ADDRESS BY THE HON. DR LOUIS GALEA, MINISTER OF EDUCATION, AT THE SEMINAR ON "LITERACY – CHALLENGES AND OPPORTUNITIES", ORGANISED BY THE EDUCATION DIVISION IN CONJUNCTION WITH THE COUNCIL OF EUROPE IN-SERVICE TRAINING PROGRAMME FOR TEACHERS
As the theme of this conference indicates, literacy is today, as it has always been, the gateway to learning, and as such the gateway to the world. Being literate had always meant being empowered to learn, and never has this empowerment been more important than today in this age of lifelong learning and of the knowledge based society.
Computer literacy, which is a sine qua non for both, requires the achievement of basic literacy, the skills of reading and writing, before it can be obtained. More fundamentally still being illiterate, or only poorly literate, in today’s world means being marginalized from crucial sources of information like Internet. And being unskilled in learning means being incapacitated in different ways that are fundamental to the quality of one’s life; as an active citizen in a democracy, as a discriminating consumer in the market of goods and lifestyles, as a worker concerned with one’s permanent employability and economic stability. Culturally, it means living in a world that is as alien and mysterious to one as nature was to the primitive savage.
Besides, no society today can afford to have a significant literacy problem if it wishes to survive and prosper in a global economy and information system with strong dependence on digitalised technology and on a skilled and knowledgeable workforce. In short, no government today can afford not to have aggressive policies to combat illiteracy at all levels of society beginning with its schools where it needs to work towards obtaining the fullest literacy possible.
Of course, the question of literacy in Malta is inextricably tied, as this Seminar has been showing, with that of bilingualism. The Maltese have always been proud of their linguistic proficiency and of their national language. Many are capable of speaking three or four different languages, or more. In recent times, the challenge of achieving universal basic literacy has always been cast as the challenge of achieving bilingual proficiency in Maltese and English, and our new National Curriculum poses it precisely in this way.
In 1994, my predecessor as Minister of Education, Michael Falzon, set up a Consultative Committee on the future of primary and secondary schooling in Malta with the object of identifying priorities for policy planning, and in its 1995 report entitled Tomorrow’s Schools: Developing Effective Learning Cultures, it clearly signalled the connection between low achievement and failure at school and literacy and numeracy problems. It went on to observe that ‘the research on school failure suggests that it is only when programmes are implemented early on in the life of a primary school age child that difficulties with basic competencies, such as literacy and numeracy, can be overcome.’ (p19) This has always remained the government’s thinking.
Very soon after being presented with this report, in March 1996, Minister Falzon requested the Director General of the Education Division to set up a Steering Committee to review the 1989 National Curriculum (the first in our education history) with the object of proposing a new updated, and more relevant, document in its stead. Minister Evarist Bartolo (1996-1998) took the process one step further publishing a first draft of the National Curriculum. My immediate concern, knowing the importance of the document, was to ensure that the debate was kept on course and to complete the exercise. For this purpose, between November 1998 and January 1999, I set up various consultation meetings with special interest groups and with all the stake-holders, one of which dealt specifically with language policy in schools. A new re-drafted National Curriculum was finally approved by Cabinet in September 1999 when it became government policy.
I put such stress on the National Curriculum since, because of its contents, it marks a decisive challenge, a moment of catalyst for our primary and secondary schooling in Malta. For the first time in our education history we had a detailed policy document which was the fruit of years of consultation and careful planning and that enjoyed national consensus. More importantly what was being consented to by teachers, parents, politicians, and officials, was an undertaking to engage in a paradigm shift in our schooling culture which would put the learner and his/her needs squarely at the heart of the Curriculum. Everyone’s entitlement to a basic quality education became a more focussed national strategic objective.
The National Curriculum specifically devoted substantial space to the strengthening of bilingualism in our schools and proposed changes to assessment methods, which would, I quote, provide ‘the school with the opportunity to provide effective remedies to individual students to overcome their linguistic difficulties.’ (Principle 10) In short, the National Curriculum, like its precursor the Tomorrow’s Schools Document, emphasised the importance of the early identification of literacy problems in primary schools and the implementation of early intervention programmes to address them. The history of a series of initiatives in this field to-date is a clear indication of the priority that this challenge has been given in Malta’s national agenda.
Meanwhile, in November 1995, shortly after the publication of Tomorrow’s Schools document, Minister Falzon directed that measures be taken to set up a planning group and urged the Division of Education and the Faculty of Education to come up with concrete proposals. Dr Charles Mifsud, through the Dean of Faculty of Education at the University of Malta, then submitted a formal proposal to Minister Falzon to set up an Early Literacy Unit in collaboration with the Education Division, designed ‘to ensure that no child in our state schools will leave primary school without a high level of functional literacy in both Maltese and English.’
In February 1997, a new Labour Minister of Education replacing Mr. Falzon, set up a Ministerial Committee to co-ordinate an Early Literacy Programme, and this was followed with three initiatives in the same year the Kampanja Nieħu Gost Naqra (a campaign to promote the pleasure of reading), a public forum on the importance of reading for young children, and an in-service course for teachers. Through the rest of 1997 and 1998 a number of short courses, teaching clinics and seminars on reading and literacy difficulties were held with the help also of foreign experts. 1998 was declared a National Literacy Year by the Ministry of Education.
At the end of 1998 in a ‘situation report’ prepared by Dr. Mifsud I was advised to set up a smaller, core group from the University and Ministry\Division to lead the Literacy Unit, which recommendation was soon implemented by my Ministry.
In 1999, a Baseline Assessment exercise for children in Yr 2 in 100 primary schools was set up and administered by the Literacy Unit at the University in collaboration with the Education Division and with the assistance of experts from the British National Foundation for Education Research (NFER). The published results of the Baseline Assessment was then explained to heads of schools and the general public.
