Maltese Parliamentary Delegation attends the Autumn Session of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe (4-8 October 2010)
pr1836
08/10/2010
| Debates on “the need to | avoid duplication of the work of the Council of Europe by the EU Agency for Fundamental Rights”; “Child Abuse in Institutions: ensure full protection of the victims”, and “Women’s access to lawful medical care: the problem of unregulated use of conscientious objection”, were among the highlights of the autumn session of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe (PACE) convened between 4-8 October 2010 in Strasbourg. The members who attended this part-session were Hon Francis Agius MP as Leader of the Delegation, Hon Joe Debono Grech MP, Hon Marie Louise Coleiro MP and Hon Joseph Falzon MP. |
| During the session the | Parliamentary Assembly elected Wojciech Sawicki to the post of Secretary General of the Assembly for a five-year term starting on 1 February 2011. Mr Wojciech is an M.Sc. graduate in computer science from the University of Warsaw and subsequently worked at the Power Industry Computer Centre where he was also chairman of the “Solidarnosc” Trade Union Section. He joined the Council of Europe in 1996 as Director of the General Services Department and has held the post of Director General, deputising for the Secretary General of the Assembly since 2006. |
| Throughout the week, the | Assembly was addressed by two distinguished speakers, namely Hon Guido Westerwelle, Deputy Federal Chancellor and Federal Minister for Foreign Affairs of Germany; and HE Nikola Greuvski, Prime Minister of “the former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia”. |
| In his address Hon | Westelle warned of an increasing nationalism in politics. "It may get you applause back home", he said, but it is "irresponsible". This sentiment was mirrored by the PACE President Mevlüt Çavusoglu during a press conference on the first day of the session where he expressed his concern at the recent rise of populist and extremist candidates and groupings who were obtaining significant results in many countries at regional and national elections. He stressed that “they exploit the resentments stirred by economic decline and social crisis as they are elected on an 'anti'-ticket: anti-immigration, anti-muslim, anti-europe. We have to carefully monitor these movements as they have become a parliamentary force and start to influence how other parties behave and speak”. |
| The PACE adopted a | resolution whereby it called upon EU member states and institutions to take all necessary measures to avoid unnecessary duplication of the work of the Council of Europe by the EU Agency for Fundamental Rights. The Assembly members stated that, such duplication could cause confusion in the interpretation of European human rights standards or even lead to the emergence of double standards. According to the PACE rapporteur on the subject, Boriss Cilevics (Latvia, SOC), the activities of both organisations – the data collection and analyses conducted by the Agency and the monitoring carried out by the Council – may complement each other. The Assembly also declared that fruitful co-operation will only be possible if the Council of Europe’s acquis in the area of human rights protection is always used as the main point of reference in the Agency’s work. |
| At the end of a debate | on child abuse in institutions, the PACE called for more far-reaching measures in the future when it comes to according full justice to victims of past offences. According to the Assembly, more committed action is required at national level when it comes to reinforcing legislation on child abuse and applying it to various institutional contexts. No authority or institution should be exempt from critical review, as all institutions without exception are subject to the same national legislation, particularly in the field of criminal law. The adopted text, based on the proposals by rapporteur Marlene Rupprecht (Germany, SOC), expresses concern at the lack of committed action which has sometimes been observed when it comes to dealing with offences against minors. It recommends that European governments ensure legislative protection by providing for the ex-officio prosecution in cases of child abuse in any context, defining as illegal and excluding certain practices with regard to the punishment of minors in institutions which are contrary to their dignity and rights. The adopted text calls on the Council of Europe member states to sign and ratify the Convention on the protection of children against sexual exploitation and sexual abuse, and invites public authorities and national parliaments to join in the Council of Europe’s campaign to stop sexual violence against children, which will be launched in Rome on 29 and 30 November 2010. |
