STATEMENT ON NEGOTIATING EU MEMBERSHIP: THE VIEW FROM MALTA DELIVERED BY RICHARD CACHIA CARUANA, CHAIRMAN, CORE NEGOTIATING GROUP AT THE CONFERENCE ON THE STATE OF NEGOTIATIONS - THE DOLMEN HOTEL, QAWRA, 22 FEBRUARY 2002
We are almost two years into Malta’s membership negotiations with the European Union and I am grateful for this opportunity to reflect on the various objectives that have been set for the Maltese negotiating team and the progress that has already been achieved.
In preparing for today’s session, I found it interesting to see what I had said a year ago at the first State of the Negotiations Conference.
At that stage, we had provisionally concluded negotiations on twelve of the twenty-nine substantive chapters. We have now closed twenty chapters, and expect to end discussions on the remaining chapters in the coming ten months.
Twelve months ago we were at the point where we were digesting the implications of the Nice Summit, while we are now preparing to participate - with the EU’s other current and future member states - in the European Convention, which will be holding its inaugural session next week.
A year ago we were preparing to start negotiating the special and transitional arrangements Malta was requesting. In the twenty chapters closed so far we had nineteen requests for special arrangements under discussion. Eleven of these were achieved as requested, two were modified and agreed to, one is being dealt with under another chapter and five were found not to be necessary. All of the positions taken by Malta were adopted by the Malta-EU Steering and Action Committee (MEUSAC) as well as the Maltese Government itself.
Each of the thirteen arrangements achieved is important in its own right, although some of them have an impact that is restricted to a particular sector or sectors. These include the agreements negotiated in the chapters on Free Movement of Goods, Transport and Energy on pharmaceuticals, land transport and oil stocks, respectively.
On the other hand some of the special arrangements have a far wider bearing and should be considered in some more detail.
The Maltese Government subscribes fully to the objectives of the EU’s social policy. Malta has no issues on principle with the Directives that implement these policies. Nevertheless, seven requests for transition periods were made under this chapter following a series of impact studies, conferences and discussions with the social partners, both in and outside the MEUSAC process. Two elements came to the fore during these consultations: first of all, it was necessary for industry to have sufficient time to adapt to the changes required to working time practices; secondly it was necessary to allow Malta’s new Occupational Health and Safety Authority the time required to reach full operational capacity.
As negotiations progressed, it became clear that three of the requests made in the field of labour law, those concerning daily rest, weekly rest and night work, were not required as industry was able to adapt to this part of the acquis. The requests on noise levels at the work place, temporary and mobile construction sites and the use of work equipment were agreed to by the European Union.
The discussions on the European Working Time Directive were, however, more complex. This Directive expects the average employee to work a maximum 48-hour week, including overtime. Extra overtime is possible, but only where the employee concerned agrees. Maltese legislation would thus have to change from an obligatory system of overtime to a voluntary one. This also requires a change in mentality at the workplace.
The initial request was for a four-year transition period to bring this Directive into force. During negotiations it became clear that certain sectors of industry were already well prepared for this shift in employment relations. This meant that the request could be more focused in time and in scope.
The agreement reached, with the support and participation of the social partners, was for a transition period until 31 July 2004 for those manufacturing sub-sectors that needed it: food and beverages; textiles, clothing and footwear; transport equipment (including shipbuilding and ship repair); furniture; electrical machinery, appliances and supplies.
In addition, it was also agreed that where any current collective agreements in these sub-sectors are still in force on 31 July 2004, the transition period will be extended until 31 December 2004.
As, I am sure, you are all aware, one of the more difficult chapters closed during 2001 was that which concerned the free movement of workers. In this context it was necessary for the Maltese negotiating team to address the perceived threat of an influx of labour upon accession. The result was a safeguard clause applicable for the first seven years of EU membership. This will permit Malta to retain its work permit system, although EU citizens will receive such permits automatically. In urgent and exceptional cases, Malta has retained the right to suspend the full application of the acquis. Such suspension can be general or specific to one or more sectors of the labour markets. This means that Malta will itself be able to assess the manner in which the labour market will be adapting to the free movement of workers and will be able to act accordingly.
The Government remains of the opinion that the economic growth brought about by accession will mean that any labour movement into Malta can be sustained. This special arrangement will, however, give the Government the means to address a problem in this area should it prove necessary.
This arrangement is coupled with a joint declaration that will be attached to the Final Act of the Accession Treaty. This underlines Malta’s right to raise its concerns over any future pressures in the labour market within the institutions of the Union, beyond the seven years of the transitional arrangement.
