Left arrow Go Back

MALTA’S POSITION REGARDING THE EUROPEAN COMMISSION’S PROPOSAL FOR A COUNCIL DECISION ON ESTABLISHING THE POSITION TO BE ADOPTED ON THE EUROPEAN UNION’S BEHALF WITH REGARD TO CERTAIN PROPOSALS SUBMITTED TO THE 15TH MEETING OF THE CONFERENCE OF THE P

PR0340
Date Icon 26/02/2010

This is the position submitted by Malta to the Council, on 25 February 2010, on the European Commission’s proposal for a Council Decision establishing the position to be adopted on the European Union’s behalf with regard to certain proposals submitted to the 15th meeting of the Conference of the Parties (CoP 15) to the Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species of Wild Fauna and Flora (CITES), Doha, Qatar, 13-25 March 2010.

Annex 1 

While the Commission has proposed for the European Union to support the listing of Bluefin tuna (BFT) as an Appendix I species to the CITES Convention, Malta believes that the management of BFT should continue to rest within the International Commission for the Conservation of Atlantic Tunas (ICCAT) as Regional Fisheries Management Organisation. It is pertinent to note that at Community level Malta has always advocated support for the sustainable management of tuna stocks, and the Commission proposal in fact makes reference to the stock assessment data to emerge from ICCAT’s scientific body. ICCAT’s Standing Committee for Research and Statistics on the other hand has consistently stated that the available data to carry out stock assessments is inadequate and incomplete. Malta’s primary interest is to ensure that the management of BFT remains within ICCAT as the appropriate forum in which the sustainable management of tuna stocks should be discussed and ensured. Malta believes that the decisions on fisheries activities concerning BFT should be based on scientific studies, that is, on criteria of sustainability rather than assumptions. Sustainability in the management of the stock is required as this is a very important stock in Malta’s fisheries and aquaculture sectors. 

Malta is also of the opinion that CITES procedures do not allow for the proposed listing on a conditional basis, that is pending the assessment of ICCAT’s scientific body. The staggered approach being proposed by the Commission will continue to rely on the framework of ICCAT’s decisions, including the recovery plan for this stock, without ensuring legal certainty on future decisions that will affect those involved in this sector.  In light of this, Malta continues to be of the opinion that the management and sustainability of Bluefin tuna stocks should be ensured through ICCAT, thus avoiding issues that may arise out of dual governance (CITES and ICCAT) of the species. In line with the question raised by other delegations at the Working Party on the Environment meeting on 23 February, Malta also awaits legal clarifications from the Commission on whether the CITES rules allow for such conditional listing, and asks for legal clarifications from the Commission. 

Rather than the procedure being proposed, Malta believes that a better option to ensure real sustainability would have been to base decisions on a scientific study that identifies the requirements of the sector in a factual and objective manner.

Financial assistance 

While Malta agrees that in the case of an eventual entry into force of an international trade ban, seafarers and shipowners who are affected would require financial assistance, this text so far ignores the farming intermediary services, which in Malta are very significant, and represent 4.5% of the value of all country exports. One should recall that these enterprises have made considerable investments in this sector and have not been directly responsible for over-fishing of the stock. Malta maintains that deep socio-economic consequences would result for those involved in this industry if such a listing were to take place, and it, therefore, looks forward to an amended proposal that will cater for tuna farm operators. Financial assistance should be in the form of additional funds from the EU budget, since Malta could not meet its eventual compensation requirements from its current fund allocation. 

In this respect, Malta understands that aquaculture will play an ever increasing role in meeting Europe’s food requirements, and in this regard it is worth noting that Malta is a key player in pan-European research such as the SELFDOTT project. Where operators and stakeholders themselves demonstrate willingness and an interest in ensuring sustainability of this species, their needs must be taken particularly into account.

Traditional fishing practices

Malta also clarifies that its fisheries sector is small scale and uses traditional methods of fishing, targeting BFT exclusively in international waters. Therefore, the Commission’s current proposal will adversely and unfairly affect the Maltese traditional fisheries. In fact, Malta has consistently allocated its national Bluefin tuna quota to small-scale fishers. Malta believes that such practices of sustainable fishing using suitable controls should not be penalised in the event of an international trade ban, and that intra-community trade from fish caught through traditional methods should be provided for. Malta urges the Commission to revise its proposal to provide for the continuation of this fishery.

Maintaining competitiveness

Finally, Malta agrees that the European Union should exercise care to ensure that any decision taken and acted upon will not result in any loss of its competitiveness in this, and other sectors. Malta agrees with the European Union’s conviction that it should be a leader in environmental protection, and feels that it should be ensured that each decision taken should not ignore the interests of any stakeholders.

Share this Press Release Icon socials Icon socials Icon socials Icon socials

Other Press Releases:

STQARRIJA MILL-MINISTERU GĦALL-AGRIKOLTURA, IS-SAJD U L-PROVVISTA TAL-IKEL  Tittella’ r-raba’ edizzjoni ta’ Porkilicious: inizjattiva li tgħaqqad il-gastronomija u s-sostenibbiltà tal-ikel mal-appoġġ għall-Malta Community Chest Fund

PR261991

STQARRIJA MILL-MINISTERU GĦALL-AGRIKOLTURA, IS-SAJD U L-PROVVISTA TAL-IKEL ...

STQARRIJA MILL-MINISTERU GĦALL-EDUKAZZJONI U L-ISPORT  “L-intelliġenza artifiċjali għandha tkun għodda mħaddma tajjeb, filwaqt li qatt ma tista’ tieħu r-rwol fundamentali tal-edukaturi” – Il-Ministru Byron Camilleri fi Brussell

PR261990

STQARRIJA MILL-MINISTERU GĦALL-EDUKAZZJONI U L-ISPORT “L-intelliġenza arti...

More Press Releases Right arrow