Speech by the Hon. John Dalli, Minister of Finance, during the ANNUAL DINNER of the Institute for Financial Services – Malta - 7th November 2002
Mr President, Fellow Minister, Governor, Your Excellencies, Distinguished Guests, Ladies and Gentlemen,
I am pleased to have the opportunity once again to address members of the financial community and their guests at this annual dinner hosted by the Institute of Financial Services - Malta. The Institute continues to contribute significantly to the financial services industry in Malta through its ongoing programmes in the area of education. The previous speakers have already acknowledged this so I will limit myself to wishing the President of the Institute and his committee continued success in their endeavours to foster and promote professional excellence in the financial sector.
This was another milestones year for the financial services industry. We have made a deep reform of the regulatory and supervisory structures and we overhauled the legal infrastructure on which the sector is based. We have today a regime that is state of the art and competitive in the global scenario.
This year we have also continued with our involvement in the development of international standards within the OECD. Even though a small country Malta played a leading role in the negotiations between OECD countries and the countries that provide financial services. Our interest was to upgrade the industry worldwide and to ensure that in this competitive sector, there is a level playing field that will enhance fair competition.
Let this be a lesson to those who are intimidated by our size. Those who still think that we are irrelevant because we are small. I shudder at the metaphor that we have heard comparing Malta to a butterfly on an elephant’s back or whitebait swimming with the whales. I shudder in resentment at these People who, because of their own complex, keep putting this country down. I know that we can walk with the best of them. I know because I was there, time and time again. I know because I see so many of our compatriots achieving a huge success when they are given an equal chance.
Europe will be giving us a chance, all of us, to compete on an equal footing with other nationalities. We have the acumen, we have the spirit and we have the stamina to succeed.
When I addressed you last year I stated that I am very optimistic about the future. I declare that I am still very optimistic about the future.
As we treaded through a very difficult year, we gave proof that although we are a small economy, wide open to outside influences, we managed to hold our own and manoeuvre our economy around and through the turbulences.
It was not easy.
The events of 11th September 2001 did have a devastating effect that reverberates louder and longer than expected. The angst of the public worldwide was kept at a high pitch with the constant media barrage of the New York drama and then of Afghanistan. Uncertainty was at the forefront of everybody’s consciousness causing a deep depression in attitude and which had a very negative effect on consumption and on investment decisions.
It is also unfortunate that as recovery was taking off, the beating of the war drums derailed it as the US turned its sights on Iraq. This came at a very delicate and vulnerable stage causing consumer confidence to falter and oil prices to skyrocket. This has affected all economies worldwide. As a result, all the developed economies revised their growth projections downward. In fact, for the first time in the last 25 years, we are going through a situation where the economies of all major economies around the globe are going through hard times.
Against this background, we in Malta also lowered our growth forecasts, particularly in view of the persistent negative outlook for the export-oriented sector that was inevitably affected by global conditions. In fact, although by the end of September the local economy was estimated to have contracted slightly in real terms, this trend became more pronounced during the last quarter when real GDP declined at an annual rate of 2.2%.
What is the situation today? On the international scene there was some evidence of a recovery, earlier in the year, led by the US. However, since then the global economy has remained weak and projections for this year and the next have once again been revised downwards by the IMF in recent weeks. This no doubt will have an impact on the Maltese economy, which because of its openness is very susceptible to developments in external demand. However, it must be said that in the context of a very unfavourable global context, the economy has shown a considerable degree of resilience. Indeed, there is enough evidence to demonstrate that we have been able to weather the storm much better than many other countries. Thus although Malta registered slightly negative growth in real output during 2001, the economic difficulties encountered by other economies, large and small, were often worse. Similarly, at a time when the domestic unemployment rate hovered around 5%, many developed countries had unemployment rates that were well above that level.
Since then there has been encouraging evidence of a recovery. Over the first quarter in fact the Maltese economy grew by 1.2%, while in the second quarter growth accelerated to 2.2%. Private consumption has picked up and the decline in export turnover that was registered during the latter half of 2001 has stabilised. Meanwhile, the contraction in exports experienced during the last quarter of 2001 was gradually reversed, and this has contributed to a substantial reduction in the merchandise trade deficit over the first three quarters of this year. Furthermore, the unemployment rate, though increasing slightly when compared with the year ago level, has remained generally stable, while the rate of inflation has declined to below 3%.
With regard to government finance, there has been much talk about the fiscal deficit, which in response to cyclical factors appears to have widened over the first nine months of the year. I am confident that despite the less than favourable economic conditions we have been facing, we will still be able to meet the target set in the budget estimates for this financial year.
In the tourism sector, although the number of arrivals up to July this year was 8% lower than a year ago, this decline was much less pronounced than that recorded in a number of competitor countries in the Mediterranean. Cyprus, for example, registered a fall of 13% over the same period. It appears that the downturn is bottoming out and that prospects are improving. In fact a number of tour operators have re-established themselves in Malta, while others plan to expand their operations here. Another positive development has been the increase in the number of cruise passengers arriving in Malta. These rose by 26% over the seven month period to July.
Overall, therefore, while some sectors are still operating below capacity, the Maltese economy is gradually emerging from the economic downturn in a better shape than might have been expected, and also better than some of our competitors.
We managed well. Our sights are now focused on the future.
