Left arrow Go Back

STATEMENT BY THE HON. CARMELO MIFSUD BONNICI, MINISTER OF JUSTICE AND HOME AFFAIRS, AT THE HIGH LEVEL CONFERENCE ON THE FUTURE OF THE EUROPEAN COURT OF HUMAN RIGHTS – INTERLAKEN, SWITZERLAND – 18/19 FEBRUARY 2010

PR0292
Date Icon 19/02/2010

Mme President,

The timing of the conference is particularly significant. For 27 of our member states, the conference comes in the wake of the entry into force of the Lisbon Treaty, which paves the way for the European Union’s accession to the European Convention on Human Rights. This will inevitably have a positive impact on the system as a whole, as it will reaffirm and strengthen our commitment to the values that have transformed our continent in the last six decades.

The Court has played a fundamental role in this transformation. We are here to ensure that it will continue to do so by building upon those values which have given Europe its identity. The Court’s history, especially the past decade, proves that it is a living organism that connects with our citizens in a very concrete, direct and personal way. We had accepted the Court’s jurisdiction since 1969 but it is since 1987 that Maltese citizens have had the right of individual petition to the Court. In the course of years several Maltese have availed themselves of this right successfully. In doing so they have contributed to the further enhancement and strengthening of our democratic fabric. They have helped us venture into new legislative pastures in order to secure improvement in the procedures to safeguard those fundamental human rights based on our common Christian heritage around which our society is built.

The legal steps taken after 1987, have ensured that the judgments of our domestic courts have relied consistently on, and have received guidance and inspiration from, the judgements delivered in Strasbourg. The judgements of the European Court are in reality one the sources of our domestic law.

In addition, through its European Convention Act of 1987, my government introduced a landmark measure that has had an important bearing on facilitating the enforcement of this Court’s judgments. That Act provides for a far simpler legislative mechanism which allows us to implement faster judgments of the ECtHR delivered against Malta. I do not know if any other country has a similar provision.

We are aware, and it is a matter of concern for us, that as a direct result of its very success throughout the continent, the Court has had to face a number of serious crises. Statistics speak eloquently. My government believes that the declaration, which we shall adopt at Interlaken, offers a good basis for an adequate response. We have before us a plan which, without going into specifics, lays out concrete objectives and commits us to specific target dates.

It is a multifaceted plan that acknowledges that, for reform to be successful, it needs to be embraced by all the relevant actors. However it must be stated that we might need to resort to even far more drastic and radical measures which will truly allow a more expedited process.

It is of concern to us that the end result could end up being counter productive in two directions, with the domestic courts receiving the wrong kind of message from this court on the reasonable length of judicial proceedings and secondly that the perception is generated among our citizens that this Court is not sufficiently sensitive to the unique distinguishing cultural characteristics, which foster national identities and that diversity within unity, which is the hallmark of democracy. A case in point, in my opinion, is the recent judgement delivered in the Soile Lautsi Albertin case against Italy (30814/06).

From this perspective it is evident that the role of member states has been clearly acknowledged and given the central position it deserves. We believe that better implementation by member states of what is today accepted as jus commune contributes towards a decrease of the case load.

Measures taken at the domestic level are, in our opinion, crucial in order to reduce the number of inadmissible applications to acceptable levels. We attach great value to the principle of subsidiarity. We are pleased to see that the declaration spells this out loudly. We have to keep in mind that realities change but not always at the same pace in all places at the same time. New systems and processes need to be flexible enough to respond to new circumstances.

The Court, for its part, needs to engage in a process of reflection to arrive at proposals for a more efficient use of its resources. It is essential that we maintain clarity and consistency in case law. This is important both to reduce the number of inadmissible cases and also to safeguard the Court’s authority.

We look forward to examining in more detail, proposals for reform in the process of electing Judges. We have to ensure that member states nominate their most qualified candidates. My government has long been a strong proponent of the principle that competence should remain the dominant and overriding criterion in this regard.

Going back to the timing of this conference - the Secretary General, with the full backing of the Committee of Ministers, has launched a reform process. This offers a great opportunity. As the Secretary General has said, the organisation needs to focus on areas where it can give added value and have the greatest impact. To do this we need to seriously re-examine the decision-making process. Member states need to have a real sense of ownership of all the decisions that the organisation takes, and a strong commitment to them. This is the best way to ensure that each one of us upholds and honours its commitments. This is of utmost importance as the Court’s case law often refers to texts adopted by the Committee of Ministers.

Finally, whilst I wish once again to express my government’s commitment and full support to the process of reform being launched here at Interlaken, I believe it will prove useful to review and discuss afresh, which are the guiding values, which are the ethical principles, that should continue to inspire and underlie the interpretation of the Convention and its relevant protocols. I am sure it will turn out to be a landmark for our organisation.

Share this Press Release Icon socials Icon socials Icon socials Icon socials

Other Press Releases:

STQARRIJA MILL-MINISTERU GĦALL-AGRIKOLTURA, IS-SAJD U L-PROVVISTA TAL-IKEL  Tittella’ r-raba’ edizzjoni ta’ Porkilicious: inizjattiva li tgħaqqad il-gastronomija u s-sostenibbiltà tal-ikel mal-appoġġ għall-Malta Community Chest Fund

PR261991

STQARRIJA MILL-MINISTERU GĦALL-AGRIKOLTURA, IS-SAJD U L-PROVVISTA TAL-IKEL ...

STQARRIJA MILL-MINISTERU GĦALL-EDUKAZZJONI U L-ISPORT  “L-intelliġenza artifiċjali għandha tkun għodda mħaddma tajjeb, filwaqt li qatt ma tista’ tieħu r-rwol fundamentali tal-edukaturi” – Il-Ministru Byron Camilleri fi Brussell

PR261990

STQARRIJA MILL-MINISTERU GĦALL-EDUKAZZJONI U L-ISPORT “L-intelliġenza arti...

More Press Releases Right arrow