Certain principles which were discussed in the free movement of persons chapter also came to the fore during the negotiations on property rights where EU law provides that all EU citizens have the right to freely buy property in any EU country.
During the negotiations on this chapter we explained how the implications of EU membership, in particular those arising from capital liberalisation as well as from the free movement of labour and the free movement of establishment, could exacerbate an already difficult situation concerning land use in Malta. We stressed that a transition period could not address our particular situation in an adequate manner, since the problems were not transient in nature.
The validity of our case eventually permitted an understanding on the principle underlying our request, though it took some further detailed, and occasionally difficult, negotiations to translate this principle into a specific and permanent arrangement.
We argued that we already have a law regulating the acquisition of property by non-residents. This law provides that any individual who is not Maltese and wishes to buy property in Malta has to apply for a permit. Owing to Malta’s size and related problems, this legislation should remain. In other words there should not be a free for all where the acquisition of property is concerned and there should be restrictions for people who would wish to buy property but not live here.
Malta will therefore maintain non-discriminatory restrictions on the right of EU citizens to acquire and hold secondary residences, unless they have resided legally in Malta for a minimum period of five years. This arrangement will be entrenched in a Protocol to be annexed to the Accession Treaty.
A number of requests for special arrangements must still be dealt with in the chapters on which negotiations are still open. The bulk of these have naturally been made in the agriculture chapter, which is the largest chapter in terms of European legislation.
These remaining chapters can be categorised according to the timeframes within which we hope to conclude negotiations. In the shorter term, the chapters on Justice and Home Affairs, Customs Union, Fisheries and Environment appear to be drawing to a close, with varying degrees of imminence.
Although no special requests have been made in Justice and Home Affairs, the negotiations have proved to be longer than expected. Considering recent international events and the increased sensitivities within the Union regarding security and border control, the attention with which Malta and the EU’s member states have tackled this subject is perhaps understandable. Nevertheless these negotiations are now in the very final stages.
Another open chapter is that dealing with Customs Union. The outstanding issues in this chapter are related to duty relief for capital and industrial goods, which should be discussed in the coming weeks, and agricultural levies, which should be discussed in the agricultural chapter.
The negotiations on Malta’s Fisheries Management Zone have been intense and highly technical. We are now very close to reaching agreement on the need for the waters around Malta to be managed as a conservation zone. A number of related points are, however, still being discussed.
The Environment chapter comprises a large portion of the EU’s laws. As we all know, Malta has much to do in this sector and the Union has recognised that we need an amount of support in the completion of the various implementation programmes. A significant amount of work has been done in this area during the past few months to assess our legislative, infrastructural and administrative capacity in this field.
Initially Malta had made ten requests for special arrangements or transition periods in this chapter. During the course of the negotiations we have had the opportunity to analyse our needs in greater depth and, in the light of this, we have been able to consider the modification or even withdrawal of certain requests.
One example of this is the request for a three-year transition period for the abolition of leaded petrol. During last year’s Budget Speech, the Minister of Finance announced that the Government had decided that, for environmental reasons, leaded petrol should be phased out by 1 January 2003. This request is therefore no longer necessary.
Detailed consultations are still under way on a number of issues, particularly with our counterparts in the European Commission and we are now at the stage where we are addressing the most complex and sensitive environmental issues.
Foremost among these is hunting and trapping. A year ago I quoted our position paper in this regard, saying: "it is considered that within the framework of EU legislation, measures will be taken to maintain on accession the traditional patterns of hunting and trapping which have evolved as a result of Malta’s particular biogeographical circumstances". This remains Malta’s position and I believe that we have the means at our disposal to achieve a balance that will be acceptable to all.
In the medium term there are two other chapters that require some more attention and which should be ready for closure during the latter part of the current Presidency. These are Competition and Taxation.
One of the key issues for Malta in the Competition chapter is the question of state aid especially insofar as it concerns the shipyards. We are asking for a seven-year period to enable Malta to complete the restructuring exercise for the yards that is currently underway.
The EU permits certain types of aid to these industries and we are seeking to demonstrate that the reforms that will be implemented in Malta can, to a significant extent, be encompassed within the EU’s competition rules.
As regards the Taxation chapter, substantial progress has been registered over the last months and the outstanding issues have been narrowed down mainly to Malta’s request to retain the VAT zero-rate on a number of socially sensitive items, including foodstuffs and pharmaceuticals. This request is motivated primarily by the social and economic implications which these new taxation measures could have on the Maltese population’s standard of living, substantiated further by the similar precedents established by number of member states in this field.
