Left arrow Go Back

CONCLUDING SPEECH BY THE HON. GEORGE PULLICINO, PARLIAMENTARY SECRETARY IN THE MINISTRY FOR HOME AFFAIRS AND THE ENVIRONMENT, AT THE MALTA STUDENT SCIENCE FORUM

PR447
Date Icon 05/04/2002

As an initial thought I must say that I was surprised at the question put to me; because we rarely get more than a few weeks to sort out a problem, let alone an entire century! One other preliminary point: I’m 37 years of age and I wonder how much time I will spend on this earth in this century!

Environmental management deals with a number of aspects but at its core lies humankind’s interaction and intervention on the life support systems. An effective management of the environment, including the impacts of human activities on it, presupposes an adequate understanding of how the earth-air-water-life system "works".

Unfortunately, environmental management tends to suffer from the same symptoms that occurred to "sustainable development" since the term’s popularisation in the late eighties. It can very easily become a meaningless buzzword.

Environmental managers negotiate for the most "environmentally friendly" package of measures possible in relation to scientific knowledge and the social and economic conditions of the real world of today. Environmental idealists have a different role – they may help to change what is socially acceptable in the future.

Environmental management has not only to do with environmental protection; it has more to do with sustainable resource use and this is something that needs to be understood if we really want to manage (as opposed to mummify) the environment.

A managerial view of the environment is founded on 3 assumptions:

  1. there is a sustainable level of renewable resource use from activities such as agriculture and fishing and that technology can be found to extend the supply of non-renewable resources, involving more efficient extraction and/or use of the resources and by substitutions of traditional materials with new ones;
  2. a suitable combination of policy measures can "correct" environmental damage and conserve resources (this is where EIAs and Environmental Audits come in);
  3. environmental objectives can be agreed and conflicting interests reconciled (this is where the role of NGOs, Local Councils and the general public is particularly important).

Environmental science and environmental management as disciplines are important in policy-making and implementation in today’s modern politics. Good environmental management demands abundant information and advice from environmental scientists. Long gone are the days when decisions were based on only the ideas or fancies of one decision maker. Policies are formulated on the basis of detailed information – even scientific surveys – and likewise decisions.

Even those related with policy need to understand what science can offer – as well as its limitations – so that they can commission meaningful research and profitably use its results.

Scientific investigation has a four-stage role to play in dealing with environmental problems – firstly by revealing the problem, secondly by raising awareness of the need for a solution, thirdly by devising and testing remedies (i.e. scientists need to propose solutions not simply highlight a problem or criticise the policy makers), and fourthly by monitoring the effect of policy changes.

Managing the environment scientifically entails all of the above – all of which are shared responsibilities. It is of crucial importance that decisions are based on real scientific data, if possible using tested results - however this should not be done as an excuse to procrastinate and not take decisions. Science should not be used as an excuse to stop decisions in their tracks. It is important to recognise that science is a tool and a means to achieve more sustainable decision-making; it is not the end. We would really be in a sad state had scientific research to be carried out for its own sake – all research should be guided and directed at finding solutions to old problems and highlighting new ones.

In order to illustrate this point, I mention as an example the fact that the Malta Environment and Planning Authority (MEPA) is embarking on a programme through which scientifically-qualified people will be engaged in order to carry out duties which require a scientific background.

Moreover a tender has been issued, and will be awarded by the end of the month, for the monitoring of conditions attached to tuna-penning permits which of course would require people with scientific knowledge to carry out such monitoring. The monitoring of the tuna-penning permits, which were issued with the condition that they be reviewed after a year shows that scientific knowledge can and should be applied to concretely improve the environment.

The responsibility of the decision maker and the role of the scientist do not stop with the decision. Monitoring and auditing is an equally, if not more important aspect that unfortunately is often overlooked. It is only through these measures that we can ascertain whether our decisions were really "environmentally friendly" or "sustainable". It is only through such programmes that we can learn from our mistakes and rectify environmental problems.

Finally, in using science to manage our environment, we must be careful not to assign to science the level of certainty that it does not deserve. Science itself deals with the concept of uncertainty and scientists are often "pressed" to give their "best guess" upon which decisions are taken. It is important that we always call a spade a spade and highlight uncertainties, while putting a limit in them. The same applies to assessments of risk. One must accept that ignorance is endemic to scientific knowledge. This is perfectly acceptable and only becomes a problem when (as is often the case) scientific knowledge is misunderstood and is institutionalised in policy making as if this condition did not pervade all competent scientific knowledge.

Hence, to synthesise, science should be one of the cornerstones for a sustainable management of the environment over the years to come. Scientists must make their work available to highlight problems that require rectification. Policy makers should heed the advice put forward by the scientists and policy formulation should be based on as varied an information as possible. Decisions and policies should also be monitored and audited and new data used to learn from past mistakes. The necessary information needs to be collated into national environmental inventories and made available to as wide an audience as possible. And finally, we (and that includes not simply the government) must take the decision to act. We should use the data that is available to intervene in areas were the environment requires drastic solutions to heal old problems and to stop offending activities. More positive action, in the form of direct on-site management, possibly through public-private (including NGO’s) partnerships is also something that needs to be given further impetus. Only in this way can we, hand on heart, say that we might tomorrow transmit, to our children what our fathers left for us to enjoy in good shape and condition.

Share this Press Release Icon socials Icon socials Icon socials Icon socials

Other Press Releases:

STQARRIJA MILL-UFFIĊĊJU TAL-PRIM MINISTRU  “Sodisfatt bil-qbil bejn il-mexxejja tal-UE għax Malta ilha mill-bidu nett timbotta favur soluzzjoni għall-paċi” – Il-Prim Ministru Robert Abela

PR261926

STQARRIJA MILL-UFFIĊĊJU TAL-PRIM MINISTRU “Sodisfatt bil-qbil bejn il-mexx...

PRESS RELEASE BY THE MINISTRY FOR EUROPEAN FUNDS, SOCIAL DIALOGUE AND CONSUMER PROTECTION  European funding through the Erasmus+ programme to strengthen educators’ professional development

PR261925EN

PRESS RELEASE BY THE MINISTRY FOR EUROPEAN FUNDS, SOCIAL DIALOGUE AND CONSU...

More Press Releases Right arrow