With the adoption of the National Curriculum by Government a new phase of implementation was embarked upon. Past experience had shown us that the Curriculum could be a beautiful but dead document unless it was backed by a strategic plan to put it into effect. So in January 2000 I appointed a National Steering Committee to produce such a plan, and to recommend the policies required to implement it. The Committee had broad terms of reference, including the setting up of specialised working groups to address key policy areas of Curriculum planning. One of these expert working groups addressed issues and strategies of language teaching, with a specific focus on bilingualism.
The group defined the line of policy that needed to be pursued and recommended a national policy for bilingual teaching in our schools reflecting the new National Curriculum’s emphasis on inclusion and entitlement, setting out the framework within which illiteracy and other language teaching problems could be tackled where it should be, namely at the school level.
As a first step towards this objective one of the key recommendations of the working group was that schools should identify their language and literacy policies in their annual school development plans which, it was recommended by the Steering Committee, should become mandatory for all schools in Malta. The Steering Committee also indicated the need for a newly constituted National Curriculum Council to identify national benchmarks, including those in literacy attainment, as well as standards and targets that would guide the schools in their planning and assessment, and the Council has, indeed, taken the matter in hand and created a focus group for the purpose.
It was clear from the strategic plan that the process of effecting the changes required to prepare our schools to take school based literacy initiatives seriously, and to create school based strategies of intervention to locate and tackle their own literacy problems would be a long one and would require outside help and support. Meanwhile, it was equally clear that immediate action was required on behalf of those children, about 18% - 20% according to the Baseline Assessment report, presently in our schools who had serious literacy problems and could not afford to wait for this process to complete itself. These required immediate remedial action.
So that, two clear lines of policy were indicated for us to follow. One long term and gradual, indicated by the National Curriculum, involving the changes in the school culture, ethos, and teaching methods, that would create a more personalised and individualised approach to teaching, more effective methods of detecting learning problems at school level and at an early age, a more collegial approach to addressing these problems, and more inclusive school environments generally, on the model of Tomorrow’s Schools. The other more short term and immediate involving direct remedial strategies with the support of outside agencies of which the Early Literacy Unit is one, but of which there are others also.
In 2000 the Education Division sponsored a joint project between the University of Malta and the London Institute of Education, to the tune of Lm 20000, to hold an M.Ed. degree in Literacy which will eventually produce seven graduates in the field. In 2001 the literacy support programme, known as the Communicative English Project for Yr 2 and 4 children, was launched in three primary schools in the Cottonera area. In the coming weeks the National Literacy Survey follow-up project will be carried out on all Year 5 pupils who took the first assessment back in 1999.
These are not, however, our only initiatives in the school. As I have just stated, there are other external services, with both long and short-term objectives, already in place in the schools to support literacy teaching and to attack the problem of illiteracy as effectively as possible. One long-term initiative to help schools change in the light of the demands of the National Curriculum is the Let Me Learn Project, which has been in operation now for a number of years and which is growing slowly but steadily.
A more immediate form of intervention is provided by the Curriculum Department in the Education Division through its Complementary Teaching service, which was set up in 1991 for Year 3 primary school children who fail to acquire phonic word skills by age eight, and which has been strengthened since, though its provision continues to be limited mainly to Yr 2 and Yr 3 pupils. All the state primary school today are covered by this service, which is supplemented by the services given to the schools by the SpLD (Special Learning Difficulties) Unit, also created in 1991 within the same Curriculum Department, and which deals with the learning problems faced by dyslexic pupils, mainly, but not exclusively, in our primary schools.
Finally, the most recent inclusion in this set of external remedial agencies working with the schools, is the after school programmes Ħilti and Id f’Id launched this year by the recently established Foundation for Educational Services. These programmes also direct their attention at the problems of literacy and numercy in the state primary schools, but it tries to adopt a broader, more holistic perspective to the problem by instigating a policy of partnership between itself, the school teachers, and the parents of the children participating in the programme. In the process it has launched the Parent Empowerment for Family Literacy (PEFAL) project to create support for these children through the empowerment of their parents. This project has attracted seven other European partners and which the EU, through its Grundtvig Programme, has funded to the tune of Lm 70,000. These project partners are today starting a three-day workshop here in Malta to finalise a two-year programme.
As one can easily see, our strategy, where literacy policies in the schooling sector are concerned, is a coherent and sensible one. We have understood that we must move away from the ad hoc, piecemeal, disjointed policy making of the past and move towards a service which is based on a clear strategic plan with clear quality indicators. In these past three years the government’s first priority was to create the structures required by this approach. We set up the National Curriculum Council to guide and oversee the implementation process. These are all considerable achievements, landmarks in our education history that have created the planning framework required for up-grading and modernising our primary and secondary school provision in a coherent and forward-looking way. They have also created the instruments for our literacy policies for the future. What we clearly need now is to complete the exercise of setting the clearly defined national literacy targets and benchmarks we require at different levels of the primary and secondary schools. The National Curriculum Council, through its Focus Groups will also need to devise a strategy for working with the individual schools to help them create school-based policies and strategies for reaching these targets, effective diagnostic tools for the earliest identification possible of those who are not succeeding in reaching them, and personalised learning instruments to address their problem. All this must be achieved in partnership with the parents and the community.
As I said earlier, our thinking for the future is clear and our prospects are good. International seminars like the one you have been holding over these past days are important ways we can share and compare our experiences with those of others in Europe, learn by the experience of doing so and, hopefully, contribute to the learning of others.
Other Press Releases:
PR261926
STQARRIJA MILL-UFFIĊĊJU TAL-PRIM MINISTRU “Sodisfatt bil-qbil bejn il-mexx...
PR261925EN