| At the end of a rather | lively debate on Thursday evening, the Assembly emphasized the need to affirm the right of conscientious objection in lawful medical care. The Members were discussing and voting on text presented by the Social, Health and Family Affairs Committee entitled “Women’s access to lawful medical care: the problem of unregulated use of conscientious objection.” Conscientious objection in the health care field occurs when health professionals such as doctors or nurses refuse to provide certain services based on religious, moral or philosophical objections. As rapporteur Christine McCafferty (UK, SOC). pointed out in section 4 of her memorandum, these services consist of, for example, certain family planning services and reproductive technologies, safe abortion services where legal, and pain-relief by life-shortening means for terminally ill patients. |
| The original text | presented by the Committee was substantially amended, with the adopted resolution now stating that: |
| “no person and no hospital or institution | shall be coerced, held liable or discriminated against in any manner because of a refusal to perform, accommodate, assist or submit to an abortion …” |
| Hon Francis Agius MP, | Hon Joseph Debono Grech MP and Hon Joseph Falzon MP formed part of, at times, a slight majority that contributed to extensively amending both the resolution and recommendation prepared by the Committee rapporteur. The objections made to the McCafferty report from the Maltese side were to retain the right of conscientious objection to participation in certain medical procedures and the ethical responsibility of healthcare professionals, while at the same time ensuring that patients are not prevented from receiving the necessary medical care appropriate to their need in a timely manner. A total of 89 amendments were presented, 11 of which were tabled by Hon Luca Volonte (Italy, EPP/CD) President of the EPP Group, Hon Agius, Hon Falzon and other members. (see annex A) |
| The amended resolution | was adopted with 56 votes in favour, 51 against and 4 abstentions. The amended recommendation was not adopted as it did not get the required two thirds majority. |
| The resolution was also | discussed earlier in the week by the Committee on Equal Opportunities for Women and Men. The Committee members were called upon to approve an opinion report (Doc. 12389) prepared by rapporteur Ingrida Circene (Latvia, EPP/CD) which supported the McCafferty resolution and recommendation. Malta - which was represented in this Committee by Hon Mary Louise Coleiro Preca MP – formed part of the minority - three countries - that voted against the opinion report. |
| Hon Francis Agius | participated in the Social, Health and Family Affairs Committee which, in view of the large number of amendments tabled for the McCafferty report held extended meetings. Hon Agius was also elected Vice Chairperson of the sub-committee on children’s rights. The upcoming event of the Council of Europe in this area is the above mentioned launching in November of the European Campaign to stop sexual violence against children, officially known as the Lanzarote Convention on the protection of children against sexual exploitation and sexual abuse. |
| Hon Joseph Falzon MP | participated in the Committee on the Environment, Agriculture and Local and Regional Affairs which confirmed the minutes of the previous meeting held in Paris during which Hon Falzon presented a report and a preliminary draft resolution entitled “Preserving the environment in the Mediterranean”. The Hon Member stressed that, in order to preserve the environment in the Mediterranean; action was needed both at local and international level. He also remarked that political pressure was needed in order to obtain results. In the preparation of his report, Hon Falzon had the opportunity to work with the International Centre for Advanced Mediterranean Agronomic Studies (CIHEAM). |
