SPEECH BY THE HON GEORGE PULLICINO, PARLIAMENTARY SECRETARY IN THE MINISTRY FOR HOME AFFAIRS, AT THE WORKSHOP ORGANISED BY SACES (SOCIETY OF ARCHITECTURE AND CIVIL ENGINEERING STUDENTS) ON ‘RESTORATION AND RENOVATION’ - FORT ST. ANGELO 15TH NOVEMBER 2002
Today, the culture of restoration is facing a double challenge as regards content and communication. The age when so called ‘experts’ in restoration resolved the theoretical aspects of restoration by simply referring to their professional experience is over and we are, or should be, in a regime where the methods studied by a large body of experts from a wide range of expertise and from all over the world can offer at least some of the necessary scientific guarantees. One must not lose sight of the fact that the "Venice Charter" was drawn up as a result of the experience of many years of renewal which was carried out in the period immediately after World War II, during which much modern construction was carried out in a great hurry within many historic cores. This Charter was born from the necessity of a code to regulate, in the most general manner, the practice of restoration by tying it to principles which were acceptable to the majority of experts working in the field of restoration, principles which have subsequently borne the test of time and been verified in occasions too numerous to list: certainly their influence on the art and science of restoration cannot be over emphasised.
During the twenty years following the end of World War II, or by 1960’s, the socio-economic context had changed considerably because the pressure for city expansion in Europe had been reduced considerably. Also, the culture of restoration lost, to some extent, its pivot, since the organisation, which had proposed the Venice Charter, ICOMOS (International Council of Monuments and Sites), did not achieve the international standing, which had been forecast, and therefore the principles it promulgated did not attain the universality, which they deserved. It may be said that it was only the ‘rescue’ of the Temples at Abu Simbel1 by the two sub-organisations of UNESCO: ICOMOS & ICCROM that brought these organisations onto the World’s newspaper front pages.
The introduction of a lot of technical jargon also tended to obfuscate rather than clarify the basic principles. If one were to consider the volumes, which have been written merely to justify the distinction between ‘restoration’ and ‘conservation’, one realises that during this period, the theoreticians on their part did little to help the cause of restoration since much of their energy was spent on mere rhetoric. Indeed, in the resulting confusion, the word ‘restoration’ was much used and possibly abused to cover a multitude of projects of renewal in which little of the original fabric, or even context, was actually conserved. Gradually, the ideas about ‘urban renewal’, which were now firmly linked with ‘restoration’, came to signify a process of the gradual destruction of the historic cores of towns and villages. This attitude was aggravated by the notion that the architect should leave his mark, or at least the mark of the period of carrying out of work, and this to the detriment of the authentic character of the areas, which suffered the unhappy consequences of this attitude.
The problems of communication which are afflicting restoration stem from the fact that until not too long ago, little or nothing was heard about restoration, since it simply never made it into the news, unless it concerned a case of worldwide importance, or more commonly the loss of some piece of national heritage. This fact, in the context of today’s world where communication has become a key element to success, since the present apparent need for communication has far outstripped the importance it ever had in the past, and we are all now being trained to be better communicators, whatever our jobs or vocations may be. One may, in this context consider the Royal Opera House in Valletta, which was damaged during World War II and demolished during the ‘urban renewal’ of the City Gate area during the 1960’s. Although a number of projects have been proposed for it, none can said to have met with universal approval.
The culture of restoration reflects the all the contradictions of the architectural context of any specific period, since these are the consequences of the spirit of the time or ‘zeitgeist’. The danger of this is that much of what is passed-off as restoration is easily datable despite the pretensions of universality of the persons working in this field, since the architectural clichés, fashionable materials and methods of the period in question are embedded in the restoration. Often it is these very clichés that are the first to be removed in subsequent restorations since they soon become accretions!
It is obvious that there has never been a period in the past during which no restoration took place, since the most humble acts of maintenance, such as dusting and washing the floor, are restorative actions aimed at reinstating the original appearance which has been tarnished with time. This fact is commonly ignored by restorers as well as by the general public, which feels that no restoration is taking place unless some grand project is executed. It should be noted that according to the Venice Charter, any restoration project worth its salt should end with the formulation – and adoption – of a sustainable daily maintenance programme designed to avoid the need for further costly and intrusive restoration projects.
The same concepts apply to renewal. Although mankind has been renewing his environment since time immemorial, by repeatedly effecting small changes, which only gradually altered the appearance of the environment, and which until recently occurred so slowly that the authentic and traditional character of the environment was retained since the locale had time to adapt and react to the small sustainable changes which were taking place. This does not mean that radical changes did not happen over a long period of time, however the rate of change was such as to enable the conservation of the collective memory, or tradition, as well as being sustainable.
All of this also applies to our country, where renewal and restoration have been around since ever. The destruction wrought by World War II also brought about a rapid post-war reconstruction programme. The succeeding decades saw an exponential expansion of the urbanised area and as a result, many urban cores were largely abandoned and thereby saved apart from the onslaught caused by the so called urban renewal of the period, which generally consisted the creation of wide roads leading straight to the parish church.
In recent times the concept of restoration has become almost a buzzword, on everybody’s lips and with it, the idea of enjoyment, by a wider public, of its heritage. We all understand that the tourists who visit our monuments are to a certain extent the motors fuelling the restoration bandwagon and the money they spend on culture, in part, finances restoration. This concept, called ‘valorizzazione’ in Italian2,is a process of operations, which reveal the value of heritage. The patrimony is the universality of values, which includes language, culture and traditions, urban morphology and traditional building construction methods – which in our case incorporate some unique features. Therefore the perit, should be made well aware of all of this in his training, since the built environment, on which the profession of a perit is based, effects all aspects of human life to a greater or lesser extent. It is important for us to communicate – and transmit – the importance of our heritage and it is equally important to conserve it, and therefore renewal, which is a process that ensures a decent life-style for the citizen, must not reduce or diminish our heritage, which is also world heritage.
Therefore, the concepts of content and communication, with which I introduced these thoughts, remain fundamental for the furthering of sustainable restoration and renewal, communication enables the spread of knowledge of the content, and this leads to our critical evaluation of our environment and its components, in which, after all, we and the generations which follow have to live.
1 - XXth dynasty temples of Ramsesis II, in Egypt, moved to higher ground since the original site is now flooded by the waters of Lake Nasser, created by the Aswan dam.
2 - Or ‘mise en valeur’ in French.
Other Press Releases:
PR261929
PRESS RELEASE BY THE NATIONAL AUDIT OFFICE National Audit Office Malta hos...
PR261928