Left arrow Mur Lura

Speech by the Hon. Tonio Fenech, Parliamentary Secretary IN the ministry of Finance, at a workshop ‘Making public procurement work for Innovation’ – valletta – 14 may 2007

PR0706
Date Icon 14/05/2007

Permanent Secretaries, Chairpersons,

Dear Participants

 The Government last July adopted a comprehensive strategy to place research and innovation at the heart of the economy.  The Strategy proposed a series of measures, 66 in all, directed at creating both the demand and supply for research and innovation thus assisting in attaining this vision.  One of the supply measures that the Strategy proposed is the adoption of innovative public procurement.

I am pleased to be here today to launch the first of a series of workshops that my Ministry, through the Contracts Division, together with the Malta Council of Science and Technology is undertaking to instill the application of innovation through procurement within government and the public sector.

The basis of today’s workshop is to introduce innovative procurement.  The goal of the programme that is being launched today is to establish a pro-active culture within government for the application of innovation procurement.  The Contracts Division and MCST are seeking to achieve this through the holding of a series of workshops directed at various stakeholders within government on key matters relating to the innovative procurement process, developing guidelines and best-practice methodologies.

Innovative procurement stems from two fundamental premises. 

First, Public Procurement – in whatever jurisdiction accounts for between 15% to 18% of GDP.  This is no mean statistic.  It implies that Government has the necessary purchasing clout to shape and determine the type of products and services that it requires.  It is pertinent to note that, historically, public procurement has played a strategic and often critical role in promoting the development of a particular technology area or industry. This has often led or resulted in the country gaining a regional/global strength and competitive advantage in the sector. Public investments in the defense industry in the US and other countries, for example, have led to important spin-offs in terms of civilian applications of the technology developed.

In Germany, public investments in the chemical industry played an equally important role.   Although we will never have the financial muscle to enter into these areas of investments, clearly we can still make our contribution toward innovation in other areas, particularly energy, ICT, and other area that I hope you will manage to identify during the course of your discussions.

However for this to happen, we need to imbue a culture for innovation, through which public procurement will demand innovation.  Too often, we tend to apply public procurement as a transactional matter rather than as a strategic leverage to transform what we do, how we go about matters.  In doing so we tend to design tenders on specifications of what we know exists as against outcomes that we should strive to achieve. 

Invariably specification led public procurement to limit opportunities to the business communities to provide innovative solutions.  Most often in undertaking public procurement we shy away from dialogue and discussion with industry – the channel of communications being established through the iron-clad specifications set, which if not met, even if a better solution is provided, disqualify bidders, as solutions are restrained within the straight-jacket of the specifications set.

Innovative procurement demands a culture shift – one that requires the placement of procurement as a key cornerstone of the strategic orientation of the organisation, as against a mere transactional matter; one that seeks open discussion and dialogue with suppliers as against a black box approach; one that seeks solutions that address outcomes, key performance indicators, outputs as against defacto pre-defined solutions based on specifications.

Innovative procurement shifts the paradigms of procurement as we have understood it to be.  It brings with it new challenges:  how do you design the outputs and Key Performance Indicators? How do you adjudicate?  How do you control and manage the supplier?  What happens if the innovative solution fails?

Whilst recognition has been reached by the EU and nation states that traditional procurement is restraining innovation, the search of the right approaches and methodologies to innovative procurement is in its infancy.  Nevertheless, as will be shown by the Director General of Contracts, it is pertinent to underline that following the reform of EU procurement rules in 2004 mechanisms that enable innovative procurement are available. 

Two pathways are indeed present today – Negotiated Tendering, and Competitive Dialogue.  To a large degree, one can argue that the tools to apply innovative procurement are already in place.  To date, and not only in Malta, the application of these mechanisms has been negligible.

There may be a number of reasons, but I will only touch on three.  Firstly innovative procurement involves a major paradigm shift in thinking, requiring not only strong procurement and contracts design organisational support and skills but also knowledge and understanding of a new business approach.  It is a business approach that must be understood not only by the executive of the entity but also by the technical employees involved in the identification of the solution sought. 

As the presentation by MITTS Ltd will show, the major difficulty in the application of innovative procurement was not lack of strategic vision or leadership by the company’s Board but internal resistance:  stemming primarily from the fear by its staff of loss of control over the solution to be provided.

Secondly, innovative procurement requires strategic forward thinking.  The process to achieve innovative procurement may take longer due to the discussions that are necessary between the purchaser and the innovative supplier.  It thus means that launching bids for innovative solutions must a priori factor the time elements within the procurement process.

Thirdly, the business community must be prepared for innovative procurement.  At times we tend to be too harsh on ourselves when compared to the private sector.  Yet, the private sector too faces a culture shift of the way it sells its products.  To a large degree, I would say that the private sector itself is yet not prepared – generally speaking – to embrace innovative procurement.  As the MITTS Ltd example will show, the multi-nationals involved struggled to respond to its innovative procurement request as this ‘did not fit their business model’:  in the ICT world they still prefer to sell boxes then solutions, let alone innovative ones.

It is important for me to add that innovation procurement is not the panacea for all procurement; or that so called ‘traditional’ type of procurement is no longer relevant.  What I am stating is that procurement is strategic, and that every organisation should strategically assess the options available to them prior to embarking on a procurement process.  And innovative procurement is one of those options that should be strategically assessed particularly in matters that relate to technology, environment, energy.

The process that we have embarked upon today is one of awareness building on innovation procurement as a strategic tool and option.  It is a process that the Malta Council for Science and Technology and Contracts Division will jointly carry out through such seminars, dissemination of documentation, lessons and experiences, etc.

I look forward to the results of this workshop and to the introduction of a wider application of innovative procurement in Malta.

Ixxerja din l-istqarrija Icon socials Icon socials Icon socials Icon socials

Stqarrijiet Oħra:

STQARRIJA MILL-MINISTERU GĦAL GĦAWDEX  Fin-Norveġja, il-Ministru Clint Camilleri jsostni li s-suċċess tal-Istrateġija Ewropea għall-Gżejjer se jitkejjel mir-riżultati li twassal

PR261964

STQARRIJA MILL-MINISTERU GĦAL GĦAWDEX Fin-Norveġja, il-Ministru Clint Cami...

PRESS RELEASE BY SERVIZZ.GOV  International Recognition for Servizz.gov and Centrecom

PR261963en

PRESS RELEASE BY SERVIZZ.GOV International Recognition for Servizz.gov and...

Aktar Stqarrijiet Right arrow