| Following Hon Joseph | Debono Grech’s participation on a mission to Azerbaijan as co-rapporteur for the Monitoring Committee on 8-12 February 2010 a resolution on the functioning of democratic institutions in Azerbaijan was adopted during the Summer part-session. In relation to the work conducted by Hon Debono Grech in this sector, the Hon Member met with a representative from the European Association of Jehovah’s Christian Witnesses on the latter’s request. Mr Luca Toffoli, Counsel for Religious Freedom, raised a number of issues concerning difficulties his religious organization was experiencing in the country with regard to re-registration, illegal police interference, importation of religious literature and conscientious objection to military service. Hon Debono Grech gave a brief overview of the work he carried out on behalf of the Committee and informed Mr Toffoli that, given the opportunity, shall raise the issues during his participation as an election observer in Azerbaijan in November. |
| On | Wednesday, the 2nd meeting of the PACE network of contact parliamentarians committed to combating violence against women met in Strasbourg. As Malta’s contact parliamentarian - Hon Francis Agius - could not take part due to his participation in other Committees, he submitted a paper (see annex B) on the recent legislative developments in Malta with respect to the third Committee agenda item entitled “Parliaments get involved: presentations by contact parliamentarians on recent parliamentary activities undertaken or to be undertaken at national level.”. |
... / Annexe A - B
DOI – 08.10.2010
Annex A
Amendment 80
| Tabled by Mr Luca Volonte, Mr Dariusz Lipinski, | Mr Valeriu Chiletchi, Mr Latchezar Toshev, Mr Laurent Beteille, Mrs Marie-Louise Bemelmans-Videc, Mr Joao Bosco Mota Amaral, Mr Francis Agius, Mr Jospeh Falzon, Mrs Rossana Boldi. |
| In the draft resoltuion, replace paragraph 1 with | the following paragraph: |
| “The right of conscientious objection is a | fundamental aspect of the right of freedom of thought, conscience and religion enshrined in the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and European Convention on Human Rights”, (Recommendation 1518(2001). In the field of health medical care, the European Convention on Human Rights case law guarantees this right to both individuals and organisations which subscribe to a particular moral ethos. |
Amendment 81
| Tabled by Mr Luca Volonte, Mr Dariusz Lipinski, | Mr Valeriu Chiletchi, Mr Latchezar Toshev, Mr Laurent Beteille, Mr Pavol Kubovic, Mr Martin Fronc, Mr Joao Bosco Mota Amaral, Fr Francis Agius, Mr Joseph Falzon, Mrs Rossana Boldi. |
| In the draft resolution, after paragraph 1, | insert the following paragraph: |
| “No person and no hospital or institution shall | be coerced, held liable or discriminated against in any manner because of a refusal to perform, accomodate, assist or submit to an abortion, the performance of a human miscarriage, or euthanasia or any act which could cause the death of a human foetus or embryo, for any reason.” |
(adopted)
Amendment 82
| Tabled by Mr Luca Volonte, Mr Darusz Lipinski, Mr | Valeriu Ghiletchi, Mr Latchezar Toshev, Mr Laurent Betheille, Mr Rudy Salles, Mrs Muriel Marland-Militello, Mr Giacomo Santini, Mr Luigi Vitali, Mr Joao Bosco Mota Amaral, Mr Francis Agius, Mr Joseph Falzon, Mrs Rossana Boldi. |
| In the draft resoltuion, replace paragraph 2 with | the following paragraph: |
| “The Assembly emphasises the need to duly respect | the right of consientious objection to participation in certain medical procedures and the ethical responsibility of healthcare professionals, while at the same time ensuring that patients are not prevented from receiving the necessary medical care appropriate to their need in a timely manner.”. |
Amendment 83
| Tabled by Mr Luca Volonte, Mr Joseph Falzon, Mr | Dariusz Lipinski, Mr Valeriu Ghiletchi, Mr Latchezar Toshev, Mr Francis Agius, Mr Laurent Beteille, Mr Rudy Salles, Mrs Muriel Marland-Militello, Mr Giacomo Santini, Mrs Marie-Louise Bemelmans-Videc, Mr Hans Franken, Mr Francois Rochebloine, Mrs Christine Marin, Mr Joao Boso Mota Amaral, Mr Marco Gatti, Mr Martin Fronc, Mr Pavol Kubovic, Mrs Rossana Boldi. |
| In the draft resoltuion, after paragraph 2, | insert the folloiwng paragraph: |
| “No person and no hospital or institution shall | be coerced, held liable or discriminated against in any manner because of any refusal to perform, accomodate, assist or submit to an abortion, the performance of a human miscarriage, euthanasia or any action which causes the deth of a human foetus or embryo, for any reason.” |
