Left arrow Go Back

SPEECH BY THE HON. LAWRENCE GONZI, DEPUTY PRIME MINISTER AND MINISTER FOR SOCIAL POLICY, AT THE EUROPEAN CONFERENCE ORGANISED BY A.Z.A.D. WITH THE THEME: "THE QUALITY OF LIFE – THE EUROPEAN SOCIAL MODEL IN CONCRETE TERMS" - MELLIEHA – 4 OCTOBER 2002

PR1354
Date Icon 04/10/2002

Since I am the first Maltese politician to address you during this conference, I should begin by telling you what the Constitution of the Republic of Malta says about work: the first article of the first chapter of the Maltese Constitution states that the Republic is founded on work. This constitutional commitment to work contributes to my enthusiasm for this conference and to the great interest I have in its proceedings.

Naturally, I am also here as a Minister: labour policy falls within my portfolio; the challenges of globalisation, in their various forms, are challenges that I face on a daily basis.

I am here also as a Member of Parliament who represents people with rather particular challenges as regards the world of work. Essentially, my constituency is currently undergoing a transition – from a geographical area where much work was provided by the shipbuilding and ship-repairing industry, to an area where much more work is expected to derive from the tourist and service industry. I have no doubt that such a transition will be of great benefit to my constituency, but I also know that, like all transitions, this one will bring with it some social uncertainty and anxiety; and as a political representative with my constituents’ interests to heart I am keen to learn how these anxieties can best be addressed.

I am also here as a politician who is the deputy leader of a political party. It is a party that takes great pride in its record on work and employment: my party can boast that at the end of each term of office, it has left national employment at a higher level than it was at the beginning of the term. My party, which is called the Nationalist Party, has achieved this record by pursuing policies that drew upon the tradition of Christian Democracy, paying a close attention to the common good, to the principle of subsidiarity, and to the ideal of dialogue with social partners.

This does not mean that we have a magic formula that guarantees results. All it means is that we believe strongly that principles need to be applied to particular settings and these settings need to be diagnosed well before solutions and initiatives are undertaken. This is precisely why I am very interested to learn how, during this conference, you will diagnose the prospects of work in the future and the role that governments can play in generating work and protecting workers.

However, as I said at the very beginning, I am also here as a Maltese politician who has sworn to uphold a Constitution that states that the Republic of Malta is founded on work. I should say a few more words about this commitment because it colours my perspective on the subjects of this conference.

If the Constitution gives this great importance to work it is not because it sees Maltese citizens from a narrow perspective – only as workers. On the contrary. The point is that work is seen from a broad perspective. It is not just a source of gainful employment – or even a combination of paid and unpaid employment. Rather work is, ideally, a creative activity that is linked in various ways to the rest of our lives.

The satisfactions of work are located at the heart of our lives as complete persons. Labour markets cannot be completely divorced from other areas of social life, and when we try to act as though they were, we – governments, societies in general, and workers and their families in particular – quickly and intimately feel the negative, impoverishing consequences.

Now I think these observations are true as a rule: but perhaps they are more easily perceived to be true in a country like Malta, given its employment profile. The service industries are very important to the Maltese economy. Tourism is a key industry to us. Among the EU candidate countries, Malta is second only to Cyprus in the percentage share of employment in hotels and restaurants.

In the sectors of health and social work, Malta again ranks second among the candidate countries; in education it ranks third; in financial services we are once again second only to Cyprus. Of course the service industries are closely connected with the rest of social life in obvious ways: the quality of services depends on the personal attention and care that is given to the client; while the demand for such services is very exposed to changes in the quality of life of the clients.

For instance, like many other tourist venues Malta has suffered over the past year from the fear created by the terrorist attacks of September 11 last year.

But even in our manufacturing sector, the social element is very obvious. Our manufacturing and export industry is dominated by the production of semi-conductors; that is to say, parts that are essential to the communications industry. Over the past year our exports suffered somewhat because of a dip in the global fortunes of the communications giant Nokia – which thus reduced its demand for semi-conductors.

To sum up so far, I have said that the government of which I form part has three primary interests where work is concerned. First, we are interested in making the real world of employment correspond as much as possible to the ideal of work as a dignified and creative activity.

Second, we are very aware that the world of work cannot be divorced from other areas of life and that labour policies should be formulated by placing the whole person at their heart.

Third, the exposure of the Maltese economy to the world beyond Malta leads us to collaborate with other governments – governments that have values similar to ours – in order to secure the most favourable conditions for our workers in the face of the challenges posed by globalisation.