We are aware that although we have come a long way in restructuring and organising our country, there is still much to be done. Let me say that this is a truism that will continue to hold in eternity. No matter how much is achieved, there is always still more that will be needed to be done. In fact experience shows that the more that is done, the longer the agenda for action becomes.
I welcome all ideas that instigate change. However all must realise that talking about problems does not solve them. Neither are problems solved by writing about them. Problems are solved by designing programmes of action that can be implemented within the milieu of the country - and at the pace that reform can be absorbed without causing unbearable rifts in society.
There are no such things as easy solutions.
It is extremely important that we put our finances on a viable track. It is the only way in which future governments can be unshackled and be at liberty to pursue policies that are proactive in increasing wealth, diffusing social justice and uplifting quality of life. It is the only way to secure our future by increasing our funding of innovation programmes and by increasing our funding of cultural initiatives.
To achieve this requires us to introduce and instil a culture of moderation in the demands we put on government. I am not speaking only about social programmes. Demands on government are not made only by those who are still imbued with the culture that government should provide everything for free. Demands are also being put on government by parts of the productive sector that seem to believe that competitivity should be enhanced through government subsidising their costs.
I keep reminding everybody that demands on government will only translate into demands by government – that is taxation. There is no manna falling from heaven.
One way to control these demands is by bringing this reality to the foreground during our deliberation of policy. The best way is to benchmark major expenditure to specific revenue flows. This is a way to bring discipline that enhances efficiency in the delivery of public services and discipline that curtails demands for more and even more.
Such mechanisms are now possible as we are approaching viable deficit levels. I propose that this is discussed very seriously at MCESD to try and find a consensus on how it is to be done. The first exercise can be the proposal that I have made in my budget last year about a split in the social security contribution into two portions, one related to pensions and another related to health.
We have also organised this country so that we devolve as much power as possible to the people. Subsidiarity is a mainstay of our belief. We have not only delegated downwards by pushing more and more functions to the local councils, we have also transferred authority sideways through the setting up of regulatory and supervisory authorities.
These are expected to operate autonomously from government, ensuring objective decisions and direction for the fair functioning of a competitive market. This is in the interest not only of the economic operators but also of the consumers. Because, after all, their main responsibility is the protection of the consumer. Their mission statement is to seek the interest of the people and therefore they must also be wary not to evolve into some kind of bureaucratic mammoths that exist for their own sake, braking progress through rigid dogmatic practices that lack creativity. We are responsible to make sure that this does not happen.
Those who denigrate subsidiarity denigrate this development. However this is what these obdurate critics have invariably done with all new developments that moved power away from politicians. They denigrated liberalisation, privatisation and local government. In all instances they were invariably proved wrong. The result is that they have repeatedly proved themselves to be devoid of vision.
The same will happen on the European issue.
As we look forward with excitement at the new atmosphere that we will step into, these obdurate critics keep looking back, hankering for days of old.
Some keep asking, "What is there in the EU for me?"
My answer is simple. If one goes by the seaside, or on a boat, or in the countryside, breathing nice fresh air, would not his mind work better, would not his performance be improved? But how does one give a value to this fresh air. Only through the sum of the improvement in his efforts and in the way he lives.
Europe is the fresh air that will give us the stimulus to perform better, to live better, and to attain better standards. We want to give this stimulus while the obdurate critics continue to disseminate anguish and fear in an attempt to anchor this country in a status quo.
However, there is no such thing as a status quo.
There is no status quo for the entrepreneur, as the protective regime will not be restored. Not being in Europe will only mean a stagnated economy as we have had four years ego when our application was frozen. This will destroy the opportunity of growth.
There is no status quo for the farmer. The World Trade Organisation will lift protective levies through the development of competitive standards. Not being in Europe will only mean that the assistance that they can expect to maintain their incomes will no longer be there.
There is no status quo for the workers. Membership in Europe will dramatically improve the investment profile of Malta. Membership in Europe will enhance the access to existing EU markets and will open access to the markets of the EU trading partners. This means jobs. This means better wages.
For the workers, non-membership means a worsened investment profile. We will be at a disadvantage with the new members as our market access and risk assessment will be deficient. This would mean lost investment, lost jobs, and lowering of wages to hang on to the jobs that remain.
There is no status quo for the financial services industry either. Non-membership will still tie us down to the standards set by global organisations, without the benefits.
I sincerely believe that this sector will benefit significantly from membership. First of all, as the Governor has observed, the next enlargement will imply an extension of the "single passport" to the new member states. As a result, financial services providers will be able to establish themselves freely across the enlarged Union.
There is no status quo for any of us. We want to move forward by hitching our cart to a robust entity in the globalised world. Not going forward will only mean going backwards.
I am convinced that as Malta’s investment potential is further enhanced by EU membership, the inflows of direct foreign investment will increase substantially, enabling the country to broaden its productive capacity and thus be in a stronger position to achieve higher rates of economic growth and to converge with the more advanced countries of the European Union.
Mr. President, Ladies and Gentlemen,
I am still very optimistic about the future. And this is because I am very optimistic about us, the People of Malta and Gozo.
Other Press Releases:
PR261929
PRESS RELEASE BY THE NATIONAL AUDIT OFFICE National Audit Office Malta hos...
PR261928