Left arrow Go Back

speech by the Hon. Tonio Borg,  Deputy prime Minister and Minister of Foreign Affairs at the “Seminar on Best Practices in Assisted Voluntary Return”  - VALLETTA – 9 October 2008

pr1456
Date Icon 09/10/2008

Ladies and Gentlemen,

May I first of all welcome you all and, inparticular, our foreign guests and thank you for participating in this seminar on Best Practices in Assisted Voluntary Return. Today’s seminar provides an excellent opportunity for  our countrymen, especially those concerned with migration issues, to learn from our  European and African guests about their experiences and different approaches  in the area of  voluntary return of rejected asylum seekers and irregular migrants. As total newcomers to this aspect of migration there is much we can learn from countries which have amassed considerable experience over the years.
Let me start by briefly addressing the specificand particularly difficult situation Malta is facing with regard to irregular migration. In recent years, Malta has been confronted by this new and often tragic migration phenomenon which has been particularly active in the Mediterranean area.. Since 2002, almost 11,000 irregular migrants and asylum seekers have reached our shores, most of them having never intended Malta to be their final destination. The majority of the irregular migrants in Malta originate from sub-Saharan African countries, such as Somalia, Eritrea, Ethiopia and Sudan.
When they left their countries these migrants'aim was to arrive in mainland Europe; their hopes were dented but not completely dashed by their ending up in Malta. In spite of all efforts, including those by Frontex,  the migrant population in Malta keeps increasing;  its impact  on the society and economy of Malta, one of the most densely populated countries in the world,  is being felt all over the island and creating a feeling of unease amongst our population. As our Prime Minister rightly pointed out in his recent address to the United Nations General assembly,  “it is extremely difficult for us to continue to carry such a burden which is so acutely disproportionate to the size of the country and its population”.
The situation calls for urgent action. What areour options in dealing with this situation? Of course we do our best to integrate as many of these migrants as we can. But a small and overpopulated island like Malta has a limited absorbative capacity and is not in a position  to provide enough jobs, shelter and social services for the large numbers of migrants arriving on our shores every month.
Therefore we have repeatedly called upon  ourEuropean partners, as well as on other countries and UNHCR to acknowledge Malta’s specific situation and to take action towards a concerted  response to the problem in the spirit of  solidarity and true burden-sharing. To date a few European countries as well as the USA, have come forward with offers to take a limited number of migrants from Malta, and we are grateful for this assistance, but the response has been well below expectations.
The decision by European Home Affairs Ministersa few days ago, to entrench the principle of burden-sharing in the proposed migration pact provides us with a welcome and none-too-soon sigh of relief  and we look forward to ratification of the Ministers' recommendation on burden-sharing when the European Heads of Governments meet later this month..
Burden sharing, when it comes into effect, willdefinitely lighten our present burden, but will not wave goodbye, once and for all, to the problem.  The rate at which the number of irregular migrants in Malta is increasing means that we have to look also at other methods for the reduction in number of irregular migrants to a manageable size.
Besides integration and burden-sharing, a thirdoption for dealing with the situation  is to take a firm stand against irregular migration and insist on the expeditious repatriation of immigrants who have come to Malta illegally or do not satisfy the requirements for protection under the Geneva Convention. Credible  return policies are key elements to effective migration management and control. A state has to be in a position not only  to decide whether a foreign national is legally entitled to remain on its territory or not but also  to be in a position to actually enforce the removal, if that person does not leave of his or her own accord.
Because of the reluctance of many irregularmigrants to return to their home countries, we know that we have to pursue a policy of enforced returns, painful as they are. But irregular migrants in Malta who have double rejection do not necessarily have to leave Malta in such a manner. We offer them an alternative which is much more migrant-friendly, and that is Assisted Voluntary Return (AVR).  This is what project DAR is about - a return in dignity to one's home country, with advice and assistance pre-departure and post-arrival, as well as some cash, so that the returnees can re-integrate themselves quickly in their societies and can look forward to a brighter future. DAR, which has found political and financial support from the European Union, is a pilot project, and therefore a starting point for voluntary returns from Malta, several of which have already taken place in recent months.. But DAR is also laying the groundwork for other AVR programmes which will follow it and its experiences will help us develop the necessary structures and policies for successful Voluntary Returns in the future.
European States as well as countries of originof irregular migrants have a clear preference for voluntary return. In recent years, several countries have invested considerable time and effort in developing tailor-made  Assisted Voluntary Return  policies and packages which take  into account both the situation in countries of origin and the needs of individual returnees. By strongly supporting the individuals in all the various stages of  return, these policies  make return more respectful and responsive to the dignity and integrity of the returnees,  increase the degree of sustainability of return measures and, last but not least,  make return processes more cost effective.
No matter how attractive an AVR package is theimplementation of AVR is far from being an easy one, with challenges all along the way, starting from that of gaining the trust of returnees, and their consent to taking up AVR,  to the identification of the true identity and nationality of the potential returnee,  the cooperation of the authorities in the countries of origin through identification processes and release of travel documents.
Malta is a newcomer to Assisted Voluntary Returnand we are building our voluntary return policies from scratch. The project DAR and the development of its return and re-integration programme have benefited a lot from the experience and know-how which today's speakers and their colleagues have shared with us, and I want to take the opportunity to thank them again for the hospitality and spirit of cooperation with which the members of the project team have been welcomed during their working visits last autumn.
We know that we have to find our own way inbuilding effective return policies tailored to our specific conditions and we have to adapt foreign systems to our situation but there is no dount that the information gleaned from these educational visits has provided with a strong basis from which to start. We are of course on a learning curve and we will commit some mistakes along the way but we are determined to  reach our target in the end.
Before I conclude this short address I shouldlike to thank the speakers present here today and their governments for their readiness to provide advice and other assistance whenever required. I should also like to single out the Embassies of Ghana, Sudan and Nigeria for their cooperation in the identification of their nationals and the issue of travel documents whenever asked.  I would also like to express my appreciation of the contribution of our partners, SOS Malta and Med-Europe towards the successful start of the programme, and to a large number of entities which, although not official partners, form part of the extensive DAR network built in the past few months and which provide assistance whenever required. These include the Ministry of Justice and Home Affairs, the Police, the Armed Forces, our agency for migrant integration OIWAS, Suret il-Bniedem, IOM, the Emigrants' Commission, the Refugee Commissioner and the Employment and Training Corporation.- I apologize if I have inadvertently left anybody out.

I encourage all of you to take the opportunity of today’s seminar to further deepen your knowledge on AVR through dialoguing with the speakers. I also hope that through their presence, this seminar will also secure a  further strengthening of the excellent relations already established with the various countries here represented .

I thank you once again for your presence here today and hope you will find this seminar both enjoyable and instructive.

Share this Press Release Icon socials Icon socials Icon socials Icon socials

Other Press Releases:

PRESS RELEASE BY THE MINISTRY FOR HOME AFFAIRS AND SECURITY  Minister Bedingfield stresses the importance of prevention and cooperation in strengthening fire safety

PR261981en

PRESS RELEASE BY THE MINISTRY FOR HOME AFFAIRS AND SECURITY Minister Bedin...

STQARRIJA MILL-MINISTERU GĦALL-INTERN U S-SIGURTÀ  Il-Ministru Bedingfield jisħaq fuq l-importanza tal-prevenzjoni u l-kollaborazzjoni biex tissaħħaħ is-sigurtà kontra n-nirien

PR261981

STQARRIJA MILL-MINISTERU GĦALL-INTERN U S-SIGURTÀ Il-Ministru Bedingfield ...

More Press Releases Right arrow