SPEECH BY THE HON JOE CASSAR, MINISTER FOR HEALTH, THE ELDERLY AND COMMUNITY CARE - THE OVIEDO CONVENTION MATER DEI HOSPITAL – 6TH MAY 2010
Ten years into the passage of the Oviedo or Bioethics Convention of the Council of Europe, is a good time for reflection on the process of acceptance of this important Convention as a part of the body of European law.
After the Second World War, it was justified by the Council of Europe to come up with the European Convention on Human Rights to protect the most vulnerable. Medical or biological abusive research and practice by notorious doctors, particularly on those persons who were not able to exercise full psychological responsibility such as children and psychiatric patients was quite common at the time. Therefore it was justifiable and prophetic to include a special convention on human rights with regard to the application of biology and medicine, the Convention on Human Rights and Biomedicine or Oviedo Convention.
Since those dark chapters of European history, new developments in psychiatry and medicine have developed which pose a new potential threat to the dignity of the human being. New developments in IVF and embryo fertilization technology, genetic testing, genetic engineering, transplantation of organs and human cloning and stem cell research, all pose a potential threat unless used appropriately.
The Oviedo Convention includes articles on all these potential abuses and seeks to put the primacy of the human being above the sole interest of society or science. It also ensures equitable access to health care and the maintenance of professional standards. It also allows individual recourse to the European Court on Human Rights if any of the provisions it contains are broken. It enforces the rule for free and informed consent and sets out detailed procedures to cover medical interventions and research on those not able to consent. Children and patients with a mental disorder are specifically referred to with special procedures listed separately for both. It also makes allowance for special procedures for previously expressed wishes of a patient to be carried out after death.
In this day and age of computers, care is taken to protect privacy of and access to personal medical information and to protect the right to a private life. Transplantations of organs are dealt with specifically in separate articles and even are alluded to in a separate protocol to the Convention. For example financial gain on organ transplants is made verbatim illegal and prohibited.
In these recent days, man has learnt to decipher the human genome and to modify it. These processes are full of potencies open to abuse and the need for regulation in these spheres is evident. Insurance companies, educational facilities and worker employment can all be spheres where the demand of a genetic test may make the whole difference between success or failure in a particular field of pursuance. The Convention makes it illegal to ask for this information outside the medical field. The danger of abortion following prenatal genetic diagnosis showing disease in the foetus, a relatively easy procedure, and the killing of embryos not up to the mark, in pre-implantation genetic diagnostic testing, both require a particular need to be addressed in today’s world. So is the issue of discrimination on the basis of genetic eugenesis and the selection of sexual attributes for economical or social reasons before birth.
Not only has man now read the genome but one can also change it. This procedure of transgenesis or genetic engineering has great potential in helping therapeutic progress in genetic disease especially those in single gene defects. However this process may also be abused. Genes may be changed for enhancement purposes as well, making this a great problem of equity. We also have a duty to pass onto future generations an intact genome that is not abusively changed by our interventions with catastrophic consequences to our future children.
Embryo research not directed at the good of the same embryo and the creation of embryos simply for research purposes should be resisted as an affront to the dignity of early human life which my government believes merits due respect from fertilization, as full members of the species Homo sapiens and thereby the human race. The Bioethics Convention lends itself to all these points mentioned in order to prevent abuse.
It has always been the aim of this Ministry to render a free health service to the community in general which is second to none. It is good that there exists such a convention such as the Bioethics one, that governments may adopt as a minimum standard to safe medical and research practice and thereby one that contains common European and Human values under the umbrella of the Council of Europe.
Stqarrijiet Oħra:
PR261991
STQARRIJA MILL-MINISTERU GĦALL-AGRIKOLTURA, IS-SAJD U L-PROVVISTA TAL-IKEL ...
PR261990