PRESS RELEASE BY THE NATIONAL AUDIT OFFICE An audit of the contract for the provision of food and beverage services at the Malta Life Sciences Park
The National Audit Office (NAO) reviewed the request for proposals (RfP) issued by the Malta Life Sciences Park for the provision of food and beverage (F&B) services at the Malta Life Sciences Centre and the Malta Digital Hub Ltd. (MDH) in November 2015. A lease agreement was entered into between the MDH and Cook & Co. Ltd. in May 2016. After several years of operation, Cook & Co. Ltd. maintained that the RfP was fraudulent in that the premises were not as described, giving rise to operational difficulties.
The NAO noted that the RfP provided bidders with an understanding of the broad objectives of the call; however, shortcomings were noted. Its heading was ambiguous in that, rather than procuring an F&B service, Malta Enterprise was leasing a site from which this service was to be provided. The RfP lacked detailed plans for the site, which was considered relevant given that its use was changed from a childcare centre to a catering establishment, necessitating adaptations. The NAO noted inconsistencies between the actual premises, the plans annexed to the RfP, and those submitted by Malta Enterprise in its planning application for the change of use. Visibility was curtailed since no site visit was held during bidding.
The process of evaluation undertaken by Malta Enterprise adhered to the conditions established in the RfP, with the criteria set and relevant weightings fairly applied to both bids received, which effectively led to the selection of the bid that was the most economically advantageous. Notwithstanding this, shortcomings during this process were noted, including gaps in documentation, the meeting held solely with Cook & Co. Ltd. during evaluation, and the notification of the successful outcome of its bid prior to the referral of the evaluation report for the endorsement of the Malta Enterprise Board of Directors.
The lease agreement specified the rights and obligations of the MDH as landlord and Cook & Co. Ltd. as tenant. The main concern that emerged was the state of the premises and the onus of the works required to render them suitable for the envisaged use. While the agreement specified that the property was being transferred tale quale, the RfP only provided a limited understanding of its condition, did not specify that it was being transferred 'as is' and did not provide a warranty on use.
Cook & Co. Ltd. started operating the Zenzero restaurant in January 2017, several months after the stipulated date. This delay could not be solely attributed to Cook & Co. Ltd., for several defects were noted when assuming ownership, necessitating rectification. Responsibility for the work remained contentious, with latent deficiencies complicating matters. While the endorsement of the MDH for work undertaken was sought and provided, the procedure specified in the agreement was not followed.
The Planning Authority permit for the change of use of the site was issued on August 24, 2016, a week prior to the stipulated commencement date. Moreover, the permit was subject to conditions necessitating work to adapt the premises. An attempt by Cook & Co. Ltd. to sanction the works undertaken revealed a discrepancy in the area of the site, which was not in conformity with the permit. The NAO established that this incongruence was not attributable to either party but arose during the planning screening process. Of concern was that Cook & Co. Ltd. carried out the work without the prior sanction of the authority. Nevertheless, the MDH had visibility over the works and ought to have ascertained that these were covered by a permit. Delay in the issuance of the permit prolonged the process of obtaining an operating licence, with a temporary licence secured on December 12, 2016. When this expired in March 2017, Cook & Co. Ltd. continued to operate the restaurant for several years despite not having a valid licence.
The NAO asserts that Cook & Co. Ltd.'s failure to pay rent and other charges constituted a breach of the lease agreement. While the NAO noted that there existed several grounds for the rescinding of the lease, it is pertinent to note that judicial action instigated by the parties was ongoing at the time of reporting.
The report may be accessed by visiting our website, www.nao.gov.mt, or on its Facebook page, www.facebook.com/NAOMalta.
Stqarrijiet Oħra:
PR261934en
PRESS RELEASE BY THE MINISTRY FOR THE ECONOMY, TECHNOLOGY AND STRATEGIC PRO...
PR261934