GOVERNMENT'S COMMENTS TO THE INTERVIEW GIVEN BY THE OMBUDSMAN AS REPORTED IN THE PRESS
In the wide-ranging interview he gave to "The Independent on Sunday" on 1 September 2002, the Ombudsman was reported as having said that "Overall it (i.e. the Office of the Ombudsman) is an institution which is working". There is no doubt that this opinion is widely shared in Malta. The Government itself also holds firmly to the same view.
It is therefore very unfortunate, to say the least, that a number of opinions expressed in the interview are not only gratuitous but, taken as a whole, do nothing to enhance the respect in which the institution should be, and in fact is, held. Indeed the whole tone of the interview and the way that the Ombudsman handles many of the issues can be said to give the distinct impression that the replies have the flavour of political comment. One can assume that this is not intentional but nonetheless it is inherently wrong coming as it does from the head of such an important independent institution. The independence afforded by law to the Ombudsman certainly extends to his right, and indeed duty, to criticise Government institutions where such criticism is due. This is certainly not disputed in any way. But even the way that the criticism is presented in the media should surely be an important consideration in any interview given by the Ombudsman.
It is not intended to go into detail here on each and every point raised in the interview with the presentation of the criticism of which the Government does not agree. However, there are some aspects on which one cannot but comment briefly.
When commenting on his report about the case of Enemalta Finance Manager Tarcisio Mifsud, the manner in which he refers, more than once, to government’s arguments as "unbelievable" and his assertion that the Prime Minister "didn’t bother talking to me about the case" are certainly objectionable, if not downright insulting. The Ombudsman in fact himself uses the very same adjective ("insulting") when he says that "they" were trying to use his arguments to shoot down his own conclusions. The pronoun "they" is one he uses time and time again in the interview, the obvious inference being that it is the opposite of "us"!
The linking by the Ombudsman of the case of the Enemalta Finance Manager with that of the attempted murder of the Personal Assistant to the Prime Minister is unacceptable because the two cases bear no comparison on all counts.
As indicated by the Ombudsman, the question of compensation in the case of the attempted murder of one of the Prime Minister’s closest advisers was discussed and decided on in Cabinet. Lecturing the Cabinet on what it should have done or not have done is certainly against the spirit, if not also the letter, of the Ombudsman Act. To say the very least the Ombudsman’s comments on the Cabinet’s deliberations and decisions constitute an indiscretion on his part. The verbatim reproduction of the relevant Cabinet Minutes by Mr Joe Mifsud in the Sunday newspaper KullĦadd of 1 September 2002 when reporting on the Ombudsman’s remarks on the case, is also nothing less than deplorable.
In his interview the Ombudsman also makes strong comments on recent promotions in the AFM, which situation he describes as "a mess". One would have thought that, with his background of the Public Service of which he formed part right up to his retirement as the Head of the Service in 1995 to take up the position he occupies today, Mr Sammut should have had more background than most on the overall vast improvement in the procedure for effecting AFM promotions when compared to the methods used under previous administrations during his own civil service career. The Commander AFM will be responding separately to the points raised by the Ombudsman, as indeed will MEPA, classified in the interview along with AFM as the "worst government institutions".
When commenting on government agencies, the Ombudsman makes a number of suggestions but also thinks it fit to highlight particular examples, among them appointments in the Water Services Corporation, in the process using rather strong descriptive language, presumably intended to ‘shock’ his readers.
The Ombudsman refers to the Lands Department as being "impossible" and "hopeless" – without mentioning in that connection, that many of the, so far intractable, bureaucratic difficulties in that department are not recent developments, but in fact practices that originated during, if not before, his civil service days and his tenure as Permanent Secretary OPM and Administrative Secretary.
When the present Government proposed to Parliament the appointment of the Ombudsman in 1995 for a first five year term and subsequently for a second one two years ago, it did so not only in the knowledge of his undoubted competence but also in the expectation that, when dealing with citizens’ complaints he would do so with a general fairness of approach. The fact that that expectation has hitherto been generally met over the past seven years makes even more inexplicable what can only be described as an indiscreet and harmful outburst at this particular point in the Ombudsman’s second term.
It is finally worth mentioning that it is extremely painful for the Government to have had to issue this statement on what it considers to be highly inappropriate remarks made by the Head of a Parliamentary Institution which has so far enjoyed the respect of, among others, the two major political parties and, no doubt, of the public at large. For the sake of the country, it is sincerely hoped that the interview given by the Ombudsman will not have damaged that respect too much.
Other Press Releases:
PR261926
STQARRIJA MILL-UFFIĊĊJU TAL-PRIM MINISTRU “Sodisfatt bil-qbil bejn il-mexx...
PR261925EN