Speech by the Hon. Dolores Cristina, Minister for the Family and Social Solidarity during the Conference entitled: A MEDITERRANEAN WITHOUT HANDICAP: TOWARDS A NEW HUMANISM – ETHICS AND DISABILITY – Floriana - 25th April 2007
It gives me great pleasure to be here today, and to add some thoughts on the conclusion of the deliberations of this Congress.
The ambition of this conference to begin the articulation of a ‘new humanism’, and the grandness of the ideal, at first glance seems to compete with the importance of finding practical measures to spread the best expert knowledge on the care of the disabled to the disabled themselves and to those others who live and work with them. And yet, on closer reflection, the idea of developing a new humanism may have the right measure of the challenge before those of us involved in making the world a more inclusive, accessible place for the disabled.
Paradoxically, humanism often uses language and images that appear to privilege the most able people over the less. It is true that making ideals out of rationality, autonomy and independence does not necessarily exclude those of us who are in some way disabled; it may make us more determined to see that, as much as possible, people with physical or mental disability can be empowered to participate in the pursuit of these ideals. Humanism provides the backdrop against which disability does not become a destiny of powerlessness and lack of human dignity.
It is a useful corrective to a certain tendency in popular culture, more evident in the past than today around the Mediterranean, to think of disability as moral punishment for the sins of the parents and ancestors.
In the Semitic religions, Judaism, Christianity and Islam, however, the Mediterranean has hosted an alternative tradition of humanism. In this tradition, rationality is also prized, as a path to God, lord of all creatures. But the sense of being a creature qualified the idea of autonomy and independence. In an important way, human beings are seen to be both rational and radically dependent animals – dependent on their Creator, in the first place, but also dependent on their fellow human beings for their salvation.
It is not as a religious believer but as a politician, with the portfolio for the national care of the disabled, that I approach this theme of human beings who are essentially both rational and dependent. It seems to me that a humanism concerned with the care and inclusion of the disabled in mainstream society will need to address two kinds of truth: first, the truths of science and technology, discovered by the use of scientific reason; second, the truths of interpersonal relations, discovered in company and friendship.
For the second kind of truth, the realisation that all of us are dependent on each other, in some way, is key. I believe it is this realisation that dawns on many able people, when they start out caring for the severely disabled in the spirit of simply wanting to help, but end up realising that the relationship is shining a light on themselves, perhaps on previously unacknowledged needs and feelings.
When such people say, as they often do, that they thought they set out to give but ended up receiving more, it is not humbug. What they are trying to express, I believe, is that in practising inclusivity with others, they found they were giving space to parts of themselves that they previously had marginalised: the disabled can help the able develop their potential.
If we can find a way of harnessing these two kinds of truth to policy making, then I believe we will be on our way to developing an ethos that helps the disabled to live a dignified life and to fulfil their potential, as is their right; such an ethos would also help the rest of us, more or less able, to realise as much as is possible of ourselves.
A policy imbued with such an ethos would need three elements. The first two can be adopted on a national level. Indeed, the government I am part of has been concerned with them for almost two decades.
In the first instance, the best use of the available science, medicine and technology must be made to empower the disabled – to render them as autonomous and independent as possible. Where it can be done, every effort must be made to shift from compensating the individual for some disability, to helping him or her overcome that disability and gain access and inclusion to mainstream society. This will not always be possible, admittedly, but keeping the target in mind will help keep the ambition from slipping.
In the second place, care is often best entrusted to the community – to helpers who are family members or voluntary groups who are bound to the disabled by values and relationships that are above and beyond the task of nursing and caring.
This is not an argument for the state to give up its responsibility for welfare; it is an argument for saying that the state should, where possible, help and empower family members and voluntary groups to administer care themselves. The best care occurs within the context of far richer relationships, of mutual giving; it is not easy for the state, with its necessarily bureaucratic apparatus, to replicate such relationships itself, even with the best efforts of its dedicated personnel.
The third element goes beyond the national level and looks at the regional. In a globalised world, true inclusivity requires that the disabled are able to be integrated, as much as possible, into the wider world; they should be empowered to be as mobile as possible. But how achievable is this as a goal in the Mediterranean?
There is, in fact, a lot of potential for development. The Mediterranean is a sea of cultural differences. It has an inherent pluralism, which is sometimes blamed for some of the longstanding conflicts in the region. However, there is a shared ethos, common to all three Semitic religions of the area, which recognises the fraternity of all people, whatever their abilities and qualities. This ethos may provide the basis for developing the various welfare societies into a welfare region, especially where the care of the disabled is concerned.
Two steps would need to be taken to secure such regional development. First, there would need to be a degree of harmonisation of the standards of spatial access, in urbanised zones particularly, that is offered across the region. This would ensure that the mobility and dialogues of peoples does not discriminate against the disabled.
Second, there needs to be institutional cooperation across the region to guarantee the standard of care that can be offered across state borders. Such institutional cooperation would need to involve not just state facilities, but also different voluntary groups. Methods of transferring payments, or of reciprocated services, would need to be arranged, too. Stated this way, it seems almost impossibly ambitious. But stated in another way what it aims to offer the disabled is the kind of ‘roaming arrangements’ with which we already regale our mobile phones! That does not sound a lot to ask for.
The ambition is worth pursuing for its own sake; however, there is another reason that gives it further importance. In the conflict-ridden Mediterranean, such institutionalised solidarity across state and cultural boundaries can serve as a model for a wider solidarity between all the peoples of the region. Indeed, it can serve not only as a model, but also as a means for achieving such solidarity. One of the rays of hope that shines in the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, for example, is a network of mothers, both Israeli and Palestinian, who join forces to protest against some of the insane extremism tearing their lands and their lives apart; out of their wounds and their heartache, they have developed a model and a means of building solidarity across borders.
If such means can be found amid death and the senseless carnage of the young, then how much more hope is there that the care for the disabled, carried out in a regional manner, according to an ethos shared across cultures, will lead to a new humanism in conflicted territories? Practising inclusivity with the apparently disabled can bring the apparently able to recognise some of their own disabling modes of living, and to see that there is a more inclusive, humanistic way of living with everyone.Stqarrijiet Oħra:
PR261959en
PRESS RELEASE BY THE OFFICE OF THE SPEAKER The Speaker of the House of Rep...
PR261959