This would leave us with the three chapters containing a strong financial element, that is Financial and Budgetary Provisions, Regional Policy and Agriculture.
The chapter on Financial and Budgetary Provisions deals primarily with the mechanisms that must be put in place to cater for Malta’s input to the EU budget.
A crucial aspect of this is the need to ensure that arrangements are in place to phase-in Malta’s contributions to the EU budget in step with the benefits it will start receiving under the Structural, Cohesion and other funds.
The two main areas of distribution of EU funds are its Regional Policy and its Common Agricultural Policy. A lot has been said on this subject in recent weeks, following the publication of the Commission’s proposals on the funds that will be available to new members under these two policies.
The Commission’s proposals are now being examined by both member states and candidate countries, Malta included. There is no doubt that an intensive debate will follow.
If I were to be asked whether I thought that a solution acceptable to all would be found, I would have to answer yes, because that is the way of the EU. If I had to be asked when such an agreement would be reached, I would have to say after many, many months of to-ing and fro-ing, because that is also the way of the EU.
Quite beyond these considerations, there are other issues within the negotiations on these chapters that we are dealing with at present. In the case of Regional Policy, discussions have been concluded on most aspects and we are currently focusing on the special needs of Gozo, where a series of studies have been commissioned, some of them with EU funding.
Apart from representing a large proportion of the acquis, agriculture is the subject of considerable debate within the EU and among the candidate states. Malta is no exception to this. Despite the relatively small contribution of agriculture to Malta’s Gross Domestic Product (approximately 2.3%), this is a sector with important environmental, socio-economic and socio-cultural implications.
It is a well-known fact that Maltese agriculture faces major constraints which restrict its competitiveness. For this reason Malta is making a number of requests in this area.
First of all, we are proposing a Special Market Policy Programme for Maltese Agriculture. This programme is designed to give farmers the required income support while levies are removed. The main thrust of this programme is unequivocal: we know the removal of levies will lead to lower prices for Maltese families but we want to guarantee an acceptable level of income for Maltese farmers.
The Rural Development Programme for Malta, which is being drafted, will provide a general framework to build, over the medium to long term, an agricultural sector that is deeply integrated with the rest of the economy. It will define projects for the restructuring of Maltese agriculture and prepare for its full integration in the Common Agricultural Policy. It will include projects designed to make the weaker sectors of Malta’s agriculture more competitive. It will also address the specific nature of Malta’s agricultural structure as well as the need to build up the required institutional capacity for the implementation of the agricultural acquis. The implementation process of this Programme will require the participation of all stakeholders.
At the same time Malta is requesting the provision of special supply arrangements for essential products and specific support measures for certain activities in the agricultural sector. This will enable Malta to maintain existing trade flows and contain any inflationary pressures which would arise if EU internal prices in the identified areas prevail.
Certain requests are also being made in the phytosanitary sector as well as with respect to the veterinary aspects of the acquis.
I have basically taken you through the key aspects of the negotiations on the substantive chapters. This leaves us with the two residual chapters: Institutional Matters and Other Matters. In the past we have almost ignored these two chapters, since they have not been presented for negotiation with any of the candidate states.
The Spanish Presidency has been charged with the formulation of the Union’s position on these chapters and it is expected that they will start to be dealt with within the next few months.
Institutional Matters will focus on the position adopted by the EU at the Nice summit, while the chapter rather enigmatically referred to as "Others" is expected to contain any remaining issues that do not fall under any of the other chapters.
In concluding, I would like to recognise the role played by both the public service and the non-governmental sector. Several hundred government officials have been involved in the various aspects of the negotiations, be it the drafting of positions, technical consultations and policy deliberations. They have been fully committed to the process and to the work it has brought with it. They are now responsible for implementing Malta’s negotiation commitments.
There is also the vital part played by Malta’s trade unions, constituted bodies, organisations and associations. They have been involved in the finalisation of all Malta’s negotiating positions, through the Malta-EU Steering and Action Committee. They have also been briefed on a regular basis of progress in the negotiations in general, as well as on items of specific interest to them. Moreover they have been consulted on a sectoral level in order to ensure that chapters are closed on a basis which is acceptable to them.
From the outset Malta had set itself the target of concluding negotiations by the end of this year. There is now a clear commitment on the part of the EU to make every effort to attain this goal. The coming months are therefore crucial.
It means, however, that a year from now we should be in a position to evaluate the complete package that the Maltese people will decide upon.
Other Press Releases:
PR261926
STQARRIJA MILL-UFFIĊĊJU TAL-PRIM MINISTRU “Sodisfatt bil-qbil bejn il-mexx...
PR261925EN