Amendment 84
| Tabled by Mr Luca Volonte, Mr Dariusz Lipinski, | Mr Valeriu Chiletchi, Mr Latchezar Toshev, Mr Laurent Beteille, Mr Rudy Salles, Mrs Muriel Marland-Militello, Mr Giacomo Santini, Mr Luigi Vitali, Mr Joao Cosco Mota Amaral, Mr Francis Agius, Mr Joseph Falzon, Mrs Rossana Boldi. |
| In the draft resolution, replace paragraph 3 with | the following paragraph: |
| “In the majority of Council of Europe member | states, the practice of conscientious objection is adequately regulated. A comprehensive and clear legal and policy framework governing the practice of conscientious objectin by healthcare providers ensures that the interests and rights of both healthcare providers and individuals seekign legal medical services are respected, protected and fulfilled.” |
Amendment 85
| Tabled by Mr Luca Volonte, Mr Joseph Falzon, Mr | Dariusz Lipinski, Mr Valeriu Ghiletchi, Mr Latchezar Toshev, Mr Francis Agius, Mr Laurent Beteille, Mrs Marie-Louise Bemelmans-videc, Mr Hans Franken, Mrs Elke Tindemans, Mr Joao Bosco Mota Amaral, Mrs Rossana Boldi. |
| In the draft resolution, replace paragraph 4 with | the following paragraph: |
| “In view of member states’ obligation to ensure | access to lawful medical care and to protect the right to health, as well as the obligation to ensure respect for the right of freedom of thought, consience and religion of healthcare providers, the Assembly invites member states to: |
| - develop comprehensive and clear regulations | that define and regulate conscientious objection with regard to health and medical services, which: - guarantee the right to conscientious objection in relation to participation in the procedure in question; - ensure that patients are informed of any objection in a timely manner and referred to another healthcare provider; - ensure that patients receive appropriate treatment, in particular in cases of emergency.” |
(Adopted)
Amendment 86
| Tabled by Mr Luca Volonte, Mr Dariusz Lipinski, | Mr Valeriu Chiletchi, Mr Latchezar Toshev, Mr Laurent Beteille, Mr Martin Fronc, Mr Joao Bosco Mota Amaral, Mr Francis Agius, Mr Joseph Falzon, Mrs Rossana Boldi. |
| In the draft recommendation, replace pargraph 2 | with the following paragraph: |
| “The Assembly reaffirms the importance of the | right of medical conscientious objection, especially in the field of reproductive healthcare, for both individuals and institutions of a religious or moral ethos.” |
(Adopted)
Amendment 88
| Tabled by Mr Luca Volonte, Mr Dariusz Lipinski, | Mr Valeriu Chiletchi, Mr Latchezar Toshev, Mr Laurent Beteille, Mr Christos Pourgourides, Mr Pavol Kubovic, Mrs Marie-Louise Bemelmans-Videc, Mr Hans Franken, Mrs Elke Tindemans, Mr Joao Bosco Mota Amaral, Mr Francis Agius, Mr Joseph Falzon, Mrs Rossana Boldi. |
| In the draft recommendation, replace paragraph 3 | with the following paragraph: |
| “The Assembly believes that the right of | conscientious objection to participation in a certain medical procedure must take into account the ethical responsability of the medical profession and ensure that patients are not prevented from receiving the necessary medical care appropriate to their need in a timely manner.” |
Amendment 87
| Tabled by Mr Luca Volonte, Mr Dariuz Lipinski, Mr | Valeriu Chiletchi, Mr Latchezar Toshev, Mr Laurent Beteille, Mr Rudy Salles, Mrs Muriel Marland-Militello, Mr Giacomo Santini, Mr Luigi Vitali, Mr Joao Bosco Mota Amaral, Mr Francis Agius, Mr Joseph Falzon, Mrs Rossana Boldi. |
| In the draft recommendation, paragraph 4.2, | replace the words “in the developmetn of such regulations and the setting up of such oversight and monitoring mechanisms” with the following words: |
| “in fully respecting the human right of | conscientious objection”. |
(Adopted)
Amendment 89
| Tabled by Mr Luca Volonte, Mr Dariusz Lipinski, | Mr Valeriu Chiletchi, Mr Latchezar Toshev, Mr Laurent Beteille, Mr Joao Bosco Mota Amaral, Mr Francis Agius, Mr Joseph Falzon, Mrs Rossana Boldi. |
| In the draft recommendation, replace the title of | the reccommendation with the following title: |
| “The right to conscientious objection in lawful | medical care”. |
(Adopted)
Annex B
Combating Violence against women
Recent legislative developments in Malta
The national legal framework on domestic violence is based on the adopted Domestic Violence Act (Ch 481) and the relative amendments to the Criminal and Civil Code carried out in 2006.