Each of these interests has implications for government policy and for how government thinks about its role.

Let us take first the ideal of work as a dignified and creative activity. I need hardly say that it is not easy to reach this ideal in practice; however, there are certain problems that arise within the workplace that should and can be resolved there – with the backing of legislation if necessary. Examples of this set of problems include standards of health and safety, and of unjust discrimination. The role of governments here is twofold: to promote the vision of dignified standards and to enforce them.

A very different set of problems is raised by the goal to see that work is not divorced completely from the rest of social life. Here there are problems that do affect the workplace, but they might arise outside it, and certainly their effects reach beyond the workplace. Whereas the set of problems I discussed a moment ago relate to the issue of the security of work at the workplace, this second set of problems is concerned with the security of employment.

People do not relate to the labour market simply as workers, or even simply as individuals. They enter the labour market, or try to do so, as members of families and other associations. And this means, as we know too well, that sometimes the obligations of one area of social life – for instance those of parenting – conflict with the obligations of work.

How should such conflicts be resolved? The problems are not all of the same difficulty. There is near consensus that accessible childcare facilities are desirable when they assist mothers to enter or stay within the labour market; but there is some controversy about whose responsibility it is to provide childcare facilities and what form they should take. Even more controversial is the idea of permitting certain kinds of flexible work arrangements; for on the one hand, non-standard contracts have the advantage of being able to address the needs of particular firms and workers, but on the other hand they can make high-standard work arrangements harder to secure.

These are not easy problems to resolve. They raise issues of responsibility, of the limits of experiment, and even of cultural acceptability. But it is clear that these problems are made more difficult to resolve if the government attempts to solve them on its own. The proper approach has to be that the government enters into dialogue with its social partners.

Dialogue need not be a euphemism for negotiation or compromise: it can be a way of constructing together a new way forward, which is only perceived once all the stake-holders come together. This is especially the case when what needs resolving is a new kind of problem, for which there is no precedent. Here social and legislative experiment will be inevitable; but experiments are not likely to succeed if the various partners do not trust each other.

In other words, social dialogue is not just a way of sharing information and resolving differences: it is a style of government that seeks to create an environment of trust that respects the social traditions and norms of the partners.

Just as government needs to dialogue with partners to resolve certain problems, it needs to dialogue with other governments to address certain issues raised by the exposure of national economies to global economic fortunes. About this there is no question. Nor does the Maltese government doubt that the European Union provides the best institutional framework within which the dialogue can take place.

However, questions about the appropriate competencies do arise, and they affect us all. Within the EU, and even within the Convention on the Future of Europe, the issue of the competencies of national governments with respect to social and labour policies is attracting more attention.

According to one point of view, labour markets should be regulated in a way as to make them more uniform across the Union; it is a uniformity that would encompass both the security of the workplace as well as the security of employment; the logic of the argument is that unequal labour market conditions create unfair competition and jeopardize the hard-won rights of workers.

On the other side of the debate, there is the view that regulation of national labour market conditions should remain the preserve of national governments, whose task it is to differentiate their labour markets as much as possible to their national advantage.

I appreciate the arguments on both sides of the debate. I also appreciate that this argument does deserve a close attention by all those who have European social values close to their heart. This is precisely the scope of this conference.

I will conclude, therefore, by stating once again that I am looking forward to listening to what this conference has to say on this topic. It is a topic that concerns us just as much as it concerns the future well being of all our citizens. I am certain that you will all appreciate that for a country such as Malta where the only resource we have is the human one, the topic acquires enormous importance.

It is for this reason that as of now, I thank all of your for your valuable contribution to the debate.

Thank-you!

Share this Press Release Icon socials Icon socials Icon socials Icon socials

Other Press Releases:

PRESS RELEASE BY THE NATIONAL AUDIT OFFICE  National Audit Office Malta hosts bilateral meeting with the Spanish Court of Audit

PR261929

PRESS RELEASE BY THE NATIONAL AUDIT OFFICE National Audit Office Malta hos...

STQARRIJA MILL-UFFIĊĊJU TAL-PRIM MINISTRU  “Sodisfatt bil-qbil bejn il-mexxejja tal-UE għax Malta ilha mill-bidu nett timbotta favur soluzzjoni għall-paċi” – Il-Prim Ministru Robert Abela

PR261926

STQARRIJA MILL-UFFIĊĊJU TAL-PRIM MINISTRU “Sodisfatt bil-qbil bejn il-mexx...

More Press Releases Right arrow