivity and importance. The measure of constraint we have negotiated in this regard constitutes an indispensable complement to the other measures for the management and preservation of our territory which are possible within the framework of the acquis. We appreciate the effort which has been made by member states to recognise and respond to this reality.
The chapter on Justice and Home Affairs covers issues dealing with security and the rule of law at both internal and international levels. During the negotiations on this chapter we have made it abundantly clear that we share the Union's objectives in this regard and that we are fully committed to join in the measures of cooperation on the whole range of issues touching upon border control, migration, asylum, money laundering, organised crime, the implementation of the Schengen system and the continuing enhancement of the efficiency of our judiciary and our police organisation.
In the process of concluding the negotiations on this chapter a number of significant legislative and administrative measures have been taken by Malta. These include the adoption of new asylum legislation and a new Data Protection Act; amendments to our long standing Criminal Code and to our existing Prevention of Money Laundering Act, together with the setting up of the necessary administrative infrastructure to support this legislation including the Financial Intelligence Unit.
I should note that the EU has made the provisional closure of this chapter subject to Malta’s commitment to fully transpose the acquis related to the Convention on the Protection of the European Community’s Financial Interests. I confirm Malta’s intention to take the necessary action in this regard.
A third chapter on today's agenda, which is now ready for closure, concerns the one on Institutions. In its Common Position the Union is proposing that the Maltese language becomes an official language of the Union, and that Malta takes part in the institutional structure of the Union on the basis of three votes in the Council, 5 members each in the European Parliament, the Committee of the Regions and the Economic and Social Committee, one judge on the Court of Justice, one Maltese national on the European commission and appropriate representation in other institutions. I wish here to express our particular satisfaction regarding the proposal for Maltese to become an official language of the Union.
The Union makes clear that as the proposals on Malta's participation in the institutions are based on the conclusions of the Intergovernmental Conference in Nice its Common Position is subject to the ratification of the Treaty of Nice. The Union also states that insofar as the first round of enlargement will involve less than twelve countries, the EU position will have to be reviewed as regards the weighting of votes in the Council and the representation in the EP at the very end of the negotiations, in order to provide for appropriate temporary measures.
Malta is ready to agree to the provisional closure of this chapter on the basis of the proposals in the EU Common position, including the contingency regarding the ratification of the Nice Treaty and the provision for a definition of temporary measures at the very end of the negotiations.
We have expressed dissatisfaction with the institutional proposals contained in the Nice Treaty with regard both to our allocated votes in Council and our representation in Parliament. In our view these proposals do not respond to objective criteria as they should apply in such cases. It is our expectation that these matters will be addressed when the Conference takes up the question of temporary measures as contemplated in the EU Common Position. We have presented a document to the conference outlining our views in this regard. At a later stage we would be prepared to discuss concrete proposals.
A Fourth chapter on our Agenda today concerns the question of Taxation Policy. Under this chapter we are requesting exemptions from imposing Vat on a number of items under the same conditions that such exemptions are currently allowed in some member states. The EU Common Position accepts our requests regarding Water, International, National and inter-island Passenger Transport and the supply of new buildings and building land. With regard to our requests on Food, Pharmaceuticals, Printed Matter and Medical Equipment we are invited to reduce the number of the product categories as well as to define the precise duration of the requested transitional periods. The EU also invites Malta to confirm that the scope of its requests for the individual product categories does not go beyond that of current Member States who apply VAT zero-rating on such supplies.
With regards to the last point the lists annexed to our latest conference document do in fact confirm that the scope of our requests for individual product categories does not go beyond that of current member states. We will study the other two requests very carefully, also in the light of the encouraging progress which is registered in the Union's Common Position on this chapter. Agreement on the number of product categories should be achievable without too much difficulty. With regard to the precise duration of the transition period our request is that our exemptions should apply for as long as they are subject to a VAT zero-rate in any of the current Member States.
The EU Common Position makes reference to Malta’s request for a transitional period to maintain the VAT zero-rate on the supply of domestic inter-island sea transport of goods. This request does not figure in the documents we have submitted to the Conference. If it is unintentionally implied in any of the formulations we have used I wish to clarify that we are not in fact making such a request.
I also wish to state that the Maltese delegation has taken note of the points on Import Levies included in the EU Common Position.
The fifth chapter on the agenda today concerns Budgetary and Financial matters. I have already referred briefly to this. We expect to have the opportunity to discuss in detail the issues arising under this chapter at a later stage.
Following today's meeting Malta will have provisionally closed 22 chapters. I would like to make a few remarks on some of those outstanding chapters which are not on today's agenda, but on which significant work have been accomplished over the last few months.
This is the case in particular with regards to the Chapter on Fisheries policy. Following extensive discussions with the Commission a compromise proposal on the conservation zone around Malta is included in the draft common position which has now been sent to the Council. I wish to request the Spanish presidency to try to deal with this draft Common position as expeditiously as possible. In the light of the useful progress which has been achieved on this important subject, as indeed supported and encouraged by the Presidency itself, I feel that it would be very appropriate for this chapter to be finalised, hopefully even provisionally closed at Deputies level, under the Spanish Presidency.
I also wish to inform the conference that work on the Customs, Environment and Regional Policy chapters has also reached an advanced stage. We hope that the Conference will be in a position to consider these three chapters, possibly for provisional closure, very early under the Danish presidency. Work on the Agriculture and Competition chapters is also proceeding actively.
Looking at the negotiating situation in its overall context we are therefore confident that Malta is on track to successfully complete its negotiations in time for the relevant decisions on accession which will be taken in Autumn this year. Our full commitment to achieve this objective remains clear and unequivocal.
I wish to take this opportunity to express my own appreciation and that of all my colleagues for the encouragement and support we continue to receive from all those concerned in the negotiations - the Presidency, member states and officials from the Council secretariat and the Commission
Other Press Releases:
PR261926
STQARRIJA MILL-UFFIĊĊJU TAL-PRIM MINISTRU “Sodisfatt bil-qbil bejn il-mexx...
PR261925EN