The Domestic Violence Act
| Domestic Violence is defined as ‘Any act of | violence, even if only verbal, perpetrated by a household member upon another household member and includes any omission which causes physical or moral harm to the other’. The Act therefore envisages that domestic violence can take three different forms, namely physical, verbal and moral. |
| The Domestic Violence Act also provides for the | setting up of a Commission on Domestic Violence. The main role of the Commission is that of advising the Minister responsible for social policy on all aspects of Domestic Violence. |
| The Act moreover provides for the designation of | an agency to provide preventive, therapeutic and treatment programmes for both victims and perpetrators. Agenzija Appoġġ has in fact been designated as this agency. |
The Criminal Code
| The relative innovations to the criminal code | constitute another very important pillar on which this legal framework is based, in that offences involving domestic violence can now be dealt with more appropriately. This is due to the fact that by virtue of these amendments, when violence involves elements which make it ‘domestic’, the relative offence is aggravated. |
| The criminal code moreover now envisages two new | offences, namely ‘harassment’ and ‘fear of violence’. Harassment occurs when there is a course of conduct which amounts to harassment of another person and the perpetrator knows or ought to know that this amounts to harassment of such other person. It includes alarming a person or causing the person distress. This offence is punishable with imprisonment from one to three months or with a fine which can range from Lm1,000 to Lm2000 or with both such fine and imprisonment. |
| Something innovative that was also recently | introduced in our criminal code is the fact that the Police are now empowered to proceed ex officio in those cases involving domestic violence. Prior to this amendment, it often happened that domestic violence could not be prosecuted since the victim would not lodge a formal complaint with the Police, usually because of fear of the perpetrator. The Police therefore had their hands tied in most cases where they would be aware of the violence; however they would be unable to proceed without the required complaint. The situation has now changed, and the Police have the power to prosecute such offences even without the complaint of the victim. This even with regards to sexual offences, in relation to which the general rule is that the relative proceedings can only be instituted upon the complaint of the victim. |
| When proceedings relating to offences involving | domestic violence are instituted, the alleged victim may request the Court to stay proceedings against the alleged perpetrator. The Courts are now also empowered to issue Protection, Restraining or Treatment Orders when dealing with cases of domestic violence. |
The Civil Code
| The Civil Code has also been amended to cater for | the protection of victims and treatment of perpetrators even during civil proceedings. Thus, when there is an application for personal separation between spouses, and domestic violence is involved, the case shall be appointed for hearing within four days. Moreover, the Civil Courts may issue Protection and Treatment Orders during suits for personal separation. |
| Extracts from ‘Domestic Violence: Recent | Legislative Developments’, Dr. Roberta Lepre B.A. LL.D. – Member of the Commission on Domestic Violence (November 2006). |
| The Commission on Domestic Violence monitors and | reviews legislation and measures provided for by the law. The Commission has been reviewing the legislation and recommended amendments to the current legislation. (Annual Report March 2008 – February 2009). |
-----------------------------------------
Other Press Releases:
PR261993
STQARRIJA MILL-MINISTERU GĦALL-INKLUŻJONI U L-VOLONTARJAT “Meta nappoġġjaw...
PR261992